Otokejr
10-28-07, 01:30 PM
Are the Pioneer plasmas still the only ones that properly display 1080p/24? I'm looking to buy a 50" model by years end, and would like to spend less money if there is another manufacturer that displays this properly.
|
View Full Version : 1080p/24 plasma Otokejr 10-28-07, 01:30 PM Are the Pioneer plasmas still the only ones that properly display 1080p/24? I'm looking to buy a 50" model by years end, and would like to spend less money if there is another manufacturer that displays this properly. RAM021 10-28-07, 07:44 PM The Samsung FP-T 5084 / 5884 / 6374 all properly display 1080p24. D-Nice 10-28-07, 10:46 PM The Samsung FP-T 5084 / 5884 / 6374 all properly display 1080p24.Displaying 1080p/24 @ 60Hz isn't "proper";) It's best to just say they accept 1080p/24. Ashop 10-28-07, 11:05 PM The Panny 65PF10UK manual says: A) The unit accepts a 24 fps input and and B) The unit does NOT perform a 3:2 pulldown on a 24fps input signal and C) The unit displays 24fps signals at a 50hz or 100hz refresh rate (without 3:2) Will the display of this signal type likely be equal to that of a unit that is doing a 3:2 pulldown, or will it likely be better (i.e. have less judder, etc.)? Can anybody explain or guess how all of this is supposedly working together? D-Nice 10-28-07, 11:10 PM The Panny 65PF10UK manual says: A) The unit accepts a 24 fps input and and B) The unit does NOT perform a 3:2 pulldown on a 24fps input signal and C) The unit displays 24fps signals at a 50hz or 100hz refresh rate (without 3:2) Will the display of this signal type likely be equal to that of a unit that is doing a 3:2 pulldown, or will it likely be better (i.e. have less judder, etc.)? Can anybody explain or guess how all of this is supposedly working together?Judder. It will look like PAL on a NTSC display that does not accept PAL signals. Ashop 10-28-07, 11:14 PM But will there be meaningfully less judder? Or is the 24fps signal handling on these units completely worthless? if it is copying an extra frame to make 25 frames and then display it at 50hz (or 100hz), will that produce just a much notciable judder as doing a full/normal 3:2 pulldown? Or is there SOME degree of improvement from this method that Panny might be using???? Are there degrees of judder here? JC7727 10-28-07, 11:26 PM But will there be meanginfully less judder? Or is the 24fps signal handling and these units completely worthless? if it is copying an extra fram to make 25 frames and then display it at 50hz (or 100hz), will that produce just a much notciable judder as doing a full/normal 3:2 pulldown? Or is there SOME degree of imporvement from this method that Panny might be using???? seems worthless to me. D-Nice 10-29-07, 12:12 AM But will there be meaningfully less judder? Or is the 24fps signal handling on these units completely worthless? if it is copying an extra frame to make 25 frames and then display it at 50hz (or 100hz), will that produce just a much notciable judder as doing a full/normal 3:2 pulldown? Or is there SOME degree of improvement from this method that Panny might be using???? Are there degrees of judder here?No where in the literature does it state it's adding an additional frame. It's going to output 24 fames at 50 or 100Hz which is dumb IMO. Completely worthless. Ashop 10-29-07, 12:40 AM But on Page 44 of the 65PF10UK manual (under the 3:2 pulldown section) it says that the unit's 3:2 pulldown occurs only on other, NON-24fps, input signals. It states that NTSC/PAL signals are processed ONLY from an S-video input connection.... mikechorney 10-29-07, 07:50 AM Are you sure it's not talking about reverse 3:2? (i.e. converting an interlaced signal to progressive?) It wouldn't need to apply 3:2 to a non-24fps signal (because it would have already been applied), it would need to use reverse 3:2. Ashop 10-29-07, 08:18 AM But then it would still have to do a forward pulldown AFTER the reverse pulldown, no? RAM021 10-29-07, 10:47 AM Displaying 1080p/24 @ 60Hz isn't "proper";) It's best to just say they accept 1080p/24. On mine, when I pump 1080p24 into the TV, it displays a 24Hz refresh rate... take that for what it is worth. D-Nice 10-29-07, 10:54 AM On mine, when I pump 1080p24 into the TV, it displays a 24Hz refresh rate... take that for what it is worth.If your panel is displaying anything at only a 24Hz refresh rate, you are going to see a LOT of flicker. D-Nice 10-29-07, 10:58 AM But on Page 44 of the 65PF10UK manual (under the 3:2 pulldown section) it says that the unit's 3:2 pulldown occurs only on other, NON-24fps, input signals. It states that NTSC/PAL signals are processed ONLY from an S-video input connection....Adding one frame to a 24fps signal (to make it 25fps) has nothing to do with 3:2 pulldown. Adding that additional frame would be classified as converting NTSC to PAL. That is not what the 10Uk is going to do. Ashop 10-29-07, 12:02 PM Creating a 25fps signal (which would easily then be displayed at the 50hz refresh rate of the unit) seems like it would create less judder than using traditional 3:2 pulldown from a non-24fps source. No? Maybe? This seems to be one of the few ways that the PF10UK unit might work given the operating specs in the new manual. |