Tried playing this a few nights ago on my new PC. Works great for every BR title so far. This disc would not allow me to select "play" or "chapter select" etc. from the menu. Really weird.

Anyone else have this issue with PC? I'm playing with Power DVD

shameless bump...

I'm believe that the menus are done in BD-J on this title, so that may have some bearing on what you're (not) seeing.

Did you have any issues with either of the Pirates movies? They have probably the "heaviest" BD-J menus released thus far, so if anything would "break" PowerDVD, logic would dictate they would be first in line to do so.

Well, not sure what BD-J is, but I haven't watched either Pirates movie. Is this a patch-related issue or am I just not able to watch BD-J encoded menus?