Just got rid of ICO on the bay and can either pick up Batman AA or Infamous for same price need for the weekend so curious what the consensus may be. know this isnt thread worthy but you guys are THE GAMERS so im asking. Just wanted a fairly new 3rd person action and already picked up uncharted 2. THANKS (this is for others...i can decide my own stuff, havent demo either)

If you want stealthy action, go with Batman. If you want something more like a shooter, go with Infamous.

Batman's shorter, but from I've heard the story is top notch.

Infamous is no slouch, but the story is pretty generic. Gameplay rocks, and it's open world; basically a better version of the spider man games.

The only correct answer is that you should have kept Ico.

The only correct answer is that you should have kept Ico.

nah... one of the few games ive finished (8 years ago) may revisit next year when they come out with the ICO/SOTC HD set;)

I have both games. I put inFamous on hold to play through Batman AA. Both are great games but Batman is a step above in my opinion.

I guess a question could be do you want a game you can play through in 15-20 hours (inFamous) or 10 - 12 hours (Batman). I'm sure you could play through them in shorter or longer times but that's an average I think.