View Full Version : Banned from BluRay.com in less than ten posts


schticker
08-29-07, 10:09 AM
...And in three days.:eek:

Now, those that have read my posts on the subject here realize that I am decidedly neutral, having neither format nor really finding fault with either. If anything, I may some experiential disagreements with Sony, or think their fanboy base is rather irrational;), but I try not to let that show.

In less than ten posts of not drinking the Kool-Aid and posting in a fair manner to counter some of the FUD, I was banned. Reason listed: none (!)

If you are not a flag-waving irrational fanboy of BR on that site, you will be gone. We see what shadblz and the like post there, and they remain.

Personally, anyone that wants to get a bad taste in their mouth about that format should visit that site (as a visitor--don't bother joining). BluRay.com does the format a disservice IMO.

Personally I could care less about the banning. I just thought some of you might find it amusing.

jasonmvt
08-29-07, 10:15 AM
You know, I'm dual format as well... but that is one scary place. It really is frightening to go there and read how blindly devoted people can be. If someone posted that HD DVD killed his mother, there'd be an angry pitchfork mob ready to kill in seconds... I've visited a few times and have no plan on going back.

vancouver
08-29-07, 10:21 AM
bluray.com = Circle Jerk

bourke
08-29-07, 10:25 AM
Engadget are the same - must be owned by Sony too.

My first 6 posts - all deleted within minutes!

Johnsteph10
08-29-07, 10:27 AM
I was banned, too, for being a format neutral person and not a smurf. The misinformation and outright lies over there are absolutely amazing.

Someone should publicize that forum and let the public see what behavior the BDA supports and encourages.

markrubin
08-29-07, 10:28 AM
you know when I hear about the circus over there it reminds me of a famous quote:

“Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people” Eleanor Roosevelt

cdzie1
08-29-07, 10:29 AM
They don’t like people who don’t speak the company line.

5thDanMaster
08-29-07, 10:29 AM
...And in three days.:eek:

Now, those that have read my posts on the subject here realize that I am decidedly neutral, having neither format nor really finding fault with either. If anything, I may some experiential disagreements with Sony, or think their fanboy base is rather irrational;), but I try not to let that show.

In less than ten posts of not drinking the Kool-Aid and posting in a fair manner to counter some of the FUD, I was banned. Reason listed: none (!)

If you are not a flag-waving irrational fanboy of BR on that site, you will be gone. We see what shadblz and the like post there, and they remain.

Personally, anyone that wants to get a bad taste in their mouth about that format should visit that site (as a visitor--don't bother joining). BluRay.com does the format a disservice IMO.

Personally I could care less about the banning. I just thought some of you might find it amusing.

They are a pack of wolves over there...starving, angry, bitter, Blu-wolves at that.:eek:

They hate anyone who does not think that BR is descended directly, and ordained by God Himself. Even Beatboy, the great proponent and proud flag bearer for the BDA cause, was severely attacked when he mentioned the WB going neutral stuff. Those Blu-savages would eat their own young...stay the heck away from there.:)

5thDanMaster
08-29-07, 10:30 AM
you know when I hear about the circus over there it reminds me of a famous quote:

“Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people” Eleanor Roosevelt

Excellent post. :D

narcopolo
08-29-07, 10:31 AM
.
My first 6 posts - all deleted within minutes!

Reminds me of the SH forum, and what they do with any posts that don't suck up to vinyl.

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 10:32 AM
bluray.com = Circle Jerk

I wish.

No, it's not.

:D

bourke
08-29-07, 10:33 AM
you know when I hear about the circus over there it reminds me of a famous quote:

“Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people” Eleanor Roosevelt

Very high-brow Mark - I dare you to post that in 'the other place' :-)

schticker
08-29-07, 10:36 AM
Very high-brow Mark - I dare you to post that in 'the other place' :-)

I might be able to generate an account long enough to sneak that in before getting discovered...;)

5thDanMaster
08-29-07, 10:36 AM
...And in three days.:eek:

Personally, anyone that wants to get a bad taste in their mouth about that format should visit that site (as a visitor--don't bother joining). BluRay.com does the format a disservice IMO.

Personally I could care less about the banning. I just thought some of you might find it amusing.

You think that they are crazy over there? Check out this "Hit List" that they have posted in their website. Blu-ray dot com. :eek:

Here is a thread that is sort of an Expansion on the HD-Rant Thread where we can categorize HDDVD Shills, tools etc. Based on PM's I receive of votes, I will categorize the HDDVD Fanboys into their Appropriate "Tier" please notate what forum they are from. For example; BobHDDUDLuvR=AVS or HDDVDShill-BD.com

So send me PM's or post telling me who you would like to vote for, and where you think they belong in the Tier thread. We are only going Tier 0,1 & 2 for now, unless someone wants a 3rd and has a valid reason.

Tier 0 is the ultimate Thread wrecker, Shill tool. This guy will Thread crap just about every "pro-BD" thread in existance. and they will spout off dillusional crap almost daily. It's always on the Up & up if it's HDDVD related, while everything BD related is reflected negatively.

Tier 1 The medium thread crapper. This one is basically the same as Tier 1 but they try and Hide under a flag of "Format Agnostic" or "Whats good for the consumer"...BULLSH**T! These guys try and pretend they are okay with both formats, occassionally they are using the fact that they (may or may not own a BD player) as a reason to "Legitmately" gripe about BD.

Tier 2 Mild Thread poo flinger. Could be someone who's new on the scene, but someone to keep our Eye on. This could be a former member who was banned & accussed of re-registering under a new name...(Think Oshodi's numerous alias) or someone who's popped on the Radar as someone to watch.

Here goes,

Tier 0
1) MichaelHDDVD /AVS
2) Oshodi /AVS
3) rdjam /AVS
4) Timothy Ramzyk /AVS
5) Amirm /AVM$/BD.com-banned
6) Nataraj /AVM$
7) Lee Stewart /AVS
8) Hmurchison /AVS/BD.com-banned
9) Plazman /AVS
10) MidnightWatcher /AVS
11) DigitalfreakNYC /AVS
11) Robert Zohn /AVS
12) Xboxboi /AVS
13) Robert George /AVS





Tier 1
1) Kosty /AVS
2) Reginald Trent /AVS
3) kevivoe /AVS
4) Andrew P /AVS
5) HPforMe /AVS
6) Urza /AVS
7) Deja Vu /AVS
8) cdzie1 /AVS (could be moved, awaiting more votes)
9) alpha21 /AVS
10) wormraper /AVS
11) Cees Alons /HTF
12) Robert Crawford /HTF
13) Adam Gregorich /HTF




Tier 2
1) aaronwt /AVS/BD.com-banned
2) VC-1 /HDD-Banned (could be moved, awaiting more votes)
3) HDDVDFuture /HDD-Banned (could be VC-1, see #2)
4) Barricade /HDD (could be VC-1 & or HDDVDFuture see#2,3)
5) divian /HDD (could be moved, awaiting more votes)
6) GizmoDVD /AVS

:eek::eek::eek::D

MidnightWatcher
08-29-07, 10:37 AM
I read that it was started by a 16 year old. They're probably all just children. Their behaviour indicates as much.

5thDanMaster
08-29-07, 10:37 AM
Very high-brow Mark - I dare you to post that in 'the other place' :-)

:D

markrubin
08-29-07, 10:37 AM
Very high-brow Mark - I dare you to post that in 'the other place' :-)

I would, but don't I think they like me over there...

5thDanMaster
08-29-07, 10:38 AM
I read that it was started by a 16 year old. They're probably all just children. Their behaviour indicates as much.

Please, I will not condone PS3 fan battering on this forum. :mad::D

lyris
08-29-07, 10:38 AM
Wow, they're really letting it get personal. I agree, as a neutral format owner, that site only damages Blu-ray's name.

Looks like they need to relax, sit back, and take some red pills...

schticker
08-29-07, 10:39 AM
You think that they are crazy over there? Check out this "Hit List" that they have posted in their website. Blu-ray dot com. :eek:



:eek::eek::eek::D

I like how they banned Amir. Guy knows more about BluRay than all of them combined.:rolleyes:

bourke
08-29-07, 10:39 AM
Somehow someone needs to have that quote posted into that hit-list thread!

'Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people' -- Eleanor Roosevelt

jclark67
08-29-07, 10:45 AM
you know when I hear about the circus over there it reminds me of a famous quote:

“Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people” Eleanor Roosevelt

LOL! I am glad that we are not talking about people. :D

Milt99
08-29-07, 10:51 AM
I like how they banned Amir. Guy knows more about BluRay than all of them combined.:rolleyes:
I know more about BluRay than all of them combined and I don't own it.
If you want to see a large part of the why and who of what happened to this forum all you need do is look at the posters there.
Vancouver's description is perfect.
Nothing more that a sycophantic circle jerk.

eatenbacktolife
08-29-07, 10:52 AM
I think it's a great site. If it keeps most of the format wackjobs over there instead of here, I'm all for it. Lots of oxygen thiefs on that site....

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 10:57 AM
Ha. I've never even BEEN on that site and someone nominated me.

I'm touched. :)

schticker
08-29-07, 11:00 AM
Ha. I've never even BEEN on that site and someone nominated me.

I'm touched. :)

You are a threat :mad::rolleyes::D

Michael Mullis
08-29-07, 11:00 AM
Hey 5thDanMaster, you have the old list. I have an updated one. Or at least updated from a few days ago. I wonder if anyone ever relayed my message to them to spell my name correctly.

Tier 0
1) MichaelHDDVD /AVS
2) Oshodi /AVS
3) rdjam /AVS
4) Timothy Ramzyk /AVS
5) Amirm /AVM$/BD.com-banned
6) Nataraj /AVM$
7) Lee Stewart /AVS
8) Hmurchison /AVS/BD.com-banned
9) Plazman /AVS
10) MidnightWatcher /AVS
11) DigitalfreakNYC /AVS
11) Robert Zohn /AVS
12) Xboxboi /AVS
13) Robert George /AVS





Tier 1
1) Kosty /AVS
2) Reginald Trent /AVS
3) kevivoe /AVS
4) Andrew P /AVS
5) HPforMe /AVS
6) Urza /AVS
7) Deja Vu /AVS
8) cdzie1 /AVS (could be moved, awaiting more votes)
9) alpha21 /AVS
10) wormraper /AVS
11) Cees Alons /HTF
12) Robert Crawford /HTF
13) Adam Gregorich /HTF
14) ILJG /AVS
15) B.Greenway /AVS
16) Bruceames /HDD
17) Slim GoodBooty/AVS
18) jdg345 /AVS
19) WayneL /AVS
20) Sean_O /AVS
21) MichealMullis /AVS
22) Technicolor /AVS
23) efxmaster /AVS
24) Iggster /AVS
25) HomerJay /AVS
26) calikarim /AVS
27) pteittinen /AVS
28) tsd2005 /AVS
29) Julie /HD GURU/Ucom-4/HDD
30) Revolv(rdjam) /HDD
31) PFC5 /HDD
32) Godson /HDD
33) Stew4HD /HDD
34) HD-Stuntman /HDD
35) nfinity /AVS
36) alfbinet /AVS/BD.com(for now)





Tier 2
1) aaronwt /AVS/BD.com-banned
2) VC-1 /HDD-Banned (could be moved, awaiting more votes)
3) HDDVDFuture /HDD-Banned (could be VC-1, see #2)
4) Barricade /HDD (could be VC-1 & or HDDVDFuture see#2,3)
5) divian /HDD (could be moved, awaiting more votes)
6) GizmoDVD /AVS
7) BOO /AVS


Tier 3
1) Cletus Clamsniffer /BD.com (watching)
2) Blurry /HDD (watching)

schticker
08-29-07, 11:03 AM
Tier 3
1) Cletus Clamsniffer /BD.com (watching)
2) Blurry /HDD (watching)

"Watching" lol Holy snap--"We need to watch these people. They represent a threat to order and the establishment.":p

trots
08-29-07, 11:05 AM
Ha. I've never even BEEN on that site and someone nominated me.

I'm touched. :)
That's hysterical! They actually ban people before they've even been there, just in case? LOL!

BuGsArEtAsTy
08-29-07, 11:05 AM
To give the Blu-ray side credit, it is not a sanctioned Blu-ray website. It's purely a fanboy website.

P.S. This is probably in the wrong forum.

JaylisJayP
08-29-07, 11:05 AM
i went over there to read the posts when the Paramount News came out...all I have to say is "Lord of the Flies."

Russ Younger
08-29-07, 11:06 AM
I read that it was started by a 16 year old. They're probably all just children. Their behaviour indicates as much.

I agree, talk about Lord of the Flies crap.

Droid6
08-29-07, 11:08 AM
How do you sign up to be on that list?

wittangamo
08-29-07, 11:09 AM
bluray.com = Circle Jerk

I wish.

No, it's not.

:D

Would you settle for Circle OF Jerks?

sambow87
08-29-07, 11:10 AM
That's...a little disturbing. If I didn't take this format war so seriously, I would almost feel threatened. But I do feel quite ashamed that there is a list made for this reason.

I'd feel like a goof if I based all my information for everything on one type of group. Good to have different opinions, broadens my views.

This saddens me...

bourke
08-29-07, 11:11 AM
How do you sign up to be on that list?I've been trying my hardest to canvass votes - it seems their parliament is snoozing at the moment!

Urza
08-29-07, 11:13 AM
Yes!!!! Tier one baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A list LOL how disturbing is that?

homerx
08-29-07, 11:15 AM
They can't allow HD-DVD owners in their. Becase in their minds their is no HD-DVD. Only blu-ray. Which won a long time ago. Don't you read the sony reports.

(:

schticker
08-29-07, 11:17 AM
P.S. This is probably in the wrong forum.

I put it here because I knew it would get a good laugh. I don't think it makes sense to put in the BR forum, where it will just tick people off.:D

Although now that I think about it...:cool:

Urza
08-29-07, 11:18 AM
New sig to honor my new status.

I would like to Thank the following...

AVS
My Family
The Academy!!

schticker
08-29-07, 11:18 AM
I agree, talk about Lord of the Flies crap.

Wow, exactly. I was looking for analogy. That's perfect.:o

schticker
08-29-07, 11:20 AM
New sig to honor my new status.

TIER 1 ON THE BLURAY.COM FORUMS! YES BABY!

Should I feel bad that I wasn't there long enough to even make the list? I feel strangely excluded...:confused:

lyris
08-29-07, 11:20 AM
I wonder how many of the "M$" posters are posting from Mac or Linux machines. I'd wager not many.

cybereality
08-29-07, 11:21 AM
Hey schticker, if you really want to get them back just post this on their site in a thread titled...

"Confirmed: Paramount goes back to neutral":

http://cybereality.com/images/hddvd_owns_bluray.gif

That'll get them good. Might even make a few fanatics commit suicide.

Just don't hot-link from my server, I'm not trying to get DoSed here.

I would do it myself, but I'm taking the high road. :D

Patsfan123
08-29-07, 11:22 AM
I am dual, but I am surprised I haven't made the list yet as Tier 2. I like how they have scoured 4 forums to make such a list. That is really great!

jwv651
08-29-07, 11:22 AM
Children Kids Teens that is what the blu ray.com is....Simply a bunch of kids being lead by the #1 BD fud god...Penton-man. What a f**king joke. The site makes Blu ray look absolutely terrible. If your neutral stay out of there unless you like being harass.

No_U-Turn
08-29-07, 11:26 AM
Tier 3
1) Cletus Clamsniffer /BD.com (watching)
2) Blurry /HDD (watching)

"Watching" lol Holy snap--"We need to watch these people. They represent a threat to order and the establishment.":p

Wow, Cletus made the list! :p lol

Urza
08-29-07, 11:27 AM
I wonder how many of the "M$" posters are posting from Mac or Linux machines. I'd wager not many.


Todays Category's


WTF?

What does this have to do with anything?

Random Posts

Another person who thinks its clever using M$

Angry BD fan


I'll take Random Posts for 200 Alex!

Michael Mullis
08-29-07, 11:27 AM
No, it belongs in this forum because many of us have been listed on their forum on that rediculous list.

And for those that are format neutral, now that you see that list, now you might understand why my signature says what it says. No one should have much doubt about the format I support. It's not exactly a big secret. But the difference between them and me (and many of us here) is that we don't have to make a list of Blu-ray "zealots". We don't go into the Blu-ray forums to troll (I don't go into the AVS Blu-ray forums AT ALL), and we don't just start 3 threads a day in the general section with crap that eventually has to be deleted because it's obviously fanboy.

Truth is for me, I could not care any less if Blu-ray lived or died. It's not that important to me. Both formats could live side-by-side just like video game systems. That is NOT going to stop me from enjoying movies on HD DVD. Hell, I want ALL studios to be neutral (which will never happen it seems). But I don't need Blu-ray to die for me to enjoy what I am enjoying right now.

These are the differences between us and them.

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 11:31 AM
Should I feel bad that I wasn't there long enough to even make the list? I feel strangely excluded...:confused:

I've never even REGISTERED and i'm on that list! :)

Would you settle for Circle OF Jerks?

MUCH more appropriate :)

Urza
08-29-07, 11:32 AM
Some of the best stuff has to be when PENTON says ANYTHING on that forum.

He talked about going out with two beautiful ladies or something to that affect, and the boards lit up.

"Oh my god, its code, what could that mean?"

"I think he means someone is going exclusive"

It's very funny!!!!

Other good one is that AVS is a paid MS site. Oh Im sorry M$(thats how they do it).

Here at AVS your ALLOWED to be from both formats. Speaking ANYTHING positive at deathray.com, and your out.

Topweasel
08-29-07, 11:33 AM
Kind of disappointed. 1800 HD DVD related posts here and not even Tier 3.

Urza
08-29-07, 11:34 AM
I've never even REGISTERED and i'm on that list! :)



MUCH more appropriate :)

You dont have to be on that forum. Its people from that site that are here on AVS. Trust me dude, there are a bunch of zealot BD fans on here that are nice to semi nice, but loose all sense when they get over to that site. I want to name them, but I dont want to get this thread closed.

Urza
08-29-07, 11:34 AM
Kind of disappointed. 1800 HD DVD related posts and not even Tier 3.


TROLL!!:p

Steverhcp02
08-29-07, 11:38 AM
threads like this and the active contribution of mods are why this science forum is going down hill, imo. Let them be over there, i post over there but its still an outlet for information. There are folks in this very thread who are no worse than the folks over there.....at least most of them, if not all of them stick to their own website which is more than can be said for people here going to BD forums on AVS.

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 11:42 AM
threads like this and the active contribution of mods are why this science forum is going down hill, imo. Let them be over there, i post over there but its still an outlet for information. There are folks in this very thread who are no worse than the folks over there.....at least most of them, if not all of them stick to their own website which is more than can be said for people here going to BD forums on AVS.

I'm format neutral.

Those morons don't know the difference between a critique/concern and "bashing."

Steverhcp02
08-29-07, 11:43 AM
I'm format neutral.

Those morons don't know the difference between a critique/concern and "bashing."
That very well may be true, i am not denying that there are idiots out there.....but at least they are THERE is my point....to go and bait them and then come here to have your own circle jerk is just as stupid, imo.

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 11:45 AM
That very well may be true, i am not denying that there are idiots out there.....but at least they are THERE is my point....to go and bait them and then come here to have your own circle jerk is just as stupid, imo.

Who's baiting them?

Urza
08-29-07, 11:45 AM
That very well may be true, i am not denying that there are idiots out there.....but at least they are THERE is my point....to go and bait them and then come here to have your own circle jerk is just as stupid, imo.

BIG difference is that the circle jerk can be challenged. You wont be thrown out for being from the OTHER side.

This IMHO opinion is what seperates AVS from sites like bluray.com

GregApple
08-29-07, 11:45 AM
...And in three days.:eek:

Now, those that have read my posts on the subject here realize that I am decidedly neutral, having neither format nor really finding fault with either. If anything, I may some experiential disagreements with Sony, or think their fanboy base is rather irrational;), but I try not to let that show.

In less than ten posts of not drinking the Kool-Aid and posting in a fair manner to counter some of the FUD, I was banned. Reason listed: none (!)

If you are not a flag-waving irrational fanboy of BR on that site, you will be gone. We see what shadblz and the like post there, and they remain.

Personally, anyone that wants to get a bad taste in their mouth about that format should visit that site (as a visitor--don't bother joining). BluRay.com does the format a disservice IMO.

Personally I could care less about the banning. I just thought some of you might find it amusing.

Wow, so you went to a Blu-ray fan website that is open and honest about its support of Blu-ray.

Then you post HDDVDs propaganda there and are surprised that they ban you?

At least they have the guts to be open about their format affiliation, unlike another website I am thinking of. ;)

SamwisetheBrave
08-29-07, 11:46 AM
bluray.com = Circle Jerk

:D:D

GregApple
08-29-07, 11:47 AM
BIG difference is that the circle jerk can be challenged. You wont be thrown out for being from the OTHER side.

This IMHO opinion is what seperates AVS from sites like bluray.com

Actually I talked to several people on HTF and Blu-ray.com that were banned from here within 10 posts for being pro-Bluray.

Maybe people on this site need to look in the mirror?

Urza
08-29-07, 11:48 AM
Wow, so you went to a Blu-ray fan website that is open and honest about its support of Blu-ray.

Then you post HDDVDs propaganda there and are surprised that they ban you?

At least they have the guts to be open about their format affiliation, unlike another website I am thinking of. ;)

Welcome Bluray.com forum member!!

Steverhcp02
08-29-07, 11:50 AM
Who's baiting them?

Im not about to have this debate....if you folks want to plead ignorance thats fine. but to sign up over tehre merely to debate is baiting them. Sure, idealy we should be able to debate on these topics, but to go into an area with a majority of fanboys to try to have a debate and then come back and say "zOMG look at all the crazy wild fanboys, this is why bluray.com are teh sucks i cant even have a conversation" When you all know damn well what its going to turn into make th epeople going over there for the sol purpose of playing devils advocate look even more immature than the people who stay on their own site and drink their blu kool aid.

Urza
08-29-07, 11:50 AM
Actually I talked to several people on HTF and Blu-ray.com that were banned from here within 10 posts for being pro-Bluray.

Maybe people on this site need to look in the mirror?

I know some of the people you were talking about. Having only 6 posts, you clearly dont know what happend. One guy came on here and went FLAME away. You can be BLU all you want on here, its HOW you conduct yourself.

Nice try tho.

schticker
08-29-07, 11:51 AM
Wow, so you went to a Blu-ray fan website that is open and honest about its support of Blu-ray.

Then you post HDDVDs propaganda there and are surprised that they ban you?

Posting HD DVD propaganda? Link? It would be interesting to see what you (or any BRFB) thinks is false information. Should be good for a chuckle.

One would think that any staunch supporter would want to see the truth and be intellectually honest, as opposed to clinging to mythology and false information in order to justify their support. That support is typically revolving around the fact that certain folks have invested in one format, and currently have the means to only support one. As a high-def supporter (format neutral), it makes sense for both sides to see the good and bad of their chosen camps to aid in the education of the formats and see reality. Challenging false concepts is good for self-examination.

GoCheese
08-29-07, 11:52 AM
Here is my favorite post from over there by their "insider" Penton Man that I will remember EVERY time I see this guy post, read it and don't forget it:

It’s been a tough week for the Blu faithful, no doubt about it. I think many here feel that something of paramount importance that partly belonged to them was more or less stolen from them and the psychological blow has been tough to recover from…… no matter how truly important or unimportant that entity was/is in the grand scheme of things for the future.

I can only say that it has shown me that Blu-ray early adopters/supporters are overly tired of this format war already and just want it to end so they can go about enjoying their hobby at home without fear that high definition packaged media will even survive to gain widespread mainstream acceptance. Whereas, it’s becoming increasingly obvious that the red side hobbyists just want to win for the sake of wining…..PERIOD. Any interest in optimized picture quality and audio quality of movies or recordibility on their part is just superficial fluff and talking points.

All I can tell you is that the decision makers and power brokers are working their butts off behind the scenes exploring as many avenues as possible …… so go out and rent or buy a Blu-ray movie this weekend that you’ve been hesitating to get for some reason or other, and let the people that get paid for this stuff worry about it. That way you can enjoy your home theater experience and at the same time, support the format the best and most effective way that you really can.

eapleitez
08-29-07, 11:52 AM
Wow, so you went to a Blu-ray fan website that is open and honest about its support of Blu-ray.

Then you post HDDVDs propaganda there and are surprised that they ban you?

At least they have the guts to be open about their format affiliation, unlike another website I am thinking of. ;)

He never said he posted propaganda! Propaganda is spinning the truth or outright lying. He just presented a neutral stance and tried to cut through the BS. That site is FULL of BD propaganda.



I'm disappointed I didn't make the hit list :mad::(







:D

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 11:52 AM
Im not about to have this debate....if you folks want to plead ignorance thats fine. but to sign up over tehre merely to debate is baiting them. Sure, idealy we should be able to debate on these topics, but to go into an area with a majority of fanboys to try to have a debate and then come back and say "zOMG look at all the crazy wild fanboys, this is why bluray.com are teh sucks i cant even have a conversation" When you all know damn well what its going to turn into make th epeople going over there for the sol purpose of playing devils advocate look even more immature than the people who stay on their own site and drink their blu kool aid.


Don't debate it with me.

For the THIRD time this thread, I NEVER signed up on that damn site.

Urza
08-29-07, 11:52 AM
Posting HD DVD propaganda? Link? It would be interesting to see what you (or any BRFB) thinks is false information. Should be good for a chuckle.

One would think that any staunch supporter would want to see the truth and be intellectually honest, as opposed to clinging to mythology and false information in order to justify their support. That support is typically revolving around the fact that certain folks have invested in one format, and currently have the means to only support one. As a high-def supporter (format neutral), it makes sense for both sides to see the good and bad of their chosen camps to aid in the education of the formats and see reality. Challenging false concepts is good for self-examination.


Shhhh, your going to end up on the tier one thread they have:D

GregApple
08-29-07, 11:53 AM
maybe there is a reason that hundreds of people on another website have all reached consensus about some of you and made a list?

maybe you guys should take the plank from your own eye...

DigitalfreakNYC
08-29-07, 11:54 AM
maybe there is a reason that hundreds of people on another website have all reached consensus about some of you and made a list?

maybe you guys should take the plank from your own eye...

I'm used to people who have never met me hating me.

Par for the course.

Doesn't mean that they have a legitimate case.

schticker
08-29-07, 11:55 AM
Im not about to have this debate....if you folks want to plead ignorance thats fine. but to sign up over tehre merely to debate is baiting them.

You can stop right there. These Code Blue clowns need to grow up and have honest debate, like a real forum. I know I wasn't baiting anyone, but happily countered FUD with honesty.

Sure, idealy we should be able to debate on these topics, but to go into an area with a majority of fanboys to try to have a debate and then come back and say "zOMG look at all the crazy wild fanboys, this is why bluray.com are teh sucks i cant even have a conversation" When you all know damn well what its going to turn into make th epeople going over there for the sol purpose of playing devils advocate look even more immature than the people who stay on their own site and drink their blu kool aid.

I see. Challenging false information and mythology is the immature, irresponsible course of action.:rolleyes: You might as well sign up over there, since you think similarly.

foots
08-29-07, 11:56 AM
He never said he posted propaganda! Propaganda is spinning the truth or outright lying.

You may need to go look up the definition of propaganda. :rolleyes:

Dysson
08-29-07, 11:56 AM
That's weird...I left a few pro-HD-DVD posts on the Michael Bay article. I even left a couple of posts making fun of the posters on Blu-Ray.com. They never banned me and all my posts remained on the board.

I even posted a snide reply letter from Paramount making fun of them (which was obviously fake). Still, nothing. Weird.

Urza
08-29-07, 11:56 AM
maybe there is a reason that hundreds of people on another website have all reached consensus about some of you and made a list?

maybe you guys should take the plank from your own eye...

Proud to be on the list.

But then again, are you defending that list? How childish is this?

Lists of these kind have prroved nothing but useless in History

Ask Jews,African American's,Hollywood(McCarthy),etc.

It's very disturbing to most level headed people.

Should the people be afraid they are going to get whacked? Should they be afraid of strange phone calls?

markrubin
08-29-07, 11:57 AM
In keeping with the "take the high road" philosophy, we should not add fuel to the fire, so I am closing this thread

AVS welcomes all members in this format battle: I am saddened to see so many posts and threads end up in personal attacks: we strive to be unbiased here : I am format neutral and enjoy both HD DVD and Blu ray: for me that is the only way to enjoy the best of both

but I am going to have the last word by repeating this quote one more time:

“Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people” Eleanor Roosevelt