Blu-ray Discs: Reviewer's Recommendations [Text View]

View Full Version : Blu-ray Discs: Reviewer's Recommendations

Pages : [1] 2

Ralph Potts

06-07-08, 02:28 PM

Greetings,

I have put together a list of Blu-ray Discs that I consider to be top notch in audio, video or both audio/video quality. There are four categories as I included a list of personal favorites as well. Some I have formally reviewed and some are in my collection but I have not reviewed them. These are not meant to be completely comprehensive lists. I wanted to offer readers a chance to check out some Blu-ray discs that in my opinion look and sound great. I will add new discs to these lists as I come across them and will make note of that in future reviews.

Have fun !

Audio:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112238&d=1212770998http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112236&d=1212770992http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112248&d=1212771102http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112255&d=1212771612http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112394&d=1212859851
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112231&d=1212770937http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112240&d=1212771039http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112243&d=1212771049http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112258&d=1212772485http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112382&d=1212859735
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112384&d=1212859748http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112389&d=1212859802http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112252&d=1212771552http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112401&d=1212875343http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=113686&d=1214248168
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=113687&d=1214248168http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=117680&d=1219596287http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=170203&d=1268744970http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=174507&d=1272742684http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=175896&d=1274190680
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=177387&d=1275825250http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=193955&d=1292186815http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=208138&d=1302178900http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=208139&d=1302178994http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=223733&d=1317056960

Here are a few quotes from some of my reviews:

Ice age: "The quality of the Dolby Digital soundtrack on the DVD release of Ice age was considered by many to be great demo material. Well the DTS-HD 5.1 channel Master Lossless track on this blu-ray disc takes it to another level entirely."

Master and Commander: "This is a powerfully engaging audio mix that will test the limits of your audio system."

Cloverfield: "This in an aggressive and invigorating surround mix that incorporates a plethora of aurally stimulating effects to create a captivating and sometimes frightening listening experience."

Hitman: "Man, this is a great mix ! Bass fans will love its aggressive low end and those who appreciate genre films like this that kick butt and take names are in for a real treat."

Rambo:"Gunfire and explosions had a tactile and dynamic impact that could be felt from any point in the room. The rich and immersive quality of the audio enhanced the experience to a higher level of realism".

The Nightmare Before Christmas: "This was truly one of the most enjoyable audio demonstrations I have had in my theater room."

Terminator Salvation: "The listening position is submerged into a 360 degree web of sound that is sometimes riveting as it bombards the senses with a combination of discretely placed near field and panning sound effects."

Tron: Legacy: "The action based sequences rock as the room is transformed into a three dimensional soundstage that pulsates with room energizing bass that attains room shaking levels."

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1: "This is a wonderfully involving and dynamically energized sound design that features high level sonic detail, superb directional correlation, seamless integration, and rhythmically charged bass extension that is sure to stimulate the senses."

Video:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112254&d=1212771561http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112225&d=1212770877http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112233&d=1212770946http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112242&d=1212771049http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112227&d=1212770888
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112228&d=1212770888http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112235&d=1212770992http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112226&d=1212770877http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112245&d=1212771093http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112261&d=1212775756
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112380&d=1212859735http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112387&d=1212859789http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=116657&d=1218580192http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=117838&d=1219781661http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=118807&d=1220476543
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=120325&d=1222092179http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=124463&d=1226779505http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=170200&d=1268743483

Here are a few quotes from some of my reviews:

A passage to India: "Detail was first rate with excellent resolve and fine minutia which was easily detectable from almost every perspective."

The Water Horse: "At times I found the visual style to be breath taking. The beautiful locations used in the film looked absolutely stunning in high definition."

No Country For Old Men: "Whether in the desert or within the limit’s of a small town image quality was delivered with superb resolve and an almost endless depth of field."

Gattaca: "Fleshtones appear natural and due to the great resolve of the video reveal the finest gradations in the varying tones from person to person. Blacks are deep, dynamic, and extended."

Nim's Island: "Detail is exquisite as it delivers intricate and subtle textures with near flawless execution. It didn’t leave me wanting for better image penetration as it revealed the three dimensional depth and clear perception of nearly everything that passed into the camera’s view".

The Fall: "Bolder use of contrast and bright vivid colors helped to propel images to an elevated level of vibrancy and three dimensional quality that was unwavering. Images were impeccably detailed with fine articulation and visual acuity that seemed infinite when looking at long panning shots."

Kill Bill Vol. 1: "Images have a sparkling clarity that makes them visually enticing. Detail is impeccable from nearly every perspective which allows clear perception of the various elements within each frame".

Speed Racer: "This is a stylized video presentation that boasts a broad color palette that features beautifully lush pastels and vibrant hues that are vivid, bold and look incredible in high definition. The video has a wide dynamic range with deep, inky blacks and excellent shadow detail. The video had a consistently razor sharp quality that left images looking pristinely resolved with flawless rendering of fine detail."

Audio & Video:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112383&d=1212859748http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112224&d=1212770877http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112229&d=1212770937http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112230&d=1212770937http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112232&d=1212770946
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112234&d=1212770992http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112237&d=1212770998http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112239&d=1212771039http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112241&d=1212771039http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112244&d=1212771093
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112246&d=1212771093http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112247&d=1212771102http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112250&d=1212771552http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112251&d=1212771552http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112253&d=1212771561
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112256&d=1212771612http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112400&d=1212875343http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112403&d=1212878320http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112527&d=1213002791http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=117383&d=1219262901
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=120324&d=1222092179http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=124465&d=1226779903http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=124462&d=1226779505http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=126750&d=1229205654http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=126751&d=1229205654
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=131570&d=1233152490http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=134789&d=1235653797http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=136422&d=1236862683http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=138012&d=1238178052http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=138013&d=1238178052
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=140274&d=1240218234http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=143184&d=1242769558http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=148102&d=1248020315http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157887&d=1257952306http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157888&d=1257952306
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157889&d=1257952306http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=170204&d=1268744970http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=171008&d=1269354353http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=171009&d=1269354353http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=173835&d=1272125836
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=185281&d=1284056965http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=190185&d=1288898744http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=192888&d=1291227874http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=192889&d=1291227874http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=208136&d=1302178867
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=208135&d=1302178867http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=223731&d=1317056949

Here are a few quotes from some of my reviews:

The Chronicles of Narina: "This is a first rate video presentation that is near flawless." "The audio presentation is superbly crafted and offers a diverse representation of the things that we as listeners look for in a good audio mix."

I, Robot: "Inky noise free blacks, superb shadow detail with high delineation, an eye popping visual design, along with vibrant colors and beautiful flesh tone reproduction." " There is enough sub 30 hz bass contained in this track to keep bass heads happy. The chase scene in the tunnel is delivered with room shaking authority as it drives the entire system to create an immersive and ultra rich surround sound experience."

Jumper: "The scenes shot in Italy at the Coliseum were visually arresting as images were razor sharp with incredible dimensional depth and lifelike texture." "This is an aggressive mix that contains demonstration level material that will test just how good your system can sound."

Saawariya : " Every detail is clearly audible within the mix which rests on a cushion of crystal clear sound that ebbs and flows with precision." "There is a plethora of colors in various tones and hues that look simply stunning in high definition. Flesh tones are highlighted by the beautiful complexions of the cast and come across with succulence and subtle texture."

Transformers: "Images exhibited high level detail, razor sharpness and resolute definition that brought out the lifelike textures captured by the camera. Dimensional perspective had an infinite appeal that was visually arresting at times. ""This is an aurally stimulating sound design that is truly capable of creating a thrilling home theater experience."

Iron man: "I appreciated the attention to detail that enabled even seemingly small background sounds and effects to be distinctly audible. This is an aggressive surround mix that makes extensive use of the entire sound platform.""Resolution is excellent as images are well detailed, vibrant and dimensionally proportionate. Close up camera shots are particularly striking at times and reveal lots of fine minutia and visible nuance."

The Incredibles: "The quality of the images onscreen can be visually arresting. Detail and definition is impeccably rendered as images have a resplendent and sparkling clarity that is appreciably three dimensional. This lossless soundtrack earns of perfect technical rating and improves upon the lossy Dolby Digital version in every way. This is not an aggressive or action style sound mix but its ability to deliver a visceral home theater experience is not to be underestimated."

Personal Favorites & Guilty Pleasures:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112381&d=1212859735http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112385&d=1212859789http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112386&d=1212859789http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112388&d=1212859802http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112390&d=1212859839
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112391&d=1212859839http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112392&d=1212859839http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112393&d=1212859851http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112395&d=1212859888http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112396&d=1212859888
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112402&d=1212878320http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112404&d=1212878320http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=112776&d=1213205496http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=116658&d=1218580192http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=124461&d=1226779505
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=124464&d=1226779512http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=126752&d=1229205654http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=131571&d=1233152966http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=136421&d=1236862683http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=136420&d=1236862683
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=140273&d=1240218234http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157890&d=1257952328http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157891&d=1257952328http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157892&d=1257952713http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157893&d=1257952713
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=157894&d=1257952713http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=170201&d=1268743483http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=170202&d=1268743483http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=173837&d=1272126839http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=185278&d=1284056435
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=190183&d=1288898744http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=190184&d=1288898744http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=190186&d=1288898758http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=208134&d=1302178867http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=208137&d=1302178900
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=223730&d=1317056949http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/attachment.php?attachmentid=223732&d=1317056949

Well that wraps things up. As I said this is not meant to be a comprehensive list but rather food for thought. Be sure to check back as the list will be updated. I would love to hear from others regarding their own favorites as well.

*Here at AVS the membership has assembled The PQ Tier Thread (http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?p=10733385#post10733385) and Audio Quality Tier Thread (http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=918734) which is a rated list of top quality Blu-ray Discs. These lists are great resources. You can check them out by clicking on the links.

Cheers,

Stix2

06-07-08, 04:08 PM

You need more movies to watch there is a ton better than those. Especially audio. For example. Pan lab and the orphanage. Audio excellence

shadowrage

06-07-08, 04:21 PM

Thank you for this thread. Now when people ask "New to blu what to buy?" They can just look here.

There's just one problem. Where is the king of Audio/Video (that just happens to be a good film) - Black Hawk Down?;)

I've been looking for an excuse to buy Ultraviolet.:o Sweet.

Ralph Potts

06-07-08, 04:45 PM

Greetings,

Thanks for your posts. As I stated this is not meant to be a comprehensive total list but simply to offer some discs that were strong contenders in their catagories.

I absolutely agree with Black Hawk Down. I have not seen The Orphanage.

Regards,

krholmberg

06-07-08, 05:12 PM

My top three are on your list... Black Hawk Down, Apocalypto and POTC DMC. My guilty pleasure is Casino Royale. I like to use the chase scene at the beginning to show off my theater to others.

wvasko

06-07-08, 05:41 PM

Ralph
Independence Day/Hidalgo/Extraordinary Gentleman are among my favorites. Have you posted a review on them. Are they to be compared with Narnia. Please say it's so, the scenery shots with Hidalgo could be breathtaking.

JohnnytheSkin

06-07-08, 05:51 PM

No love for Disney/Pixar? 'Ratatouille' is fantastic, and the bright, vivid colors of 'Meet the Robinsons' are video standouts as well.

Ralph Potts

06-07-08, 05:57 PM

Greetings,

I added Black Hawk Down as I definitely overlooked it.:o

I also added The Patriot for the same reason.

Ralph
Independence Day/Hidalgo/Extraordinary Gentleman are among my favorites. Have you posted a review on them. Are they to be compared with Narnia. Please say it's so, the scenery shots with Hidalgo could be breathtaking.

I reviewed Hidalgo and ID4 prior to coming to AVS. Hidalgo was an 86 Audio and 88 Video for a total of 86. ID4 was an 84 Audio and 82 Video for a total of 83. I will probably watch ID4 again in the near future and see if my impression is any different. The League of EG would be more comparable to Hidalgo.

Cheers,

Ralph Potts

06-07-08, 06:00 PM

No love for Disney/Pixar? 'Ratatouille' is fantastic, and the bright, vivid colors of 'Meet the Robinsons' are video standouts as well.

Greetings,

Absolutely but I have not seen either of them on Blu-ray so I couldn't add them to my list. There is no reason why they can't be highlighted in this thread though.

Ratatouille & Meet the Robinsons

Cheers,

Stix2

06-07-08, 06:09 PM

By all means give the orphanage a listen. Best sounding movie I have ever heard. Everyone who has come to watch it has been just awestruck with the sound.

I did not know this was a starter list forgive my....now that i look back and reread it rude comment.... Was not really intended as such. My bd

It makes most movies sound like sdvd. A new standard for 2008.

shawn784

06-07-08, 06:26 PM

Greetings,

Absolutely but I have not seen either of them on Blu-ray so I couldn't add them to my list. There is no reason why they can't be highlighted in this thread though.

Ratatouille & Meet the Robinsons

Cheers,

yeah i agree ratatouille looks stunning and sounds amazing.

it is in tier 0 on both the pq and sq thread here.

Ralph Potts

06-07-08, 06:43 PM

Blacknight5000

06-07-08, 08:30 PM

Hi Ralph,

Thanks for the lists above. Also for the reviews you are posting. Love the template used and your writing style.

Your reviews have really been a great addition to the site. :)

Ralph Potts

06-07-08, 08:44 PM

Hi Ralph,

Thanks for the lists above. Also for the reviews you are posting. Love the template used and your writing style.

Your reviews have really been a great addition to the site. :)

Greetings,

Thanks much Blacknight5000 and welcome to AVS ! :)

Regards,

Adz523

06-07-08, 09:44 PM

Ralph,
In terms of video and audio quality, you have to demo/review Elton John's 6oth Birthday Bash at MSG. Its the best concert video I have ever seen. The "live" quality of it is stunning.

mattr762

06-07-08, 11:21 PM

Ralph,
How about including a list of blu-ray's NOT to buy because of sound/video quality. A movie we might already own on dvd but the quality is not good enough to upgrade to blu-ray.

FremontRich

06-07-08, 11:30 PM

I agree on Black Hawk Down... superb video and audio.

adidino

06-07-08, 11:47 PM

I'm surpised I am Legend is not on the list. The audio is top notch in my opinion.

lgans316

06-08-08, 01:27 AM

Good list Ralph. Nice to find out that I own many of them.

shadowrage

06-08-08, 02:24 AM

Greetings,

I added Black Hawk Down as I definitely overlooked it.:o

It's ok. You get everything else right, mostly. And your score for ID4 was right on.
BTW - Shoot Em' Up is another all around standout for Audio and Video. So is The Orphanage. As is Pan's Labyrinth(DNR, not that bad). Hairspray too.

I agree on Black Hawk Down... superb video and audio.

Just wait for the DC with highbrate AVC and 24 bit audio.:eek: It's hard to believe there is room for some improvement, luckily there's a another cut so Sony can re-do it.

I'm surpised I am Legend is not on the list. The audio is top notch in my opinion.

As far as accuracy is concerned it is, but there's really only 2 stand out LFE moments. But they are stand out. My biggest gripe is that the Shelby Mustang doesn't sound as sinister as anything labeled Shelby should sound.

aforkosh

06-08-08, 03:27 AM

For sound, consider Martin Scorcese's The Last Waltz. The 5.1 PCM soundtrack for this movie of The Band's farewell concert is fantastic.

Nordo

06-08-08, 05:20 AM

Thanks Ralph.
I'm still on SD discs, but I will be upgrading my projector and player when my wife lets me, so this is a great "to buy" list that I can impress her with when she finally lets me upgrade.:o

I think she'll like "Passage to India" and "Memoirs of a Geisha".:cool:
I hope she lets me buy some.:(

lgans316

06-08-08, 06:05 AM

+1 for Black Hawk Down.

Adz523

06-08-08, 06:56 AM

For sound, consider Martin Scorcese's The Last Waltz. The 5.1 PCM soundtrack for this movie of The Band's farewell concert is fantastic.

I'll check it out as compared to the Elton John MSG Blue Ray where both audio video should easily score over a 90++ as compared to the other discs listed.

BFJ 96

06-08-08, 09:30 AM

Thanks for that write-up Ralph. As someone mentioned before check-out "The Orphanage".. May I also suggest 1 of my favorites "The Host"

rnrgagne

06-08-08, 10:51 AM

I'd love to see a similar list for music Blu Ray's - Actually I'd love to see enough music Blu Rays to make a list!
Pat Metheney's The Way Up Live in DTS HD MA is the best sounding Live Concert DVD I've ever heard. It leaves me hungering for more DTS HD MA offerings.

Ralph Potts

06-08-08, 12:06 PM

Greetings,

OK so far I have the folllwing recommendations from you all:

The Orphanage
Ratatouille
Meet the Robinsons
Elton John 60th birthday bash at MSG
The last waltz

I will look to check as many of these out as I can.

I have Shoot em up and I am Legend and will spin them both again for consideration.

Ralph,
How about including a list of blu-ray's NOT to buy because of sound/video quality. A movie we might already own on dvd but the quality is not good enough to upgrade to blu-ray.

I think we will probably stick to this Matt. Going the other route would probably lead to needless debate. Thanks though.

Cheers,

Ralph Potts

06-08-08, 02:30 PM

Greetings,

I don't mean to be a dissenter here, but a lot of folks have put a lot of time in the Picture Quality and Audio Quality Tier Threads.

They are stickied in the Bluray Software section.

And quite frankly are much more useful than this thread.

Thanks Mike. This thread is no way meant to replace or interfere with that thread. I have gotten a number of requests regarding my favorite discs and thought that I would provide the answer.

I agree with you that the PQ Tier Thread is definitely the definitive reference on this site.

Regards,

Tom Monahan

06-08-08, 03:00 PM

That edge enhancement on Gattaca would keep me from putting it on a best video list but thats just me.;)

Tom

Dave Vaughn

06-08-08, 04:39 PM

Ralph,

Here is another vote for The Orphanage. Since it isn't reviewed here, I'll include a link to my review: http://ultimateavmag.com/moviereviews/042208orphanage/

Best regards,

chugmu

06-08-08, 04:46 PM

Batman Begins since its just about to be released would be a great one, I have mine on pre-order

Ralph Potts

06-08-08, 05:16 PM

kazm899

06-08-08, 09:42 PM

thanks for all your work Ralph!

i know its not a movie, but planet earth looks amazing...

The Bruiser

06-08-08, 09:45 PM

what kind of tv did you watch these on? (or projector)

blastermaster

06-09-08, 12:56 AM

I'll admit I'm not the first to jump on a movie with subtitles, but you don't even notice it's there after the first few minutes. Pan's Labyrinth is one of my favourite movies despite the subtitles. This thread is great so far and gives me ideas on which movies to show to people once I set up my dream theater. Thanks Ralph. Oh and spot on reviews imho.

Ralph Potts

06-09-08, 04:41 AM

what kind of tv did you watch these on? (or projector)

Greetings,

Sony VPL VW-50 1080p front projector.

Shoot em up has been added...

Regards,

irkuck

06-09-08, 07:02 AM

Greetings,

Sony VPL VW-50 1080p front projector.

Shoot em up has been added...
Regards,

Just out of curiosity, which movie reviewed by you got highest mark ever? I know there is little difference between, say, 94 and 95; but how close to 100 some movie has got? Can we expect a 100 showing up?

chugmu

06-09-08, 09:58 AM

A review for Sunshine would be nice too :)
I enjoy your reviews keep up the good work!

DeadDuck

06-09-08, 01:35 PM

Someone mentioned Pixar, so I thought I'd mention that I have "Ratatouille" and "Cars" and both have excellent picture quality and, so far as my untrained ears go, excellent audio as well.

I also wanted to toss a vote up for "Planet Earth". While many say that it doesn't have the best video or audio, it's quite excellent for a documentary and very fun to watch!

dla26

06-09-08, 02:04 PM

Ralph,
How about including a list of blu-ray's NOT to buy because of sound/video quality. A movie we might already own on dvd but the quality is not good enough to upgrade to blu-ray.

I'll second this request. For example, I was thinking of getting Superman: The Movie (one of my favorites from my childhood) but can't decide if it's worth it. Any others to avoid would be good to know.

Ralph Potts

06-09-08, 02:33 PM

I'll second this request. For example, I was thinking of getting Superman: The Movie (one of my favorites from my childhood) but can't decide if it's worth it. Any others to avoid would be good to know.

Greetings,

Thanks everyone for you input and feedback. I would rather not begin a list of movies to avoid. It has been my experience that this type of discussion will lead to endless debate and carry this into areas that don't belong within the spirit of this thread. The Blu-ray Software forum might be a good place to inquire about a particular disc and its strengths and weaknesses.

Thanks again.

Regards,

Ralph Potts

06-11-08, 01:36 PM

Greetings,

MiB added...:)

Cheers,

Ramrod

06-11-08, 03:09 PM

I'd have to vote for Pixar's 'Cars' as well. Everytime I watch it, I see something I've never seen before. Watching on a BDP-300 with a 46XBR-2.

Toolatecrew

06-13-08, 08:05 PM

August Rush would make my list for Audio. I was so absorbed in the audio i couldn't even give you a critcal review of the video:)

Beery

06-18-08, 11:50 PM

I'd have to disagree with Gattaca as being anywhere near good video quality. It's one of the softest images of any Blu-Ray disc in my collection and apparently they've boosted the EE in an effort to counteract this. I own both the Blu-Ray and the SD DVD and it's questionable in my mind whether the Blu-Ray has a better picture than the up-converted SD DVD version.

Franin

06-19-08, 04:55 AM

Greetings,

Thanks everyone for you input and feedback. I would rather not begin a list of movies to avoid. It has been my experience that this type of discussion will lead to endless debate and carry this into areas that don't belong within the spirit of this thread. The Blu-ray Software forum might be a good place to inquire about a particular disc and its strengths and weaknesses.

Thanks again.

Regards,

Hi Ralph,
I wonder if you will be looking at 10000BC anytime?

Thankyou

ThePrisoner

06-19-08, 07:36 AM

Ralph,

I finally received Cloverfield on Tuesday from Amazon. Wow, that is the best demo I could play for anyone who doesn't believe in lossy vs. lossless sound. Incredible. I'm also thrilled that the video is a step up.

While I was on vacation last week I snagged a copy of Live Free Or Die Hard for $15.00 too.

Ralph Potts

06-19-08, 02:25 PM

Hi Ralph,
I wonder if you will be looking at 10000BC anytime?

Thankyou

Greetings,

Frank, 10,000 BC is a Warner Blu-ray Disc release. I don't currently cover Warner Discs for review but I may pick it up. If I do I will certainly share my thoughts..:)

Ralph,

I finally received Cloverfield on Tuesday from Amazon. Wow, that is the best demo I could play for anyone who doesn't believe in lossy vs. lossless sound. Incredible. I'm also thrilled that the video is a step up.

While I was on vacation last week I snagged a copy of Live Free Or Die Hard for $15.00 too.

Glad that you enjoyed Cloverfield. If you have not seen Live free or Diehard you are in for a treat. ;)

Regards,

Tracy RainH2o

06-21-08, 11:57 AM

Ralph,

I am very disappointed that you have not watched every Blu-Ray on the planet.;););)

Keep up the good work.

Ralph Potts

06-21-08, 01:35 PM

Ralph,

I am very disappointed that you have not watched every Blu-Ray on the planet.;););)

Keep up the good work.

Greetings,

:D Thanks Tracy....

Cheers,

WOLVERNOLE

06-21-08, 01:58 PM

I enjoyed "No Country..." but I found it to be a mixed bag on video...some quite sharp, and other parts I saw as quite 480p.

Adz523

06-21-08, 07:17 PM

Ralph,

Here is another vote for The Orphanage. Since it isn't reviewed here, I'll include a link to my review: http://ultimateavmag.com/moviereviews/042208orphanage/

Best regards,

I watched The Orphanage last night. In terms of just pure sonics, the resolution of the audio is, I think, the best I've heard to date. Its that good.

I really felt like I wanted to learn fluent Spanish so I could appreciate it more.

Desert Pilot

06-21-08, 11:30 PM

Hi Ralph...thanks for your reviews. Creating a personal favorites list must be tough with so many choices (and I agree with many you have listed). But, how about Kingdom of Heaven? A great period piece, reasonably accurate historically, but most impressive is the great soundtrack.

Thanks! Marcus

Ralph Potts

06-23-08, 03:20 PM

Greetings,

I just added The Orphanage and The day after tomorrow. I recently watched The Orphanage and was impressed with its DTS-HD MA audio.

I have owned The Day after Tomorrow for some time but never heard it with decoded lossless DTS-HD Master Audio. This audio presentation always sounded good but I could not get over how much better it sounded bitstreamed from the Panasonic to the Denon. Truly reference quality stuff...:)

When I get the chance Marcus I will spin Kingdom of heaven in full DTS-MA and see what it sounds like.

Cheers,

gonzalc3

06-23-08, 09:19 PM

Ralph,

On the video side one of the most impressive presentations that I have seen is the
Bee movie.. In terms of sound is good but is not great.... Also the plot is very thin...

ThePrisoner

06-23-08, 10:43 PM

Ralph Potts

06-24-08, 04:48 AM

Ralph,

You meant to say you enjoyed the DTS-MA on The Orphanage (there is no TrueHD track):) I was blown away by that soundtrack myself. I just got done watching Live Free Or Die Hard and you were right, audio & video was a treat. The scene with the F-35 sounded amazing.

Greetings,

Thanks for the correction Marcus (so many discs !:)). I am glad that enjoyed LFODH and your right that is a great scene for audio.

Ralph,

On the video side one of the most impressive presentations that I have seen is the
Bee movie.. In terms of sound is good but is not great.... Also the plot is very thin...

Thanks Chris. I reviewed the DVD and remember that having excellent pic quality as well.

Regards,

Leo the 3rd

06-24-08, 12:46 PM

BIG ED

07-08-08, 04:56 PM

A BIG thanks, for all your hard (and hopefully enjoyable) work!

Myth

07-08-08, 07:37 PM

just received batman begins both audio and video are some of the best(if not the best)

robertc88

07-09-08, 09:24 AM

Not necessarily the best for audio or PQ but "overall", I feel all of the Pirates flicks and Pearl Harbor need to be mentioned if not already listed that I may have missed.

tom_stockham

07-11-08, 03:55 AM

Hope this is good.
http://home.woh.rr.com/tomtrent/Dirty_Harry.jpg
I hope it is not like the Wal Street Blu-Ray.

There is some hype on Amazon that Warner Home Video has done a great job with this. I will soon see for myself.

Adz523

07-13-08, 08:12 AM

Ralph,

You gotta review The Eye, if you can. Watched it last night and DTS 7.1 HD is so clean, crisp, clear with some very intense bass in every channel that overall its one of the very best sonic presentations I've heard. Video is just ok for blu-ray, although Jess Alba is more than ok.

Any update on reviewing Elton John's 60th Bday bash?

Finalheaven

07-13-08, 02:24 PM

Thank you for creating this thread. I was looking for a place to start and I got it all in one short list. Including the links to the PQ and Audio tier threads was a good move as well.

Thanks again.

Joewee

07-14-08, 02:56 PM

AVP Requiem
About the first 5 minutes is some of the best sound
quality I have heard out of a blu ray. Listening
in DTS-MA 7.1 of course.

wvasko

07-22-08, 03:23 PM

Ralph
I Robot, You may find this hard to believe but I have a Yamaha bar and woofer with optical audio hookup and even the sound is awesome. Independence Day view was good but not mind blowing as my upscale did a very good job already, It's nice to have it in my collection though. It amazes me the difference of views, that last scene with all the robots looking toward the one robot and bridge was spectacular.

Ralph Potts

07-22-08, 05:40 PM

sybidoc

07-22-08, 10:53 PM

Come on Nordo, get your testicles out of her purse and buy what you want man!

Nordo

07-23-08, 03:43 AM

Come on Nordo, get your testicles out of her purse and buy what you want man!

My wife said you shouldn't talk to me like that. Only SHE is allowed to be nasty to me.:o

Actually she's still getting over the big hole in the middle of the home theatre floor.:eek:
I've just finished building an IB (infinite baffle) sub. The only place I could mount the manifold was under the floor, with the top of the manifold opening throught the floor into the room. Amazingly clean low and infra low sound with no muddy boom.

Her opinion is "if it ain't broke (translated - if it still makes a sound or a picture), why fiddle or spend money on it ".:(

wvasko

07-23-08, 08:50 AM

My wife said you shouldn't talk to me like that. Only SHE is allowed to be nasty to me.:o

Actually she's still getting over the big hole in the middle of the home theatre floor.:eek:
I've just finished building an IB (infinite baffle) sub. The only place I could mount the manifold was under the floor, with the top of the manifold opening throught the floor into the room. Amazingly clean low and infra low sound with no muddy boom.

Her opinion is "if it ain't broke (translated - if it still makes a sound or a picture), why fiddle or spend money on it ".:(
Nordo
Wait a minute, How could we possibly be married to the same woman.

Nordo

07-23-08, 05:40 PM

Nordo
Wait a minute, How could we possibly be married to the same woman.
My understanding is our wifes are normal.:(

Obviously sybidoc is a lucky bachelor.:mad:
Should we tell him what's in store for him, or let him find out the hard way?;)

hooinsider

07-30-08, 09:43 AM

that is great.
but who can tell me where can buy that dvd cheap?

DJ Matt

08-12-08, 06:51 AM

Big request here, but if you have the time, money and are up to it, please review season 3 of Prison Break (13 episodes).

Ralph Potts

08-12-08, 10:00 AM

Big request here, but if you have the time, money and are up to it, please review season 3 of Prison Break (13 episodes).

Greetings,

Matt, Fox sent it to me late last week. I have already started it...:)

Cheers,

wvasko

08-12-08, 02:43 PM

My understanding is our wifes are normal.:(

Obviously sybidoc is a lucky bachelor.:mad:
Should we tell him what's in store for him, or let him find out the hard way?;)
Nordo
I'm not going to say a word about our wives. I just think there are some things in life a man got learn, what a man got learn. Let's just give him future condolences.

Nordo

08-12-08, 05:24 PM

Nordo
I'm not going to say a word about our wives. I just think there are some things in life a man got learn, what a man got learn. Let's just give him future condolences.
;)

DJ Matt

08-12-08, 05:34 PM

Greetings,

Matt, Fox sent it to me late last week. I have already started it...:)

Cheers,
Thanks! Cool, sounds good. Season 3 is not as good as the first 2 seasons, but still worth a watch.

Ralph Potts

08-12-08, 06:37 PM

Greetings,

Added a few more...:)

Cheers,

robertc88

08-14-08, 10:30 AM

Just a short note that I'm really not interested in the films that were reviewed and posted for 8/11 but your efforts are greatly appreciated! :)

Ralph Potts

08-20-08, 04:13 PM

:)

Cheers,

Ralph Potts

08-24-08, 12:49 PM

:cool:

Cheers

Ralph Potts

08-26-08, 04:19 PM

:)

Cheers,

Tryton

08-27-08, 12:45 AM

Mr Potts, just was wondering how you get the actual bit rate info on the audio and video of your reviews? is is a piece of equipment you have? thanks :confused:

DevonS

08-27-08, 04:27 PM

Excellent work on the reviews. I was wondering if there were any plans to maintain a thread that would list the reviewed material in descending order by review value? Or have I just not looked carefully enough? :)

Ralph Potts

09-03-08, 05:22 PM

:cool:

Cheers,

engineear

09-04-08, 01:08 AM

Is "Crouching tiger, hidden dragon" anywhere? The scene in the trees would be ...green!

dkny75

09-04-08, 02:29 PM

Is "Crouching tiger, hidden dragon" anywhere? The scene in the trees would be ...green!

No news on a release of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Before he left for blu-ray.com, Paidgeek said the master they had needed extensive work and that it wouldn't be out for a while.

Joewee

09-05-08, 10:47 AM

Ralph,

Thanks for the reviews. Keep them coming.
When you get a chance I hope you could
review Pan's Labryinth. IMHO it is one of
the best if not thee best in Audio and Video
quality. The movie itself is one of the best
I have seen as well.
thanks!!

stepyourgameup

09-09-08, 12:54 PM

Very suprised about League being on there. However, great choice including Usual Suspects. My list includes:

Fight Club
Glenn Gary, Glenn Ross
Heat
Pulp Fiction
LA Confidential
Sin City
many more

dkny75

09-09-08, 02:10 PM

Stepyourgameup, the recommendations are only for movies that are currently available on blu-ray.

stepyourgameup

09-09-08, 02:45 PM

Stepyourgameup, the recommendations are only for movies that are currently available on blu-ray.

Oh, I guess they will be someday.

PKamp

09-17-08, 02:12 AM

Dave Vaughn

09-17-08, 02:25 AM

Black Hawk Down..... way down! It was the first Blu-ray I bought (based on the rave reviews that it got here at AVS) and IMO it is the worst video quality that I've seen since VHS... It has a very grainy / snowy picture. I nearly stopped coming to the forums at all since I felt I could no longer trust opinions here. Either my copy is defective or maybe there is something to those Scientology brainwashing rumors afterall :D

Umm...did you see it in the theater? That's how it's supposed to look! It is a great transfer BECAUSE it is able to show the grain without blocking, which is what you would get on DVD since it can't handle grain with the lower bitrates.

tines15

09-19-08, 10:57 AM

I am wondering how great is the audio quality of "Batman Begins". Does it give impact to the whole story and watching experience?

Ralph Potts

09-22-08, 10:18 AM

Iron man and Speed Racer :cool:

Cheers,

Franin

09-22-08, 10:30 AM

Iron man and Speed Racer :cool:

Cheers,

Excellent to hear looking forward in watching my copy of Iron Man tomorrow night.

Consultant

09-22-08, 03:50 PM

zetachi

09-22-08, 03:53 PM

Consultant

09-22-08, 04:24 PM

Wow, thanks for the quick repluies! I examined both websites and cross references everything with each other. One thing I need to think about is I need to limit my buying to movies I can see myself or my kids wanting to watch over and over (not every week or month, but once in a while), otherwise it is not a good investment for me.

I also forgot to mention I'm a bigtime Disney Animation and Disneyland Collector/Afficianado including a significant focus on POTC. With that being said here's my short list. Want I need is scene recommendations:

1. Ratatouille - As far as video/audio score, I'd go with this over cars simply because I thought this was a bit more entertaining a slightly more visually diverse film. It gets top marks everyone I look. Which scenes to show off?

2. Nightmare Before Christmas - This is simply a landmark animation film that would be a must have for any animation enthusiast like myself and the kids love this movie so it's definitely a keeper that you want to bring out at least once a year during the Halloween to Xmas period.

3. Blade Runner - This and Blackhawk Down seem to be the consensus favorites amongst most sites and forum participants as the overall current best demo disc as far as live action movies go. I'm 40 years old and Blade Runner has a special spot in my memories when I was young. I like the story much better than BHD as I'm not a big war/military movie enthusiast and much more of a sci-fi guy (I do appreciate Apocalypse now :) I can see this holding a permanent spot on the shelf. Which scenes to show off?

4. Iron Man - I split between rent or buy as I haven't seen the movie yet. Question is, does it have more impressive demo scenes than Blade Runner??

5. Pirates of The Caribbean - You should see my office. It looks like the Disneyland Gallery is having a POTC collectors event. All three movies are a must-have for me being a bigtime POTC collector. Plus the kids LOVE these movies and will watch POTC over and over. Which scenes to show off?

Honorable mention I might buy if price is cheap:

2001 - Sort of like Blade Runner. A very nostalgic movie for me, but I am completely blown away how such an old movie could be rates so highly? Which scenes to show off?

Narnia - This is another borderline rent/buy decision. We've seen it in the theaters. This strikes me as a great demo movie with kids in the room along with Ratatouille as the visuals are so rich and diverse. But maybe the POTC discs serve just as well as a kid-friendly live action demo disc(s)? Which scenes to show off?

Elton John 60th - I'm a big video concert fan. This in fact is primarily the SD discs I've bought for my permanent collection as they are excellent for playing at parties instead of just music.

I Am Legend, I-Robot, Orphanage, Cloverfield - I'm considering these but I think I will definitely rent before I buy.

Planet Earth - We rented and watched the series with the kids. They may be worthing of being in a permanent collection due to their educational value. Any recommendations on which episodes/scenes have best demo potential as this would be a cool/unusual disc to demo for people.

Ralph Potts

09-22-08, 04:36 PM

My PS3 arrives this week along with my 58" Panny Plasma (800u) and Denon-1909. And of course, like most everyone else, I'm chopping at the bit trying to decide what BDs to buy for showing off the new setup. I typically don't buy DVD's, I only rent them. I'd like to buy 2 or 3 Blue Ray Discs for demo purposes. I have a 7 and 8-yo so I would stray away anything that is rated higher than PG-13 and anything really violent. I have 5.1 with large Klipsch Towers and no Sub so earth shaking bass is not #1 priority on my list.

I've been reading the posts and am having a hard time to decide. If anyone can recommend specific discs and scenes as "must haves" in the PG-13 and under ratings category, I'd appreciate the input.

Greetings,

I would have to agree about Cars although that is only going from what I have read and heard as I have not seen it yet..:o

Goring strictly from the choices in my list I would consider the following:

Ice age - The opening - audio

Flight of the Phoenix - The crash sequence is incredible. - audio

The day after tomorrow - The twisters hitting Los Angeles is a good starting point. - audio

The nightmare before Christmas - pick a scene - audio/video

Nims Island - Same thing - video

Speed Racer - Same thing - video

The Waterhorse - Same thing - video

I, Robot - maybe a little violent so consider carefully audio/video

Any of the Pirates of the Caribbean films - audio/video

Iron man - The Afghanistan village sequence - audio/video

Cheers,

Fr. John

09-22-08, 05:19 PM

I responded to your original post but the mods deleted (I broke the rules :o).

Here's (http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1066162) a link to a screenshots thread I started, it covers some of the material you mention and may give you some ideas.

1. Ratatouille - See some samples in the thread above.

3. Blade Runner...Which scenes to show off? I love the interview with Rachel scene in the corporate building. Stunning.

4. Iron Man - I split between rent or buy as I haven't seen the movie yet. Question is, does it have more impressive demo scenes than Blade Runner?? Just my opinion: not worth owning. Very fun to watch with some stellar scenes; as mentioned the attack on the Afghan rebels. The 2nd half of the movie leaves a lot to be desired for more than one viewing (this coming from a one time Shell head collector).

5. Pirates of The Caribbean I don't own any of these on BD yet but the first one is my favorite by a long shot. Too many sweeping scenes that just look great

2001 - Sort of like Blade Runner. A very nostalgic movie for me, but I am completely blown away how such an old movie could be rates so highly? Which scenes to show off? Haven't opened my copy yet but the reviews coupled with the same nostalgia you describe (I'm the same age as you and was raised on this movie) make it a no brainer.

I Am Legend, I-Robot, Orphanage, Cloverfield - Consider also Pan's Labyrinth, so rich! Also, though I've not seen it, Sunshine. It's supposed to be visually excellent.

Planet Earth - We rented and watched the series with the kids. They may be worthing of being in a permanent collection.... Don't hesitate, it's a must. Absolutely stunning. Too many unbelievable scenes to mention but Shallow Seas is obvious.

PKamp

09-23-08, 02:52 AM

TRT

09-23-08, 03:01 AM

Nordo

09-23-08, 05:19 AM

Ahhh.... so if Black Hawk Down is supposed to look grainy (I never saw in in theaters) then maybe it should get some kudos for not blocking BUT I bought it on reccomendation for use as a demo. I would rather pull my toenails out than to use that to show off my 1080p! So what if 1 person in 100,000 would be impressed by that stupid grain? I want a "window on the world" not just a dirty window !!!!!
I agree with you.
I think directors/producers lose the plot sometimes.
If they want to produce an art house movie, then fine, go for it. But for the general public, and considering the current public awareness of HD video and HD audio, then movies like Black Hawk Down and Cloverfield and The Blair Witch Project I believe don't belong in anyone's list of "great" movies.

I honestly nearly threw up half way through the B W P, because of the constant moving of the camera.:(
That's not my interpretation of "enjoyable".

Chazcdc54

09-23-08, 02:34 PM

I think we are in a very small minority on this site, gents.

aydu

09-23-08, 05:01 PM

I think we are in a very small minority on this site, gents.

You are right about this site. In the general market place, however, part of the problem with Blu ray sales is getting people to buy something that was made to look bad.

HD advertises pq that is like looking out a window. Unless your windows are really dirty, grain etc. is not part of the real world. For some reason, directors tend to think that an audience won't get the mood of a film without using some photographic technique - which usually makes the image look like crap.

Consumers in general don't care a bit about the artistic vision of the film maker if the result makes their big investment in their HDTV, Blu ray player and expensive software look like it came from a 10 year old consumer VHS camcorder.

One look at a film like 3:10 to Yuma and will get people to fork over the $ for a whole system. Unfortunately, movies with that video quality are rare - possible, but rare.

Chazcdc54

09-23-08, 07:00 PM

I'm waiting for the "other side" to chime in now. I think with the digital cameras, editing equipment and what have you available nowadays, Cinematographers and Directors can really manipulate the image. The DP is now the "artist" he always wanted to be, but the tools and technology were never there before.

Interesting also how "realism" is still important in how a film, let's say an historical movie, is mounted. However, when it comes to the image, getting an expressionistic or artistic feel or look immediately trumps that. Realism goes out the window. I admit movies are not necessarily reality but there is some major contradications in Hollywood's approach to filmmaking nowadays.

Though a good movie to me to a point, Clint Eastwood's Letters From Iwo Jima is a good example. It is so drained of color I ask, why not film it in B/W? I've hated the look of most movies for 10 to 15 years now, but there are many exceptions I will grant. What can one do that is on the dissenting side.

Maybe, an earlier approach to cinematography will resurface but I doubt it, at least for some time. :(

Consultant

09-24-08, 01:43 AM

Ralph Potts

09-24-08, 05:01 AM

PS3 arrived. Ran to BlockBuster, couldn't find anything on the lists we've been discussing that I could watch with the kids, other than POTC and they just watched that recently. So I grabbed one we hadn't seen, The Golden Compass.

WOW!! Either this is just how the first Blue-Ray experience is, or I may have picked a sleeper for the top list! I might have to buy this one. POTC trilogy, Blade Runner, Rat, Nightmare X-mas, and Elton John 60th come tomorrow from Amazon. Going to have some buddies over to watch them drool.

We played Grid and Top Spin Tennis on the PS3 in 1080P. Oh My God. And the Denon 1909 has made my Klipsch surround setup sound spectacular, I am now a very poor but very happy A/V enthusiast!

I think I'm going to go for Planet Earth to round out my initial buy and then cool it before my credit card blows up. I think the educational aspect combined with the spectacular cinematography is a must-have BD set for a family with kids.

Greetings,

Welcome to Blu-ray my friend...;)

I'm waiting for the "other side" to chime in now. I think with the digital cameras, editing equipment and what have you available nowadays, Cinematographers and Directors can really manipulate the image. The DP is now the "artist" he always wanted to be, but the tools and technology were never there before.

Interesting also how "realism" is still important in how a film, let's say an historical movie, is mounted. However, when it comes to the image, getting an expressionistic or artistic feel or look immediately trumps that. Realism goes out the window. I admit movies are not necessarily reality but there is some major contradications in Hollywood's approach to filmmaking nowadays.

Though a good movie to me to a point, Clint Eastwood's Letters From Iwo Jima is a good example. It is so drained of color I ask, why not film it in B/W? I've hated the look of most movies for 10 to 15 years now, but there are many exceptions I will grant. What can one do that is on the dissenting side.

Maybe, an earlier approach to cinematography will resurface but I doubt it, at least for some time.

Interesting point of view. You won't get too much response regarding this because it is off topic for this thread. I didn't want to just cut you guys off but I figured I would point you in the right direction. I would sugggest that you discuss a topic like this in Software or DVD Movie forums. Trust me you will get plenty of opinions on the subject.

Cheers,

Chazcdc54

09-24-08, 09:30 AM

No problem Ralph. I just was reading this thread and saw a few people talking about something that really interests me. I rarely see this point of view espoused and wanted to chime in. That being said I will admit there is certainly much to laud on BD! :)

Rogozhin

09-25-08, 03:13 AM

BWG707

10-27-08, 06:55 PM

I can't believe that nobody has mentioned "Dark City". Incredible audio and a very good overall movie.

Phoenix 5.7

11-04-08, 02:30 PM

just and idea for this list, but could u make the images for the movies that have been reviewed link to the review?

Timaw

11-05-08, 04:26 PM

Hey all. Great thread here(Thanks for your recommendations list & reviews Ralph!).
I'm just getting into Blu-Ray and picked up a Sony BPH-S550 player last week. I've been blown away by some of the movies I've rented so far: New Indiana Jones, Stargate, 2001, and my latest surprise hit, "The INcredible Hulk"! I really only rented it to demo the DTS HD Master Audio format on my system. WOW, did this turn out to be a really good movie IMO. I thought my subber was gonna blow for sure during this flick!!!
Anyway, just wanted to chime in and thank everyone for their BR choices. I'm looking fwd to checking some of them out!
Tim

Ralph Potts

11-05-08, 05:51 PM

Oz Man

11-12-08, 10:42 AM

Hellboy2. awesome baby just awesome. The Audio is just awesome and the video is pretty darn good too.

Chapper

11-14-08, 12:11 PM

Greetings Ralph,

My compliments to you and for giving us these Blu ray reviews. I think that you have been doing a great service in making the results available in such a detailed and professional manner. I do enjoy reading your reviews and encourage you to keep on doing the great work as others have been enjoying it, too.

Thanks again for your contribution and my salutations... hats off to you.

regards,

chapper.

Movies and Music is my Passion (by my wife's permission)

joplass

11-14-08, 02:34 PM

Maybe I missed it in all four pages of the thread but "Planet Earth" is a must have set.

Ralph Potts

11-14-08, 05:35 PM

Toe

11-14-08, 06:03 PM

The Incredible Hulk needs to be put on that list as the audio is pure reference material!

Ralph Potts

11-14-08, 07:12 PM

The Incredible Hulk needs to be put on that list as the audio is pure reference material!

Greetings,

Toe, I picked it up and hope to check it out this weekend. I suspect it will find its place on the list... :)

Cheers,

Ralph Potts

11-15-08, 03:17 PM

Greetings,

I have several to the list including Wall*E, Kung Fu Panda, and The incredible Hulk..:)

Cheers,

kreativeimages

11-17-08, 02:31 PM

I can't post anything on this thread, so I was wondering if anybody has reviewed or seen the new Band of Brothers on Blu Ray? I would really like to to see how well it improved over the DVD set that so many enjoyed.

I just got it today but I haven't opened it.

Thanks

Toe

11-17-08, 08:26 PM

This is the last time I will bug you about this Ralph, but man I would love to see you review 2 of the biggest audio/video demo movies of the season which are The Incredible Hulk and Hellboy 2. :o:)

Franin

11-17-08, 11:17 PM

This is the last time I will bug you about this Ralph, but man I would love to see you review 2 of the biggest audio/video demo movies of the season which are The Incredible Hulk and Hellboy 2. :o:)

I agree the LFE on incredible hulk is pure delight.:)

Toe

11-18-08, 12:33 AM

I agree the LFE on incredible hulk is pure delight.:)

It realy is:) I was still blown away watching this the other day even after reading all the hype!

Nordo

11-18-08, 04:07 AM

It realy is:) I was still blown away watching this the other day even after reading all the hype!
Sorry to ask a stupid question, but which Incredible Hulk are we talking about? I think there's been 3.:cool:

Ralph Potts

11-18-08, 05:04 AM

Greetings,

I picked up The Incredible Hulk and watched it over the weekend. Definitely reference quality. I will pick up HB II at some point as well. Right now I am pretty busy with coverage for the studios that I handle. Unfortunately Universal, who released both of these films has not been responsive to requests for review copies. If I begin posting reviews of their titles after purchasing them then there would be no need for them to ever consider adding us to their list for coverage of their releases.

Hopefully that will change soon.

Thanks.

Franin

11-18-08, 05:55 AM

Franin

11-18-08, 06:49 AM

Sorry to ask a stupid question, but which Incredible Hulk are we talking about? I think there's been 3.:cool:

The latest one with Edward Norton . The other one was called Hulk with Eric Bana

Toe

11-18-08, 10:00 AM

wvasko

11-18-08, 11:28 AM

I just received Hellboy 2 and will view it this week-end when wife can watch. I will return. Now I got to order latest Hulk as Ralph says it is reference and he is has been right on with discs I have purchased because of previous reviews.

frorule

11-18-08, 11:41 AM

August Rush would make my list for Audio. I was so absorbed in the audio i couldn't even give you a critcal review of the video:)

Same here. I was amazed...

Even my wife, who wouldn't know the difference between SD and BD if it hit her in the face, made a comment on how great the movie sounded. And she never comments on anything besides the movie itself. It was that good.

Nordo

11-18-08, 04:15 PM

The latest one with Edward Norton . The other one was called Hulk with Eric Bana
Thanks Frank.

I've seen the Edard Norton version, but only in SD.:(
I want to buy a BD player. But I know if I do that I will want to upgrade my pj, and that's big money. Especially when my wife can't see anything wrong with the system we already have.:rolleyes:
I just received Hellboy 2 and will view it this week-end when wife can watch. I will return. Now I got to order latest Hulk as Ralph says it is reference and he is has been right on with discs I have purchased because of previous reviews.
Wow !!
You have a wife who actually likes to watch movies like Hellboy?:o

Ralph Potts

11-20-08, 10:12 AM

Greetings,

As much as I enjoy discussion wvasko/Nordo, this has drifted a bit too far off topic. I have deleted non topic related posts.

Regards,

mnc

11-20-08, 10:54 AM

I absolutely recommend Kung Fu Panda! Not only is it reference audio and video, it is one of the funniest movies I have seen in a long time. My whole family loved it.

wvasko

11-21-08, 05:51 PM

Franin

11-21-08, 09:00 PM

hey Ralph would we be seeing a review of the Dark knight soon ?

Ralph Potts

11-21-08, 10:07 PM

hey Ralph would we be seeing a review of the Dark knight soon ?

Greetings,

Frank, I received it today..

It is embargoed until 11/25 so expect something soon after...:)

Cheers,

Franin

11-23-08, 08:09 AM

I just finished Hellboy 2 and it was great.

Still waiting hopefully tomorrow.

Sgooter

11-23-08, 03:28 PM

This morning I bought a Panny BD-35 at my local Sears - a fantastic deal.
My HT is 1080p/24 and can handle the new audios over HDMI.
So, if you had to pick the single best Blu-Ray movie to get that will really blow your socks off for visual and sound impact when using this player, what would it be?

paris_tn

11-23-08, 09:00 PM

I'm in the same boat with Sgooter but can any of you in here recommend a documentary like Galapagos, Planet Earth or etc? I am guessing maybe alot of the documentaries are not full 1080p and won't really show off blu ray in the audio department.

Toe

11-23-08, 09:43 PM

gonzalc3

11-23-08, 10:10 PM

Hi Ralph!
Have you seen hellboy 2? I think it should be added at least in the top audio recomendations...

tnewguy

11-26-08, 12:12 AM

Is Saving Private Ryan on blu-ray? I seen it on dvd and it was really good.

Ralph Potts

11-26-08, 04:49 AM

Hi Ralph!
Have you seen hellboy 2? I think it should be added at least in the top audio recomendations...

Greetings,

Chris, I saw it theatarically but have not had the chance to see it on Blu-ray. I will check it out as soon as I can..:)

Cheers,

Redskin

11-26-08, 11:21 AM

Hi Ralph,

Thanks for the list. I noticed you put Flyboys as recommended for both Audio and Video. I know you have not written a formal review, but would love your thoughts. I saw a demo at a local high end store, and saw about 5 minutes of a dogfight scene. I didn't know what movie it was, but had to ask the salesperson what movie was playing.

Any general thoughts on movie content, audio and video presentation? I might just blind buy this.

Thanks!
Greg

Ralph Potts

11-26-08, 11:28 AM

bgillyjcu

11-26-08, 12:14 PM

Ralph Potts

11-26-08, 12:35 PM

Ralph I have been reading your reviews for a long time and I love them. I think now is the time that you have to be tougher on soundtracks since they are all getting so darn good in HD.

I see that your LFE ratings are sort of high for movies that I feel should be at least 1 notch lower. For instance last night I watched the Lion, Witch and Wardrobe and to be honest the LFE for that movie was at best a 3 out of 5. Really only 2-3 scenes stood out to me and I, like you, have a PB-13 and mine is in a 1800cu ft theater. Movies like Cloverfield and WOTW should be our 5 star benchmarks. I doubt for instance Kung Fu Panda and the upcoming Prince Caspian can reach the levels of those movies.

The new HULK in my eyes wouldn't even get a 5 start LFE...I'd say a 4 because it was very good, but not JAW DROPPING besides just a couple scenes.

Just my 2 cents :D

Greetings,

Thanks for your input. I would have to agree that the Lion, The witch and the wardrobe wouldn't be in the LFE catagory of KFP or Prince Caspian. That was one of my eariler Blu-ray Disc reviews and I hadn't had the exposure to the number of discs that I have seen to this point.

I don't agree with your assessment of The inscredible Hulk but do agree that WOTW and Cloverfield are two of the best LFE experiences.

Thanks again and I look forwrd to seeing you here at AVS..:)

Regards,

DonnerHead

11-26-08, 02:21 PM

Ralph I have been reading your reviews for a long time and I love them. I think now is the time that you have to be tougher on soundtracks since they are all getting so darn good in HD.

I see that your LFE ratings are sort of high for movies that I feel should be at least 1 notch lower. For instance last night I watched the Lion, Witch and Wardrobe and to be honest the LFE for that movie was at best a 3 out of 5. Really only 2-3 scenes stood out to me and I, like you, have a PB-13 and mine is in a 1800cu ft theater. Movies like Cloverfield and WOTW should be our 5 star benchmarks. I doubt for instance Kung Fu Panda and the upcoming Prince Caspian can reach the levels of those movies.

The new HULK in my eyes wouldn't even get a 5 start LFE...I'd say a 4 because it was very good, but not JAW DROPPING besides just a couple scenes.

Just my 2 cents :D

Not even the IH? I run a nice sub as well and IH is easily 4.5 or 5 for LFE IMO. The campus scene and ending battle are downright scary in the LFE department!:eek:

NYC Guy

11-29-08, 07:49 AM

I can't believe that nobody has mentioned "Dark City". Incredible audio and a very good overall movie.

I second the motion for "Dark City". I watched it last night on my Kuro 111FD and the night scenes were simply incredible!

The audio rocks also.

Sgooter

11-30-08, 12:28 PM

I vote for Transformers which will blow more than just your socks off!:D Strap your house down!:eek:
Thanks Toe,
I'll look into Transformers this week; sounds like the right movie choice for the impact I'm seeking.
BTW, I actually thought the right BR movie choice would be the Planet Earth set, and I almost bought it online. However, another minute of "Planet Earth" searching on AVS shocked me with the fact that it's a 1080i product, not 1080p, and reportedly there's even some footage in SD! Up til now I presumed that Blu-ray automatically meant 1080p, but looks like I'll have to first read the fine print on every BR disc...live and learn, I guess.

adidino

11-30-08, 12:59 PM

Thanks Toe,
I'll look into Transformers this week; sounds like the right movie choice for the impact I'm seeking.
BTW, I actually thought the right BR movie choice would be the Planet Earth set, and I almost bought it online. However, another minute of "Planet Earth" searching on AVS shocked me with the fact that it's a 1080i product, not 1080p, and reportedly there's even some footage in SD! Up til now I presumed that Blu-ray automatically meant 1080p, but looks like I'll have to first read the fine print on every BR disc...live and learn, I guess.

Actually, if you can find the original release (the BCC British version narrated by David Attenborough vs the Discovery Channel US version) Which sold here about six months before the American version was released, it's 1080p and picture quality is stunning.

Sgooter

12-01-08, 09:40 AM

Sgooter

12-01-08, 01:54 PM

Actually, if you can find the original release (the BCC British version narrated by David Attenborough vs the Discovery Channel US version) Which sold here about six months before the American version was released, it's 1080p and picture quality is stunning.
Adidino,
Inspired by your post, I went to a local store today to buy the BBC/Attenborough version of Planet Earth in Blu-Ray (4-disc set), but the fine print on the box said it's in 1080i, not 1080p. So, no go.
Do you actually own this Planet Earth blu-ray set in 1080p?

canyonblue737

12-04-08, 12:16 PM

several reviews on the internet indicate that the BBC box of planet earth indicates 1080i while the material actually is 1080p. this appears to be an error on the box.

Sgooter

12-04-08, 01:45 PM

several reviews on the internet indicate that the BBC box of planet earth indicates 1080i while the material actually is 1080p. this appears to be an error on the box.
I've seen the same reviews, but the confusion/contradictions still exist. Even Amazon lists the BBC version as 1080p.

Sgooter

12-05-08, 09:43 AM

Yesterday I found the BBC/Attenborough Planet Earth Blu-Ray 4-disc set in 1080p at Wal-Mart and at a very good price.

apellon

12-08-08, 09:58 AM

Sgooter

12-08-08, 10:12 AM

jbburks

12-08-08, 04:28 PM

Any interesting BD-Live content?

I'm getting a Sony BDP-S350 for Christmas, and I'm interested in what's possible on the BD-Live platform....

Stormshadow4life

12-09-08, 08:28 AM

I don't know if recommending this movie really qualifies, as the picture is only slightly above average at best for a BluRay. But The Fountain is just such a GIANT leap in PQ over the standard DVD that i feel it's worth mentioning. Also it's just an amazing movie (once you wrap your head around it) with a gorgeous soundtrack.

pahhhoul

12-09-08, 01:27 PM

so would this thread be considered the Blu Ray reference disc list?

Ralph Potts

12-09-08, 01:34 PM

so would this thread be considered the Blu Ray reference disc list?

Greetings,

Actually I started it to offer a list of Blu-ray Disc's that I either own or have reviewed (or both) which I consider to be worth adding to your collection. Member's have been adding their suggestions but nothing will be added to the list unless I have seen it.

Cheers,

pahhhoul

12-09-08, 05:41 PM

so does your list (the 1st post) get updated with new movie recommendations or would one have to browse through this thread to find the top rated BR discs in terms of video & audio quality.

Ralph Potts

12-09-08, 06:02 PM

so does your list (the 1st post) get updated with new movie recommendations or would one have to browse through this thread to find the top rated BR discs in terms of video & audio quality.

Greetings,

The original post gets updated...

Cheers,

dbailey100

12-09-08, 07:33 PM

So I finally commit and purchase a Blue Ray player (Sony 350 if you have to know). I have my entire setup running thru my Yamaha AVR (RX-V3800). In you the gurus of BD reviews opinion what would be the first purchase to view.
I can decode thru the player or the Reciever so that's not an issue.

Dr. No - simply incredible restoration of a classic James Bond film (first one actually); and the ladies look marvelous. :D

My first HD blu ray movie was Chronicles of Narnia: LWW because it is one of my top favorite movies. Prince Caspian is also a good one to start with. Great movies for the whole family.

I'm looking forward to the releases of Toy Stories, Beauty & the Beast, Ghostbusters, Sound of Music, Lawrence of Arabia, Indiana Jones I-III, Star Wars V-VI, and Star Trek films (original crew), just to name a few. Yea, I'll be waiting a long time...

mds54

12-10-08, 05:46 PM

The 1st BD I watched (rental) was the new Indiana Jones/Crystal Skull movie. The PQ was impressive and the HD audio was simply amazing.

Same here, mostly due to the timing of it's release with the purchase of my BD player. I would recommend it for high-ref material. My first viewings also included the beginning chapters of Phantom of the Opera for color ref (stage sets, costumes and make-up), and various "sampler" BDs.

apellon

12-12-08, 12:59 PM

Well.....the winner was
"Batman The Dark Knight..." I have to say I was impressed. Now it's rental time and I plan on using the list from the first post. BD Live will have a prefrence just to soothe my tech needs...Thaks fellas..

dbailey100

12-12-08, 10:08 PM

Ralph Potts

12-13-08, 05:07 PM

;)

Cheers,

victor-eyd

12-26-08, 11:50 PM

Is Death Race out on blu ray yet?

Victor

DJ Matt

12-27-08, 05:07 AM

Ralph, have you seen Home Alone yet? I watched it on Blu-ray and was not impressed at all. Much of the film had softness to it and had annoying unnecessary lighting with halos. No need for a full review. I just simply wanted to get your opinion on it.

Ralph Potts

12-27-08, 06:54 AM

Mister

12-27-08, 06:23 PM

DJ Matt

12-28-08, 02:12 AM

Several independent reviewers in Home Theater and other magazines rate "The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor" Blue-Ray as a refrence quality video disk. Wondering what Ralph and others have to say about this video BD?
Yeah, the new Mummy movie looks extremely good on Blu-ray. I would give it about a 9.5/10 for picture quality. Some of the action scenes were really good. If you rent or buy the movie pay close attention to the scene where they are up in the mountains during the action scene. It is truly a great action scene for Blu-ray.

JimInPT

12-28-08, 10:34 PM

Ralph,
In terms of video and audio quality, you have to demo/review Elton John's 6oth Birthday Bash at MSG. Its the best concert video I have ever seen. The "live" quality of it is stunning.

Man, I'll second that one! Phenomenal audio/video quality, worth looking at even if you're not an Elton fan. Usually low-priced as well if you look around a bit online.

Official title is Elton 60

Mister

12-29-08, 01:17 PM

Thanks DJMatt, will check it out.

Tandrin

12-31-08, 06:16 PM

Anybody reviewed Band of Brothers yet??

adam320

01-06-09, 11:39 AM

Anybody reviewed Band of Brothers yet??

I came to this thread to find out the same thing.

DJ Matt

01-06-09, 06:22 PM

[QUOTE=Tandrin;15426881]Anybody reviewed Band of Brothers yet??[/QUOTE
I'm not sure if this is allowed here, but there is a review up on another website. The link is below if your interested. I am sure Ralph will get around to it at some point.

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/247/bandofbrothers.html

sytrash

01-06-09, 08:15 PM

Thanks Toe,
I'll look into Transformers this week; sounds like the right movie choice for the impact I'm seeking.
BTW, I actually thought the right BR movie choice would be the Planet Earth set, and I almost bought it online. However, another minute of "Planet Earth" searching on AVS shocked me with the fact that it's a 1080i product, not 1080p, and reportedly there's even some footage in SD! Up til now I presumed that Blu-ray automatically meant 1080p, but looks like I'll have to first read the fine print on every BR disc...live and learn, I guess.

Is the Planet Earth Blu-ray DVD 1080i or 1080p?
I bought the Discovery channel one and it is 1080i only.
And people are debating if the BBC one are 1080p.
I openned it before I realize, so now I am just piss at home. :):confused:

ssbn733mt

01-06-09, 10:51 PM

Is the Planet Earth Blu-ray DVD 1080i or 1080p?
I bought the Discovery channel one and it is 1080i only.
And people are debating if the BBC one are 1080p.
I openned it before I realize, so now I am just piss at home. :):confused:

That sucks bad. I never knew of a difference other than Weaver doing the voiceover. I have the BBC Blu ray and it is 1080P. Here is a link with more info on that version.

http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/668/planetearth.html

Sgooter

01-07-09, 12:19 PM

Is the Planet Earth Blu-ray DVD 1080i or 1080p?
I bought the Discovery channel one and it is 1080i only.
And people are debating if the BBC one are 1080p.
I openned it before I realize, so now I am just piss at home. :):confused:
I understand the confusion. After numerous futile searches and several stumbles on my part, I discovered a BBC/Attenborough Planet Earth Blu-ray set (4 discs) in 1080p at my local Wal-Mart and at a good price. Looks great!
Everything else I found, whether from Amazon, Discovery, Best Buy, etc. were in 1080i.

osofast240sx

01-07-09, 10:23 PM

anyone watch Miami Vice on BD?

conroy9

01-09-09, 12:35 AM

I understand the confusion. After numerous futile searches and several stumbles on my part, I discovered a BBC/Attenborough Planet Earth Blu-ray set (4 discs) in 1080p at my local Wal-Mart and at a good price. Looks great!
Everything else I found, whether from Amazon, Discovery, Best Buy, etc. were in 1080i.

Why do you think the one at Amazon is 1080i? As far as I know, there are only 3 versions of this set: Discovery Channel 4-disc in 1080i w/ Sigourney Weaver, US BBC 4-disc in 1080p w/ David Attenborough, and UK BBC 5-disc in 1080p with Attenborough (actually, supposedly the 4 main discs are 1080p and the 5th disc is 1080i)

This is reported by highdefdigest.com and wikipedia, along with several review sites...

By the way, I hope I'm not breaking a rule, but anyone looking to buy the series from amazon may want to check out amazon.co.uk first

Cooper0103

01-09-09, 10:25 AM

I cannot recommend "Nightmare Before Christmas" enough. That movie is downright jaw dropping and really shows what Blu-Ray is all about.

My family and I have seen that movie so many times over the years and we all thought we new it pretty well. That was before we popped the BR version in the other night...WOW...even my 8 year old boy kept saying "Look at that! Oh, did you see that?" The colors, textures, depth, and the sound....downright amazing. So far it's by FAR the best BR disc we have seen.

Sgooter

01-09-09, 10:49 AM

Why do you think the one at Amazon is 1080i? As far as I know, there are only 3 versions of this set: Discovery Channel 4-disc in 1080i w/ Sigourney Weaver, US BBC 4-disc in 1080p w/ David Attenborough, and UK BBC 5-disc in 1080p with Attenborough (actually, supposedly the 4 main discs are 1080p and the 5th disc is 1080i)...

I called Amazon and asked them to confirm whether their Planet Earth set was in 1080i or 1080p, and I explained to them that there was much confusion on this detail point. They said they would look into it. They called back the next day to tell me it was 1080i.
In early December, I examined a 4-disc BBC/Attenborough Planet Earth Blu-ray set on the shelf at Target, and it was listed on the box as 1080i.
YMMV.

txbo

01-10-09, 10:57 AM

I called Amazon and asked them to confirm whether their Planet Earth set was in 1080i or 1080p, and I explained to them that there was much confusion on this detail point. They said they would look into it. They called back the next day to tell me it was 1080i.
In early December, I examined a 4-disc BBC/Attenborough Planet Earth Blu-ray set on the shelf at Target, and it was listed on the box as 1080i.
YMMV.
You can order Planet Earth Blu-ray DVD from Amazon.co.uk for less than US. If you read the customer comments listed under that title, it gives explanations what part or parts are not 1080p. Remember that some of the footage was filmed with 720p the only format available at that time. [url]http://www.amazon.co.uk/Planet-Earth-Complete-BBC-Blu-ray/
I just ordered Zulu Blu-ray from the UK, I could not find it locally.

adidino

01-10-09, 11:14 AM

I called Amazon and asked them to confirm whether their Planet Earth set was in 1080i or 1080p, and I explained to them that there was much confusion on this detail point. They said they would look into it. They called back the next day to tell me it was 1080i.
In early December, I examined a 4-disc BBC/Attenborough Planet Earth Blu-ray set on the shelf at Target, and it was listed on the box as 1080i.
YMMV.

Are you sure you were looking at the Attenborough edition? I ownthat one also and it's marked 1080p and my Bluray player detects the video as 1080p. However, I purchased mine when it was first released. I suppose it's possible they changed it? Wouldn't make sense though...

Sgooter

01-11-09, 10:25 AM

Are you sure you were looking at the Attenborough edition? I ownthat one also and it's marked 1080p and my Bluray player detects the video as 1080p. However, I purchased mine when it was first released. I suppose it's possible they changed it? Wouldn't make sense though...
Tony,
When I began my search for Planet Earth, I was looking to buy only the BBC/Attenborough version in 1080p...not knowing for certain that it even existed in 1080p.
If you're asking about the Planet Earth set I saw on the shelf at Target, then yes, it is was definitely marked on the box as the BBC version narrated by Attenborough in 1080i. I drove there specificially to buy the set, but left disappointed. Conversely, I was pleasantly surprised when I stumbled upon the BBC/Attenborough 4-disc set in 1080p on the shelf at Wal-Mart.

txbo

01-18-09, 05:09 AM

I just received my Blu Ray DVD of “Zulu”. This is one of my all time favorite films. The color, clarity and detail of this HD release are outstanding. I ordered the Blu Ray DVD from the UK it is not available locally but it plays perfectly on the PS3. This is one of the best HD transfers available.

jlaavenger

01-24-09, 03:38 PM

Hi Ralph,
I wonder if you will be looking at 10000BC anytime?

Thankyou

I loved 10,000 B.C. for what's it's worth. Video is outstanding IMHO.

JohnnyCupcakes

01-24-09, 08:27 PM

A few of my favorite films on blu-ray are Transformer, Wanted, Rush Hour 3, Step Brothers and Pinapple Express. IMHO, this were great on my Blu-ray player. I don't buy blu-rays unless there under $20. Gotta catch the sales you know...hehe..

wish

01-27-09, 03:01 PM

I just recently found this great. Great info and appreciate those sharing.

One comment I want to make is in regard to the discussion of Planet Earth and if its 1080i or 1080p. IMO this is really over blown. If your TV correctly deinterlaces 1080i, then there should be no visible difference between deinterlaced 1080i and direct 1080p. I think if you shy away from a title simply because it's 1080i you're making a mistake. I do agree with comment that the BBC/Attenborough copy is better than the Weaver. To me that is a more important criterion.

The first title that I saw that blew me away was Blade Runner. The opening scenes of future Los Angeles are absolutely stunning!

roxtc

01-28-09, 02:06 AM

Great list! Going to add most of these to my collection.

Ralph Potts

01-28-09, 09:32 AM

Greetings,

I picked it up over the weekend. Pure reference material..:cool:

Regards,

Sgooter

01-28-09, 01:30 PM

...One comment I want to make is in regard to the discussion of Planet Earth and if its 1080i or 1080p. IMO this is really over blown. If your TV correctly deinterlaces 1080i, then there should be no visible difference between deinterlaced 1080i and direct 1080p. I think if you shy away from a title simply because it's 1080i you're making a mistake...
So, if on the store shelf you see a BBC/Attenborough set in 1080P and next to it is the same thing in 1080i, and both sets are priced the same, which would you pick?

wish

01-28-09, 02:24 PM

So, if on the store shelf you see a BBC/Attenborough set in 1080P and next to it is the same thing in 1080i, and both sets are priced the same, which would you pick?Obviously the 1080p because strictly from a source POV 1080p is better than 1080i. That doesn't change the fact that you likely couldn't tell the difference from two sources that were 1080i and 1080p (again...assuming the TV correctly deinterlaces). 1080p is the top of the line benchmark but there are other factors that come into play. In this case a 1080i source ends up being 1080p once deinterlaced and displayed on the screen. Most HD TVs today are very good at deinterlacing. Does the source matter if the end result of both are identical?

I'm simply saying there were comments that people would absolutely not purchase a 1080i source as if it were the plague and I think that is short sighted. If you find it in 1080p buy it. If not available but 1080i is available then buy it. That’s all I’m saying.

schmeis

01-28-09, 02:32 PM

Either, the 1080i is a mis-print on the box. At least it is on my copy; it's 1080i on the box but my TV says it 1080p.

rawk

02-03-09, 05:39 AM

Either, the 1080i is a mis-print on the box. At least it is on my copy; it's 1080i on the box but my TV says it 1080p.

yeah, the blu-ray box says 1080i.
However that is only written on the back of the box because of the some extra programming in 1080i. All of the main features of the film is in 1080p.

Phrehdd

02-10-09, 06:00 PM

Ralph,
How about including a list of blu-ray's NOT to buy because of sound/video quality. A movie we might already own on dvd but the quality is not good enough to upgrade to blu-ray.

Ralph, I have to go with mattr on this one. It is great to see lists of what potentially to get and as important, a list of blu ray titles not to get.

It is sad that some movies are "dumped" onto blu ray rather than doing a thoughtful transfer including audio and video clean up. At times DVDs appear to be the same as those poorly done blu ray and the DVDs are cheaper.

Also, just an idea - divide audio into two catagories

stereo and traditional 5.1
"HD audio" (all of types beyond traditional 5.1)

For some, 5.1 is all they will ever have and its a pity to not separate the two out. For others who have "ultimate" systems for audio, they might be swayed by the quality in that venue.

- Phrehdd

Dalumberjack

02-15-09, 01:47 PM

has anyone seen The Kingdom on BD? I loved the movie in SD and I can imagine what the opening scene and following scene sound like. Must Be amazing. Is it worth the purchase on BD?

I have most of these discs on BD but havent been able to watch them all. Can't wait to have the time to get to these + now that I just got a new reciever (Onkyo 876) for HD audio :D!

P.S. Good job Ralph. With out you I don't know what I would do when it comes to these movies.

Sgooter

02-16-09, 09:50 AM

Recently watched Nights in Rodanthe in Blu-Ray.
It's an OK chick flick that would be fine on SD DVD, but it's a waste of $$ as a Blu-Ray disc. Both PQ and 5.1 audio are unimpressive for Blu-Ray IMHO.

cmarkmyers

02-20-09, 06:06 PM

has anyone seen The Kingdom on BD?
I have it on HD-DVD and it sounds fantastic and looks incredible. But the picture is grainier than 'Black Hawk Down', which could bother some people.

It is also quite possible that it won't look better on Blu (or could look better). I have 'King Kong' on HD-DVD and it looks great, but watching it the other day at a Best Buy in Blu Ray it was unwatchable. It wasn't the sharpness of the image or the vibrancy of the colors, it was the unbelievably fake looking CGI. For some reason it came across fine on HD-DVD but not on Blu Ray.

Granted I have come to this opinion based on watching only one scene at a big box retailer, but I have it in my queue so I can do a side by side comparison at home.

itsameian

02-20-09, 11:44 PM

Has anyone seen 300 on bd yet? I love the movie and love the video effects and audio effects that I saw and heard and felt when I saw it theatricaly but even with my klipsch system and denon 2808 reciever and 119 inch screen I have been unable to reproduce the feel of it on sd.

Dalumberjack

02-21-09, 12:43 PM

One Word:
Awesome

SPARTA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Has anyone seen 300 on bd yet? I love the movie and love the video effects and audio effects that I saw and heard and felt when I saw it theatricaly but even with my klipsch system and denon 2808 reciever and 119 inch screen I have been unable to reproduce the feel of it on sd.

spick

02-23-09, 03:49 PM

I watched The Fountain last night on BD. I thought the visuals and audio were both top notch. The scenes in space were really breath taking.

Not a movie for everyone. It's a love story at its core, a bit of a tear jerker too. Might be one for the ladies?

JamE55

02-24-09, 01:56 PM

thebesthereis

02-26-09, 12:40 AM

Salute,

Have you ever thought about adding Heat (DeNiro & Pacino) if it is available?

I personally have not seen it on blu ray but maybe you have. :) I have seen it before and it was a pretty loud movie. (Not that it means the audio would be great on blu ray but good enough for a chance to get on the list)

Thanks for list sharing.

Ralph Potts

02-26-09, 08:16 AM

Ralph Potts

02-26-09, 08:18 AM

Greetings,

I finally picked this up. Incredible audio/video quality that would rate 100/100in my book..

Regards,

GB Steve

02-27-09, 03:11 AM

Greetings,

I finally picked this up. Incredible audio/video quality that would rate 100/100in my book..

Regards,

I can't wait to read your review on this movie! I've never seen you rate a movie 100/100..... this must be a great movie! 100's go to the top of my "must see list".

Have you had a chance to see the movie 300 yet?

JimHigh

02-27-09, 12:35 PM

Ralph Potts

02-27-09, 02:01 PM

I wouldn't reccomend "the Mummy" for a good sound experience, as mentioned above. If you want good sound, try getting a copy of Akira on Blu Ray. (Dolby True HD 192khz). Blew me away yesterday when I watched it.

Pan's lab is pretty good too.

I figure if you're going to watch a movie, make it one that you enjoy as well. = )

Greetings,

Jim, while I agree the Mummy is not an especially great piece of cinema I disagree that its presentation isn't worth experiencing. Beside everyones tastes vary and it isn't for you or I to tell anyone what they should like or dislike.

Cheers,

Franin

02-27-09, 07:19 PM

rusky_g

02-28-09, 09:59 AM

Anyone seen Amusement? I thought it was pretty good for PQ :)

JimHigh

02-28-09, 11:06 AM

Greetings,

Jim, while I agree the Mummy is not an especially great piece of cinema I disagree that its presentation isn't worth experiencing. Beside everyones tastes vary and it isn't for you or I to tell anyone what they should like or dislike.

Cheers,

True you are. I could have worded differently only to stress "I dont personaly prefer the Mummy". However, since I just received my new Energy speakers from UPS yesterday, perhaps another viewing would be in order. = P
(and for the record, the only one I didnt like was the 3rd Mummy, lol)

silverm3s

03-01-09, 12:27 PM

Here are some I recommend on blu-ray that I thought were pretty amazing. Death Race, Path Finder, 30 Days of night, and Beowulf.

70runner

03-02-09, 01:39 PM

Another vote for Cloverfield audio. Truly amazing sound/surround presence, both the bridge scene and the street battle stand out. Was cool seeing the blue "HD Audio" readout on my Denon light up.

rusky_g

03-02-09, 06:21 PM

Hey again guys

Been thinking about my top few for Picture Quality so far and came up with:

Transformers
The Dark Knight
Speed Racer
The Mummy - Tomb Of The Dragon Emperor
Ironman
SpiderMan 3
Mission Impossible 3
Rush Hour 3
The Prestige
Swordfish

And here's some films which I watched and thought I'd put the DVD in by mistake:

Click
Jerry McGuire
Reservoir Dogs
Men In Black

Looking forward to seeing:

Harry Potter series
Pirates Of The Caribbean series
Casino Royale
Blade Runner
Dark City
Ghost Rider

:)

groundtrac

03-05-09, 11:04 AM

I picked up Jet Li's Fearless and it blew me away. I watched the Director's cut and I thought the picture and sound was just amazing. The fight scene near the end when the girls are all pounding on the drums was very impressive. The scenes showing the chinese countryside were equally impressive, overall I thought it was a great blu-ray experience.

b_dogg623

03-05-09, 02:49 PM

Ralph Potts

03-12-09, 09:36 AM

:cool:

Nordo

03-13-09, 06:03 AM

I'm shocked Max Payne didn't make it into the recommended Audio list. I have seen a majority of all the best rated Blu-Ray's and the gun fights in that movie were the best I have ever heard in regards to impact, immersion, and surround sound activity.
But you have to admit, it's all a bit overdone. The engineers have used the surround sound format like a toy. The whole movie is very tongue-in-cheek.:)
I think they were trying to make it feel like you were playing the computer game without having to worry about applying any input.

Stix2

03-15-09, 08:00 AM

Greetings,

I finally picked this up. Incredible audio/video quality that would rate 100/100in my book..

Regards,

Really...... Chalk up another 100 then :D

Ralph Potts

03-15-09, 12:17 PM

Really...... Chalk up another 100 then :D

Greetings,

Absolutely..;)

Regards,

King_David

03-15-09, 02:29 PM

Greetings,

Absolutely..;)

Regards,

How about reviewing THE PRINCESS BRIDE???

Ralph Potts

03-15-09, 02:35 PM

How about reviewing THE PRINCESS BRIDE???

Greetings,

I would love to but Fox hasn't sent it yet..:confused:

Regards,

Lordoftherings

03-15-09, 08:21 PM

I'm shocked Max Payne didn't make it into the recommended Audio list. I have seen a majority of all the best rated Blu-Ray's and the gun fights in that movie were the best I have ever heard in regards to impact, immersion, and surround sound activity.

Hi,

I absolutely agree with your comment, this movie's audio soundtrack was done expertly by an excellent team of film mixers, with the close collaboration of the director of Max Payne, John Moore.

The Bass in this movie is unreal! Very low frequencies, and deep tight gun's
sounds. But listen to the music soundtrack with the digital synthesizer...
It is pure room shaking, and deep into your guts and soul... :eek:

My sound system is well dial in, with the subs properly balanced, and all In can say, like I did already a while back, it's that this movie is now one of my top reference soundtrack for Bass tightness and impact.

By the way, John Moore is the same director that also directed "Flight of the
Phoenix". Do you remember also the Bass impact of this movie, when the plane faced the sand storm, and finally crashed? :D
John Moore, if you listen to his commentaries, in particular in the two flics
here mentioned, is really a strong bass impact advocate, and also an innovative guy with cool ideas for his film mixer, about the lowest bass frequencies ever recorded in the history of movie making, if not the Lowest. And it shows in the final results.
You have to give the guy credits plus congatulate him to bring us such entertaining and deeply satisfying sound design into his movies. :cool:

"Max Payne" rocks with strong Bass and Impact, no doubt about it. :)

Cheers,

______
Bob

Ralph Potts

03-27-09, 02:23 PM

Added Bolt and Quantum of solace. :cool:

Cheers,

Joewee

04-10-09, 11:51 AM

Ralph. I am still waiting for you review of Pan's Labyrinth. :) Take
a Looksee when you get a chance. You will not be disappointed

Mr.G

04-11-09, 02:01 PM

Ralph, I just got around to looking at your list of favorites and recommendations. I think it's a great PQ/AQ reference list as many before me have said. I find many of my guilty pleasures involve Michael Bay movies, Armageddon, Transformers and The Island. I recently picked up the UK/Australian Blu-ray version since it's not available in a U.S. version yet, something to do with copyright infringements or something like that, not sure. The Island Blu-ray looks great, nice saturated colors (a Bay trademark) and great sound although only in Dolby Digital 5.1. I'm sure I'll pick up the U.S. version if and when it appears.

Ralph Potts

04-11-09, 03:55 PM

Chamillitary

04-11-09, 07:26 PM

Greetings,

I look forward to it's release in the States. Like you, it is one of my favorites..http://www.**********************/track/img/3358/m09d0317xktz/2.gif

Regards,

One of my favorites too. I enjoy reading your posts and reviews here. Been a long time lurker.

Stormshadow4life

04-15-09, 11:24 AM

thebesthereis

04-16-09, 02:29 AM

I watched a movie called Tell No One last night. Thought the picture was superb (especially for a modest budget French film).
The movie is excellent as well. Went into it blind, and was very glad I did. Sometimes the less you know about a movie, the nicer surprise it is.

I heard about it through my Netflix subscription and added it to my XBOX 360 "watch now" queue. Will be checking it out soon. Thanks for the heads up.

mjconnor10

04-16-09, 11:47 AM

Any chances of reviewing In Bruges? Watched the bluray last weekend, and it was absolutely gorgeous. Wonderful movie, as well.

Ralph Potts

04-20-09, 05:08 AM

:cool:

Cheers,

Joseph1

04-22-09, 02:04 PM

robsis

04-22-09, 02:18 PM

Joseph1

04-22-09, 02:31 PM

IMO all three X-men movies were worth it....the third gets a little preachy; however, great climactic battle scene! Rent them if you're not sure; however, if you liked the first, chances are you will enjoy the next two. #3 is not the let-down that Spiderman 3 was.

Robert

Thanks Robert. I also found out the length of the third movie is shorter than the 2nd movie. Although a longer movie doesn't necessary mean it's better.

Stormshadow4life

04-22-09, 06:45 PM

I heard about it through my Netflix subscription and added it to my XBOX 360 "watch now" queue. Will be checking it out soon. Thanks for the heads up.

Just curious if you or anyone else had watched this one yet?

JamE55

04-23-09, 10:32 AM

I want to buy x-men but still hesitate to buy all three movies. I saw the first movie and enjoy it very much, but haven’t not seen the second and the third movie.

Does anybody think it’s worth to buy all 3 x-men movies?

Yes it's worth it.

Just curious if you or anyone else had watched this one yet?

It's not out on Blu Ray yet.

Stormshadow4life

04-23-09, 10:35 AM

It's not out on Blu Ray yet.

Sure it is. I own it.
http://www.amazon.com/Tell-Blu-ray-Kristin-Scott-Thomas/dp/B001NOMOT2/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1240497271&sr=8-1

JamE55

04-23-09, 11:49 AM

Sure it is. I own it.
http://www.amazon.com/Tell-Blu-ray-Kristin-Scott-Thomas/dp/B001NOMOT2/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1240497271&sr=8-1

Sorry i thought he was talking about the movie Heat. Interesting film though (Tell No One) and i added it to my list. Looks pretty good.

thebesthereis

04-24-09, 09:49 PM

Just curious if you or anyone else had watched this one yet?

I haven't gotten around to it yet. Darn. :(

JamE55

05-01-09, 01:07 PM

Does anybody know or can give me the link AVSForum review for Dark City?

Thanks

NYC Guy

05-01-09, 07:53 PM

Does anybody know or can give me the link AVSForum review for Dark City?

Thanks

I don't recall ever seeing one although I did recommend that one should be done. The night scenes on this movie look unbelievable on my Kuro 111FD - 05FD BD player combination!!!