View Full Version : There must be a scientific way to test the integrity of cables that send digital info


Vermonster
09-23-07, 05:51 PM
There seems to be a lot of talk about expensive "high-end" HDMI cables vs. the regular cheap stuff. One camp of people seem to be alleging that if it's a digital signal, the 0s and 1s will either get through or they won't. On the opposite end you have people talking about interference, signal drop-out, syncing issues etc.

I can appreciate that there are people out there who have a more discerning eye than others, but using the human eye to test integrity of data transmission seems kind of silly to me. There HAS to be a way to check data integrity reliably and objectively with a piece of hardware (or software). Haven't these tests been done? Fine, if there is some loss, then I think double blinded visual tests could be used to see if the human eye can actually discern a difference, but it seems as though we're still arguing about the basics.

tokerblue
09-23-07, 07:58 PM
PC World did an extensive test.

http://www.pcworld.com/article/id,121777-page,1/article.html

mrmike
09-24-07, 12:25 PM
There are ways to measure the quality of digital signals in timing and in level. They are, oddly enough, called Eye Diagrams or Eye Charts. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eye_pattern) The wiki page linked is very sparse, but any decent amount of google-fu should provide you with more data than you could ever want. Most receivers can more than make up for the degradation caused by most short-to-medium run cables in a digital domain problem (assuming no MFG defects) but it's really the combination of the two (Hmm, a system who'd have thunk it) that determines whether you have issues or not.

digital_dilemma
09-28-07, 12:44 PM
There are ways to measure the quality of digital signals in timing and in level. They are, oddly enough, called Eye Diagrams or Eye Charts. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eye_pattern) The wiki page linked is very sparse, but any decent amount of google-fu should provide you with more data than you could ever want. Most receivers can more than make up for the degradation caused by most short-to-medium run cables in a digital domain problem (assuming no MFG defects) but it's really the combination of the two (Hmm, a system who'd have thunk it) that determines whether you have issues or not.

Go to: http://www.simplayhd.com/index.aspx

This organization is testing now. Any product with this certification is guaranteed to work in a system where all components have the SimplayHD logo.