View Full Version : High Def Digest: Dawn of the Dead gets a solid 4/5 PQ...


MidnightWatcher
08-30-07, 01:04 AM
... and an even more solid 5/5 for AQ. :)

http://hddvd.highdefdigest.com/664/dawnothedead2004.html

Earlier this year, Universal seemed to be tossing any flick they had onto HD DVD, regardless of whether it showcased the high-def format or not. The result was a sobering number of HD DVD duds that offered little upgrade over their standard DVD counterparts. More recently, however, the studio seems to have reversed that pattern, offering up a series of quality HD transfers. 'Dawn of the Dead' continues the trend, turning in a strong 1080p/VC-1 encode that looks much better than its DVD predeccessor.

Although the film's palette is starkly bleached and awash with blues and grays, primaries still pop and reds are particularly healthy. Shadow delineation is quite strong, with visibility in the shadows both deep and naturalistic. Black levels occasionally seem overbearing, but only in scenes where darkness is used to good effect. Skintones are intentionally pale, but exhibit excellent texture detail that renders hair, pores, and clothing fibers with ease.

The film boasts impressive fine details as well -- the mall setting is a jackpot of small background elements that look quite good. Tiny writing, ammo shells, leaves, and droplets of water are all sharp and rarely falter. There are some moments when shots drift out of focus, but the effect seemed intentional to me -- as if to capture the disorienting panic of the on-screen survivors. I also couldn't find any instances of the kind intrusive edge enhancement that has haunted many of Universal's poorer releases....

I really can't say enough good things about the TrueHD 5.1 surround mix (48kHz/16-bit/18 Mbps) that Universal has produced for this HD DVD. Paired the film's onslaught of screams, gunshots, and revving engines, the result is nothing short of spectacular. The zombies have a wet, throaty throttle to their moans that seems to emanate from every channel, while treble tones are stable and the sub woofer rumbles effectively on more than one occasion. Simply put, the dynamics of this mix will put your surround system through its paces.

Despite the explosions of violence that occur at regular intervals, dialogue remains crisp and well prioritized. Even more importantly, the mix takes full advantage of the rear channels to deliver an immersive and convincing soundscape. There were even a few occasions where I was fooled into thinking a sound was occurring in my home rather than in the film's soundfield. Combine that with exacting accuracy of pans between channels and 'Dawn of the Dead' reveals itself as a top tier audio track that left me with zero complaints.

vancouver
08-30-07, 01:54 AM
Sweat.
I love horror and zombie movies.

valmont74
08-30-07, 02:16 AM
Any news if this is optically cencored like the US DVD (despite being unrated)?

hlindstr
08-30-07, 03:05 AM
Any news if this is optically cencored like the US DVD (despite being unrated)?
There is another thread in this forum where this topic was already discussed. It seems that US unrated is still optically cencored (that short boob shot) in HD DVD.

tsb
08-30-07, 06:17 AM
I thought this was the original.. What a disappointment. :(

John Ballentine
08-30-07, 07:42 AM
I thought this was the original.. What a disappointment. :(

I did too for a short second! However - I see the original IS due to be released on October 2nd along w/ Day Of The Dead - but only on Blu-ray. (good reason I guess to be format neutral)

Ergoguy34
08-30-07, 07:54 AM
I can agree more wit the review, I spent last night enjoying this flick..

Kolgar
08-30-07, 08:50 AM
I bought this day one, and later came home to order myself a new A2 and three movies from Amazon. :)

But... where's my HD boob shot? :confused:

rboster
08-30-07, 08:59 AM
I need to recalibrate my projector. I thought details were lost in the darker scenes....I don't think it was artistic intent. I really love this film too. I may take sometime this weekend to compare some of those scenes to the Japanese release...I don't remember having problems with shadow detail

Bleddyn H Williams
08-30-07, 10:36 AM
I need to recalibrate my projector. I thought details were lost in the darker scenes....I don't think it was artistic intent. I really love this film too. I may take sometime this weekend to compare some of those scenes to the Japanese release...I don't remember having problems with shadow detail

I haven't watched my HD DVD yet, but I do recall that when I watched my R3 DVD it was about the only time I actually brightened the image from the default settings on my ISF calibrated RPTV. The image was very dark, and this has probably been carried through to the new HD DVD.

Although I never tend to touch the settings, for this disc, lightening a little might help.

rboster
08-30-07, 10:57 AM
I haven't watched my HD DVD yet, but I do recall that when I watched my R3 DVD it was about the only time I actually brightened the image from the default settings on my ISF calibrated RPTV. The image was very dark, and this has probably been carried through to the new HD DVD.

Although I never tend to touch the settings, for this disc, lightening a little might help.

I had to do the same thing last night...but one shouldn't have to...assuming it's not the director's intent and it's been transfered correctly...which by the positive comments of the highdef reviewer they were seeing better shadow detail than I was...which stood out to me as a big problem from the opening sequence of Anna and her husband in the bedroom/turning zombie to a fair number of scenes in the mall and garage. Facial details were lost on a number of occasions. Shadow detail hasn't been a problem with other titles and my BenQ 8720. I have 700 hours on it...but have adjusted accordingly along the way....but last night stood out big time with this title.

I would love to hear others comments...esp. if your display has been ISF calibrated.

Thanks
Ron

Rom
08-30-07, 11:02 AM
I got this movie last week but only flicked through it to look at the quality of the transfer. One thing that struck me was, near the beginning, where the screen has a flare of yellow/gold, I saw quite bad posterization. Has anyone else noticed this?

Bit more info: it is after the 'Strike' logo at the beginning, where it 'morphs' into a skull. Not sure wether it is intentional, limit of the effect etc. Just an observation.

Suppose I will have to watch the whole movie :D

jbug
08-30-07, 11:04 AM
Just got this from Netflix yesterday and will be watching tonight. My wife hates zombie movies. When I use to play Resident Evil she would run for cover because of the sound the lumbering zombies would make. I still tease her about that. Speaking of Zombies, I hope Rob does a good job with Halloween.

jblank74
08-30-07, 01:02 PM
Sweat.
I love horror and zombie movies.

Sweat?:p

Don't ya mean sweet.

metalsaber
08-30-07, 01:46 PM
Watched it last night. Some scenes were absolutely amazing. Then there were some that just lacked pop and seemed rather bleh. I still love the movie and it does look better than the DVD.

MattGuyOR
08-30-07, 02:36 PM
This got a 100 for picture and sound quality both at dvdverdict.

http://www.dvdverdict.com/reviews/dawndeadhddvd.php

thewretched22
08-30-07, 04:05 PM
Great news, can't wait till my copy arrives.

maingon
08-30-07, 04:40 PM
got it and on my 92" screen it looks great. Fantastic PQ. Some scenes are unbelievable. THe AQ is awesome :)

valmont74
08-30-07, 05:15 PM
There is another thread in this forum where this topic was already discussed. It seems that US unrated is still optically cencored (that short boob shot) in HD DVD.

Bummer! Are there any international versions announced?

ADBNZ
08-30-07, 10:27 PM
TrueHD 5.1 surround mix (48kHz/16-bit/18 Mbps)

Does High Def Digest ever get a disc's specifications right?

Looking forward to this disc. One of my favorite movies of the last five years!

Darcy Hunter
08-30-07, 11:06 PM
One thing that struck me was, near the beginning, where the screen has a flare of yellow/gold, I saw quite bad posterization. Has anyone else noticed this?


I noticed this too. it happens when the "Strike" logo morphs into the x-ray of the skull. I was watching it on my new 42" Hitachi plasma, and I thought it was maybe a limitation of my display. I was watching it via 360 add on set at 1080i.

I'll have to check it out on my Pioneer 532SD RPTV that's hooked up to my HD-A1.


... and the boob shot is still censored on my Canadian release (it has a bilingual cover).

agentalbert
09-26-07, 03:11 PM
At what time does this censored shot occur? Can you tell me specifically what to look for? As the boob is covered, I can't look for a boob. I saw it in the theater, but don't remember exactly what we're talking about here. I just want to look at my sd-dvd and see what was done.

metalsaber
09-26-07, 07:06 PM
When you see the shot from inside the car. The naked girls walks by disoriented but the blood marks on the windshield block da boobies.

This is when she is stopped at the bus wreckage.

Topweasel
09-26-07, 08:21 PM
When you see the shot from inside the car. The naked girls walks by disoriented but the blood marks on the windshield block da boobies.

This is when she is stopped at the bus wreckage.

Funny thing is you can still see the boobs.

Goatse
09-26-07, 08:44 PM
Loved this movie, top notch SQ and Picture.

Dave Mack
09-26-07, 08:47 PM
I actually bought the R3 Korean dvd back in the day just to REALLY have the uncut version!