HighDefDiscNews
06-09-07, 08:16 PM
Flags of Our Fathers (HD DVD) Review (http://www.highdefdiscnews.com/?p=72)
4 out of 5 stars - The Movie Itself (has an average rating of 7.3 on IMDb)
4 1/2 out of 5 stars - Video Quality (1080p in VC-1 on a 30gb disc)
4 out of 5 stars - Audio Quality (Dolby Digital Plus 5.1 @ 1.5Mbps)
4 out of 5 stars - Bonus Materials (are included on their own HD DVD)
Rated - R (Restricted)
Year - 2006
Length - 132 minutes
Studio - Dreamworks (Paramount)
The Movie Itself is one part of a pair of films done by legendary actor/director Clint Eastwood about the battle at Iwo Jima in World War II. This film tells the American perspective I guess you could say but it’s primarily about a real life photo that can be found on the cover of this release. The picture is a very patriotic photograph that shows six soldiers raising the American flag after the battle at Iwo Jima. This picture starts a lot of media coverage and hype labeling the three surviving soldiers “war heroes.” This film follows the lives during and after that battle of those three remaining soldiers, John “Doc” Bradley (played by Ryan Phillippe), Rene Gagnon (played by Jesse Bradford) and Ira Hayes (played by Adam Beach). I’d like to point out that this film is based on true events and the names of the soldiers are real. In fact the original book “Flags of Our Fathers” was written by James Bradley (son of John “Doc” Bradley). This film was also produced by Hollywood legend Steven Spielberg.
These three soldiers are brought home labeled as “war heroes” as stated above and soon being used by the U.S. government to help sell war bonds to help the war effort. Which they do accomplish but at the same time there’s a lot of demons inside these men that came from seeing such a horrific battle at Iwo Jima. This is especially true for both John Bradley and Ira Hayes who throughout the film have post-war stress induced flashbacks that really got to them on a really emotional level that they can’t talk about with anyone or even come to terms with themselves. This movie is not one that glorifies war but instead one that shows the hell that comes with it. So if you’re expecting to see a bunch of Japanese get slaughtered you might wanna look elsewhere and seek therapy. That’s not what this movie is about. This movie and what it stands for can really be stated best by a quote by the real John “Doc” Bradley, “The real heroes of Iwo Jima are the guys who didn’t come back“. I think after watching this film that Clint Eastwood made you’ll have a better understanding for that quote.
Video Quality on this release is presented in 1080p VC-1 encoded on a 30gb HD DVD for the feature film. This film visually is up there with “Saving Private Ryan” in terms of amazing visual CG special effects and such. Even though war as it is portrayed in this film is a very ugly and disturbing thing to watch at times, this release in terms of video quality itself really does offer just an amazing transfer with great picture. The blacks are perfect, no artifacts or pixilation to be found in this video presentation. The cinematography style that this film as well as it’s counter-part, “Letters from Iwo Jima” uses might lead some to think the contrast is off but it’s just the visual style that Clint Eastwood was going for to show the time period in both films. This release is one of the best in terms of video quality yet from Paramount and I hope it’s a sign of things to come.
Audio Quality on this release is the standard Dolby Digital Plus 5.1 @ 1.5Mbps. One thing most important to this sound mix is the fact it’s a film about war, World War II at that. So it’s kind of expected a movie like this have a great surround mix and I can honestly say it lives up to those expectations very much so. Dialog comes out in obviously the center and front channels as you’d expect in the less intense scenes of the film. When you’re in the flashbacks of battle scenes of the film you really notice an awesome surround presence that will make you hear gunfire up close, distant or passing gunfire as well as mortar shells. The surround experience on this release is one that is sure to please any action film fan.
Bonus Materials are included on their very own extra HD DVD and are in High Definition. First off there’s “An Introduction by Clint Eastwood” (5 minutes), then “Words on the Page” (17 minutes) which tells us a bit about the original book written by James Bradley. James is the son of John Bradley (played by Ryan Phillipe in the film). This feature offers interviews with James Bradley (again the book’s original author) as well as the screenplay writers William Broyles, Jr. and Paul Haggis. Next is “Six Brave Men” (20 minutes) which tells the personal stories of each of the six real life soldiers in the photograph and offers interviews with the actors who portray them in this film. “The Making of an Epic” (30 minutes) is your typical making of documentary of a film. It includes interviews with everyone from the producer (Robert Lorenz), director of photography (Tom Stern), special effects coordinator, editor (Joel Cox), art director, costume designer and even the military technical adviser. “The Making of an Epic” is really by far the real highlight of the bonus materials for this film and looks amazing in High Def. “Raising the Flag” (3 minutes) is a short feature about reenacting the photograph that the film is primarily about in the film just as it was in real life. “Visual Effects” (15 minutes) is exactly what the name says, a feature on the visual (”CG”) special effects used on this film. “Looking into the Past” (10 minutes) offers up a lot of old historical military video footage of the actual battle at Iwo Jima. History Channel fans will definitely love this while some of the more action film oriented crowd may want to skip this. The last feature included is the original Theatrical Trailer in High Def. This release definitely packs some great bonus materials on it’s very own disc and is really impressive.
— Review written by Justin Sluss
4 out of 5 stars - The Movie Itself (has an average rating of 7.3 on IMDb)
4 1/2 out of 5 stars - Video Quality (1080p in VC-1 on a 30gb disc)
4 out of 5 stars - Audio Quality (Dolby Digital Plus 5.1 @ 1.5Mbps)
4 out of 5 stars - Bonus Materials (are included on their own HD DVD)
Rated - R (Restricted)
Year - 2006
Length - 132 minutes
Studio - Dreamworks (Paramount)
The Movie Itself is one part of a pair of films done by legendary actor/director Clint Eastwood about the battle at Iwo Jima in World War II. This film tells the American perspective I guess you could say but it’s primarily about a real life photo that can be found on the cover of this release. The picture is a very patriotic photograph that shows six soldiers raising the American flag after the battle at Iwo Jima. This picture starts a lot of media coverage and hype labeling the three surviving soldiers “war heroes.” This film follows the lives during and after that battle of those three remaining soldiers, John “Doc” Bradley (played by Ryan Phillippe), Rene Gagnon (played by Jesse Bradford) and Ira Hayes (played by Adam Beach). I’d like to point out that this film is based on true events and the names of the soldiers are real. In fact the original book “Flags of Our Fathers” was written by James Bradley (son of John “Doc” Bradley). This film was also produced by Hollywood legend Steven Spielberg.
These three soldiers are brought home labeled as “war heroes” as stated above and soon being used by the U.S. government to help sell war bonds to help the war effort. Which they do accomplish but at the same time there’s a lot of demons inside these men that came from seeing such a horrific battle at Iwo Jima. This is especially true for both John Bradley and Ira Hayes who throughout the film have post-war stress induced flashbacks that really got to them on a really emotional level that they can’t talk about with anyone or even come to terms with themselves. This movie is not one that glorifies war but instead one that shows the hell that comes with it. So if you’re expecting to see a bunch of Japanese get slaughtered you might wanna look elsewhere and seek therapy. That’s not what this movie is about. This movie and what it stands for can really be stated best by a quote by the real John “Doc” Bradley, “The real heroes of Iwo Jima are the guys who didn’t come back“. I think after watching this film that Clint Eastwood made you’ll have a better understanding for that quote.
Video Quality on this release is presented in 1080p VC-1 encoded on a 30gb HD DVD for the feature film. This film visually is up there with “Saving Private Ryan” in terms of amazing visual CG special effects and such. Even though war as it is portrayed in this film is a very ugly and disturbing thing to watch at times, this release in terms of video quality itself really does offer just an amazing transfer with great picture. The blacks are perfect, no artifacts or pixilation to be found in this video presentation. The cinematography style that this film as well as it’s counter-part, “Letters from Iwo Jima” uses might lead some to think the contrast is off but it’s just the visual style that Clint Eastwood was going for to show the time period in both films. This release is one of the best in terms of video quality yet from Paramount and I hope it’s a sign of things to come.
Audio Quality on this release is the standard Dolby Digital Plus 5.1 @ 1.5Mbps. One thing most important to this sound mix is the fact it’s a film about war, World War II at that. So it’s kind of expected a movie like this have a great surround mix and I can honestly say it lives up to those expectations very much so. Dialog comes out in obviously the center and front channels as you’d expect in the less intense scenes of the film. When you’re in the flashbacks of battle scenes of the film you really notice an awesome surround presence that will make you hear gunfire up close, distant or passing gunfire as well as mortar shells. The surround experience on this release is one that is sure to please any action film fan.
Bonus Materials are included on their very own extra HD DVD and are in High Definition. First off there’s “An Introduction by Clint Eastwood” (5 minutes), then “Words on the Page” (17 minutes) which tells us a bit about the original book written by James Bradley. James is the son of John Bradley (played by Ryan Phillipe in the film). This feature offers interviews with James Bradley (again the book’s original author) as well as the screenplay writers William Broyles, Jr. and Paul Haggis. Next is “Six Brave Men” (20 minutes) which tells the personal stories of each of the six real life soldiers in the photograph and offers interviews with the actors who portray them in this film. “The Making of an Epic” (30 minutes) is your typical making of documentary of a film. It includes interviews with everyone from the producer (Robert Lorenz), director of photography (Tom Stern), special effects coordinator, editor (Joel Cox), art director, costume designer and even the military technical adviser. “The Making of an Epic” is really by far the real highlight of the bonus materials for this film and looks amazing in High Def. “Raising the Flag” (3 minutes) is a short feature about reenacting the photograph that the film is primarily about in the film just as it was in real life. “Visual Effects” (15 minutes) is exactly what the name says, a feature on the visual (”CG”) special effects used on this film. “Looking into the Past” (10 minutes) offers up a lot of old historical military video footage of the actual battle at Iwo Jima. History Channel fans will definitely love this while some of the more action film oriented crowd may want to skip this. The last feature included is the original Theatrical Trailer in High Def. This release definitely packs some great bonus materials on it’s very own disc and is really impressive.
— Review written by Justin Sluss