View Full Version : Marantz VP15S1 vs. Planar PD8150??


mankite
09-12-07, 09:16 PM
Any input from people that saw both at Cedia would be appreciated.

BobL
09-13-07, 10:35 AM
That is a tough one. First they are not shown in the same environment so comparisons are tough. Marantz had a better overall demo including much better sound. Planar was demoing their PJs in a darkened conference room compared to Marantz which was a small theater setting. Planar was showing a range of their PJs for dealers and not trying to give you a HT experience. Subjectively, I'd say the Planar will be brighter so depending on your room conditions and lighting that might factor in your decision. But, this is a tough comparison. Both are good projectors.

Bob