View Full Version : Using fiberglass poster frames as room treatments?


Megalith
04-10-07, 11:32 PM
I'm interested in treating the primary reflection points in my listening room, but those spots also happen to be the locations where I would like to hang some art.

I realize that fiberglass can be used as absorbers to a certain degree, which is what most poster frames use as a practical solution for glass. So if I could use a frame to not only treat the room, but make the room look pretty, that'd be great.

But how effective would it be?

prime21
04-11-07, 01:29 AM
I'm interested in treating the primary reflection points in my listening room, but those spots also happen to be the locations where I would like to hang some art.

I realize that fiberglass can be used as absorbers to a certain degree, which is what most poster frames use as a practical solution for glass. So if I could use a frame to not only treat the room, but make the room look pretty, that'd be great.

But how effective would it be?

Are you referring to Plexi-glass or fiberglass?

Terry Montlick
04-11-07, 12:34 PM
Posters are a bad idea for early reflection treatment. The paper reflects high frequencies, which are the one that need to be absorbed. The only way I know of to have your cake and eat it too is to have poster images silk-screened onto fabric, which then covers fiberglass absorbers.

- Terry

ChrisWiggles
04-11-07, 03:02 PM
I'm interested in treating the primary reflection points in my listening room, but those spots also happen to be the locations where I would like to hang some art.

I realize that fiberglass can be used as absorbers to a certain degree, which is what most poster frames use as a practical solution for glass. So if I could use a frame to not only treat the room, but make the room look pretty, that'd be great.

But how effective would it be?

Huh? I think the previous poster is right, you are confusing plexiglass with fiberglass. I have never seen any kind of poster frame made from fiberglass. Obviously I have seen many frames covered with plexiglass as opposed to glass. Plexiglass is a clear plastic, like a window.

Fiberglass is not anything like that. Fiberglass is the insulation that is in your walls.


Plexiglass:
http://doddtechnologies.com/lecterns/plexiglass_std.jpg


Fiberglass:

http://www.advancedinsulationinc.com/images/photos/Fiberglass_Installation.jpg
http://www.ethanwiner.com/oc-703.jpg


Plexiglass is reflective, as you can imaging, much like glass is. This would be an absolutely terrible absorber and totally not appropriate as a treatment unless you WANT a large, flat, extremely reflective surface (extremely unlikely). Fiberglass is a fluffy like material, opaque of course. It's more like cotton/wool, or dense cotton/wool if made into more dense fiberglass type boards as the lower picture shows.

BTW: the bottom picture i stole from ethan's site, the other two i stole from the interweb.

Megalith
04-11-07, 11:01 PM
Thanks for clearing that up guys.

I prefer my art plax mounted anyways...