Falcon_77
04-08-08, 09:04 PM
Assuming that Google gets its way and persuades the FCC to allow White-Space Devices (WSD's) (assuming the prototypes "pass" the tests), I just realized another serious problem.
If we can cast aside doubts about adjacent channel interference (which I can't do) and a myriad of other concerns, it seems that even a 1W WSD within a few hundred feet would be enough to overload most pre-amps.
Can anyone run some simulations on how far away even a single WSD would need to be to not overload a typical pre-amp?
Since pre-amps are typically used in fringe areas for TV reception, would these areas essentially be giving up TV reception to get the Internet from a WSD?
Some have proposed that White-Space devices (if ever allowed) would need to be band-limited. I agree with this (if they must be allowed at all). However, the only area that seems suitable is Low-VHF. Something tells me that Google wouldn't be very excited at the prospect of WSD's having 5-8' antennas.
If we can cast aside doubts about adjacent channel interference (which I can't do) and a myriad of other concerns, it seems that even a 1W WSD within a few hundred feet would be enough to overload most pre-amps.
Can anyone run some simulations on how far away even a single WSD would need to be to not overload a typical pre-amp?
Since pre-amps are typically used in fringe areas for TV reception, would these areas essentially be giving up TV reception to get the Internet from a WSD?
Some have proposed that White-Space devices (if ever allowed) would need to be band-limited. I agree with this (if they must be allowed at all). However, the only area that seems suitable is Low-VHF. Something tells me that Google wouldn't be very excited at the prospect of WSD's having 5-8' antennas.