View Full Version : The Island - Blu-ray (Belgium)


Robert George
06-11-07, 08:10 PM
The Island

US Distribution - DreamWorks
EU Distribution - Warner Bros.

Blu-ray released in Belgium by Warner (no region code)
Coming to other EU countries in both Blu-ray and HD DVD (varies by country, Blu-ray only in Belgium).

Running Time - 136 minutes
Aspect - 2.40:1
Languages - (Dolby Digital 640 kb/s) English 5.1, French 5.1, Spanish 5.1, Italian 5.1, Castellan 5.1; English Descriptive Track 2.0 (192 kb/s)
Subtitles - Too many to list (like, a dozen tracks)
VC-1 1080/24P

Default Playback Configuration: English 5.1/Subtitles Off (disc goes in, Warner logo, movie starts. No scary FBI warning, no menu, no bullsh!t. My kind of disc.)

(Perfunctory reviewer comments on the movie...)

Michael Bay is one of those filmmakers that critics hate and moviegoers love. If you judged Bay's cinematic expertise on the average review one of his movies gets, you'd wonder why anyone in Hollywood would give him the time of day, much less hundreds of millions of dollars. To divine that answer, one need only look at the box office and home video receipts of the average Michael Bay movie, and you'll know why Hollywood likes him rather more than the average film critic. Michael Bay makes movies that people like to watch. While most of Bay's films are hugely successful, The Island from 2005 would have to be counted as a minor hit, except at my house.

I consider The Island to be an imminently repeatable bit of sci-fi fluff beautifully shot, competently acted, and with a story that does, perhaps, a bit more than just connect the various and obligatory action set pieces. No matter how many times I have seen this flick, I can still drop the disc in the player and have my attention grabbed right from the opening dream sequence. But, every time I have seen the film on DVD, I can't help but recall how enjoyable that first theatrical experience was and how far from that a DVD, even a good DVD, really is. The Island is a film that is best enjoyed in a dark room with a big screen and a crankin' surround system. It was with no small bit of excitement I opened the Airmail package containing the spankin' new high definition edition of this modern extravaganza on Blu-ray disc. My excitement quickly turned into almost childish glee as the opening frames lit up my 106", 1080p projection screen.

(Yada, yada, yada. Tell us how it looks...)

The hi-def transfer Warner has graced us with in this new Blu-ray disc is, in a word, gorgeous. Candy cane colors pop off the screen without a hint of oversaturation or smearing so often found on lesser video formats. Much of Bay's lighting is high contrast with bright hot whites and deep, inky blacks. This transfer conveys the film's production design without a hiccup. The image is consistently sharp and detailed with a natural grain structure and not a hint of blocking or digital noise. So sharp, in fact, one can now detect less than perfect focus from shot to shot (don't they pay guys just to "pull focus"?). I did note a few fleeting instances of banding in a few shots, though this was slight and never distracting.

Of course, this is a Michael Bay film, so lots of things get blown up. While not quite the uncompressed or lossless audio we have come to expect on the HD formats, the 640 kb/s Dolby Digital track certainly delivers the goods here. For those not keeping score, Dolby Digital on DVD is limited to 448 kb/s and as good as those are, the extra bits here are put to good use. Dialog has a clear, natural timbre while the score and effects have a rather more "airy" quality than the DVD version. Not hi-res lossless, but certainly not bad.

Warner has also included a short, 15 minute "making of" piece of the marketing EPK variety. This gives a bit of background on the film with Michael Bay and most of the film's principles talking about how great everything is. In this case, I happen to agree with them.

If you are a fan of The Island, this is a disc you will want to seek out. It will likely be a bit easier to find as it is released in other European counties in the coming weeks. I guarantee it will be worth the effort.

Pass the popcorn...

nyg
06-11-07, 08:37 PM
The hi-def transfer Warner has graced us with in this new Blu-ray disc is, in a word, gorgeous.

Awesome! Can't wait to receive my copy. Thanks for the review Robert.

TheCrackedJack
06-11-07, 08:40 PM
Anywhere besides Mediadis that this can be bought?

Also, I've seen the Blu-Ray on Amazon.fr and .de, so I don't think this will be limited to Belgium. Although, it is the only country to have currently released it.

Rob423
06-11-07, 08:42 PM
this movie was awesome.

Robert George
06-11-07, 09:05 PM
I believe Germany and France will be getting the Blu-ray, just not yet. I also don't know if the same disc will be used in other countries. Could be slightly different authorings using the same basic transfer. Won't know until they come out.

Right now, the only place I have seen the disc available is Mediadis, and even they have been out of stock more than in-stock.

Kruly
06-11-07, 09:06 PM
Anywhere besides Mediadis that this can be bought?

Also, I've seen the Blu-Ray on Amazon.fr and .de, so I don't think this will be limited to Belgium. Although, it is the only country to have currently released it.

Just watch out when ordering far far away, amazon.fr clearly say région code 2.

Penton-Man
06-11-07, 09:09 PM
[ So sharp, in fact, one can now detect less than perfect focus from shot to shot (don't they pay guys just to "pull focus"?).
Indeed they do. :D

So, I assume you indeed read my previous postings on the Blood Diamond thread. ;)

Nice review.

Robert George
06-11-07, 09:21 PM
Nice review.

Thanks for saying so.

And actually, no, I left Africa when things started getting deleted.

darkjedi664
06-11-07, 09:29 PM
Nope, no PCM, sorry, can't buy it. Wake me up when they add PCM to this movie.

Robert George
06-11-07, 11:41 PM
Wake me up when they add PCM to this movie.

No.

Digitalspice
06-12-07, 02:43 AM
I believe Germany and France will be getting the Blu-ray, just not yet. I also don't know if the same disc will be used in other countries. Could be slightly different authorings using the same basic transfer. Won't know until they come out.

Right now, the only place I have seen the disc available is Mediadis, and even they have been out of stock more than in-stock.

I tell you trying to track this disc down is driving me nuts. :mad:

According to amazon, Germanys release date is 7/20 and France is 6/27. UK has been delayed and was originally supposed to be out 5/7.

Mediadis is dissing me, They dont answer any emails inquiring about my order that I have sent to them.

ravenous
06-12-07, 02:49 AM
Germany is getting "The Island" on July 20th as Blu-Ray and HD-DVD.

Disc featuring:

Audio: Dolby Digital 5.1 German, Dolby Digital 5.1 Englisch, Dolby Digital 5.1 Spanish, Dolby Digital 5.1 Italien, Dolby Digital 5.1 French

Subtitel: German, Englisch, German SDH, Englisch SDH, French, Spanish, Netherland, Schwedish, Finnish, Norwegian, Italien

HD-DVD is very much the same, despite the Audio being DD+

BD is BD25
HD-DVD is HD-DVD30

Penton-Man
06-12-07, 02:56 AM
The image is consistently sharp and detailed with a natural grain structure and not a hint of blocking or digital noise. So sharp, in fact, one can now detect less than perfect focus from shot to shot (don't they pay guys just to "pull focus"?).
But remember this technique is intended to keep the subject of attention clearly in focus.

It is not intended as an overall soft appearance during the entire shot. That may be an encoding deficiency as has been noted on some other recent title(s). ;)

As applicable to the point I think you are trying to make, perhaps the more appropriate terminology would have been……….
(don't they pay guys just to "throw focus"?).

And again, the answer is yes they do……whether it be the DP during the shot or during post production.

TheCrackedJack
06-12-07, 03:15 AM
Just ordered it from Mediadis. I also ordered it from HMV, which said ships within 3-5 days before I checked out. Afterwards, it said on special order. So, we'll see if I get either of my orders anytime soon.

Digitalspice
06-12-07, 03:27 AM
Ive been on special order from HMV since the original 5/7 release date for the UK version. I think the best bet would be Mediadis. I just wish they would answer their damn email.

MitchR
06-12-07, 04:37 AM
Netherlands is getting it on June 27th as long as it stands, same specs as Germany/France/Belgium etc.

http://www.freerecordshop.nl/pages/productview.asp?productid=1259544

Dorian Gray
06-12-07, 05:42 AM
Beware, this release from FreeRecordShop looks like an alternative cut to me... ;)
Acteurs:
Scarlett Johansson, Ethan Hawke

mhafner
06-12-07, 05:55 AM
But remember this technique is intended to keep the subject of attention clearly in focus.
It is not intended as an overall soft appearance during the entire shot. That may be an encoding deficiency as has been noted on some other recent title(s). ;)

Not compression related focus issues are seen all the time on HD material. Perfect Focus as intended simply does not happen all the time. And with film you don't know till the following days. MI3 has lots of focus issues with faces that are supposed to be in focus, but for example only the nose or ear is, or nothing. :)

MitchR
06-12-07, 06:01 AM
Beware, this release from FreeRecordShop looks like an alternative cut to me... ;)

LOL :D hadn't even noticed that before haha

Penton-Man
06-12-07, 11:36 AM
Not compression related focus issues are seen all the time on HD material. Perfect Focus as intended simply does not happen all the time.
I agree. :)
But on the other hand, there are softness issues occuring in scenes of some films that had perfect focus. ;)

Penton-Man
06-12-07, 11:45 AM
And with film you don't know till the following days.
Michel, I don't know what you mean by "following days."

This time is shortened considerably if one is getting HD dailies back from a local post facility to the set, via courier.

Which actually occurred, now that I think about it, with this motion picture, The Island when the shooting was done close to Santa Monica.

Tidbit alert :D ........................................
The company president/managing director (himself) supervised the job involving production of the HD dailies and did the actual work on the 2K DI………….which speaks to the perfectionism? of Michael Bay in regards to light and color.

Gekkou
06-12-07, 11:50 AM
I hope that it's not a rip-off from the HD broadcast as the audio treatment is a silly DD@640Kbps. I think the US release will see Dolby Tru-HD or Uncompressed PCM 5.1.

Actually it'll probably be DD @ 640k on BD and DD+ @ 1.5m on HD DVD, since Paramount handles distribution for Dreamworks.

nyg
06-12-07, 04:58 PM
Yay, my copy shipped today. Can't wait. Have I said how much I love this movie already?! :D

Earz
06-13-07, 07:17 AM
Actually it'll probably be DD @ 640k on BD and DD+ @ 1.5m on HD DVD, since Paramount handles distribution for Dreamworks.


I think I will wait this one out after hearing unofficial talk of Paramount releasing HD audio in the near future on their titles.

Hopefully the enventual U.S. release has HD audio.

mhafner
06-13-07, 01:43 PM
Michel, I don't know what you mean by "following days."

I meant you have to develop the film and make a copy or telecine to see what you got. Does not neet to take days but at least some hours. If you are not near a lab as in a jungle etc. you may not know for quite some time what you got. Big avantage for WYSIWYG digital equipment.

trifix
04-07-08, 05:58 AM
Just watched it yesterday and i saw one disturbing thing. They have used HEAVY grain reduction on Scarletts face 3-4 times in the movie. You see it clearly as the rest of the image has that Michael Bay grain and her face is smoooooth....

lgans316
04-07-08, 06:04 AM
One side of Scarlett's face was digitally airbrushed similar to Millas face in RE-3. So nothing wrong with the transfer. Probably she had more number of distracting pimples during the filming. :D

MOberhardt
04-07-08, 06:29 AM
Yeah the digital airbrushing was very noticable in the SD release. Seemed to be the left side of her face only, and mainly in the start. I heard it was something to do with acne.

trifix
04-07-08, 07:50 AM
Yes you could clearly see in a couple of scenes that the acne was pretty bad at times. But why didn't they "regrain" the face. Looks like crap now....

aramis109
04-07-08, 09:51 AM
Yes you could clearly see in a couple of scenes that the acne was pretty bad at times. But why didn't they "regrain" the face. Looks like crap now....

I wouldn't say it looks like crap. It is definitely noticeable, but that also speaks for the quality of the rest of the film's transfer.

I got mine from xploitedcinema for $32 shipped- they got it to me really quickly. It's my first import and I am very happy with the result. I already loved the film and the BD is tier-1 status to me.

Art Sonneborn
04-07-08, 11:24 AM
Yeah the digital airbrushing was very noticable in the SD release. Seemed to be the left side of her face only, and mainly in the start. I heard it was something to do with acne.

This was even more clearly visible in HD that I got from DirectTV (I don't have the BD yet). I was just struck that so little care was taken to correct this.

Art

trifix
04-07-08, 01:39 PM
I was like "wtf is that!!" when i first saw it on the BD-release so yes it's REALLY noticeable if you got a big screen like me.

By the way, something is really wrong here when i payed 41$ for the BD-version....NO IMPORT. I bought it in the store and no that's a typical price for a BD here in Sweden. Well actually it's a little lower since they usually go for around 45-47$.

solidgator
08-11-08, 02:41 PM
Any word on a possible US release of this on Blu-ray, perhaps with lossless audio? Its been over a year since the UK version came out, so you'd think it would have happened by now. IMO they should release it on the same day as Transformers...

FoxyMulder
08-11-08, 02:57 PM
Yeah the digital airbrushing was very noticable in the SD release. Seemed to be the left side of her face only, and mainly in the start. I heard it was something to do with acne.

Was this done for the actual cinema release or just for the DVD and Blu editions ?

The same thing happened to Milla Jovovich's face in the last Resident Evil movie but i believe she had some bad spots and it was only done to the closeups....Medium and long shots were left untouched. It was kinda jarring though when it happened and i'd rather just see the spots.

Franin
01-29-09, 11:16 PM
Well I took the plunge for $30, could not resist!

MRMOTA
01-30-09, 03:31 AM
Well I took the plunge for $30, could not resist!

The UK Island is part of the Amazon UK buy 2 get 1 free. I bought it along with Predator 2(2 copies) for 46 dollars delivered for all 3.

butsu
01-30-09, 09:00 AM
In the lists too,especially helicopter chased scene.

Franin
01-31-09, 12:35 AM
In the lists too,especially helicopter chased scene.

Fantastic film, watched last night forgot how good it was!