View Full Version : Pans Labyrinth Region Coded? Or BD Mistake Carried Over


qz3fwd
12-24-07, 03:13 PM
I picked up the HD-DVD last night at BB's B2G1F and the back has a Region A designation.
Is this just a mistake carried over from the BD version artwork/jacket as HD doesnt have any region coding I thought?

GamerGuyX
12-24-07, 03:38 PM
You cannot code a region into a movie who's format has no region coding. So yes, it is a typo.

tahustvedt
12-24-07, 03:56 PM
I think it's a mistake that has happened with the cover of a few other titles as well.

obispo21
12-24-07, 04:10 PM
DVD Empire has good images of the back covers of each title, so you can compare the HD DVD & Blu-ray. It does look like a carry over from BD.

It looks like the BD is missing the Web Enhanced features, but kept the visual commentary. (I'm not sure if it was done via dual encodes or Profile 1.1 functionality.)

Also, did anyone else's Pan's have a slightly new style of HD DVD case? Mine came in an "Elite" case like all other WB titles, but the HD DVD logo is now "reverse" engraved / stamped with no silver color at all. It looks pretty neat, but is also very hard to see.

LiquidX
12-24-07, 04:12 PM
Also, did anyone else's Pan's have a slightly new style of HD DVD case? Mine came in an "Elite" case like all other WB titles, but the HD DVD logo is now "reverse" engraved / stamped with no silver color at all. It looks pretty neat, but is also very hard to see.

Noticed that on a few titles at Best Buy yesterday, it's rather odd.

aaronwt
12-24-07, 04:45 PM
DVD Empire has good images of the back covers of each title, so you can compare the HD DVD & Blu-ray. It does look like a carry over from BD.

It looks like the BD is missing the Web Enhanced features, but kept the visual commentary. (I'm not sure if it was done via dual encodes or Profile 1.1 functionality.)

Also, did anyone else's Pan's have a slightly new style of HD DVD case? Mine came in an "Elite" case like all other WB titles, but the HD DVD logo is now "reverse" engraved / stamped with no silver color at all. It looks pretty neat, but is also very hard to see.

The logo is on the inside of the case so you are looking at it through the red case instead of being on the outside like it is on other cases.

NoThru22
12-24-07, 05:39 PM
Maybe it's just the sales region code?

erkq
12-24-07, 05:48 PM
You cannot code a region into a movie who's format has no region coding. So yes, it is a typo.

I thought there WAS region coding but no one has opted to use it yet. I thought we were just lucky so far. This is great news (to me, anyway) if true!

Volitar Prime
12-24-07, 09:45 PM
Also, did anyone else's Pan's have a slightly new style of HD DVD case? Mine came in an "Elite" case like all other WB titles, but the HD DVD logo is now "reverse" engraved / stamped with no silver color at all. It looks pretty neat, but is also very hard to see.Another thing I noticed is that the paper sleeve is printed 2 sided, you can see the back side of it through the transparent red case.

steven975
12-24-07, 10:36 PM
I thought there WAS region coding but no one has opted to use it yet. I thought we were just lucky so far. This is great news (to me, anyway) if true!

no there is the image constraint token which would convert analog output to near-SD but that has not been used. HD-DVD has no region coding in the spec...a big reason disney didn't join in.

erkq
12-25-07, 02:38 AM
no there is the image constraint token which would convert analog output to near-SD but that has not been used.

That's right. I knew there was something bad that no one had used yet.

shomchuen
12-25-07, 10:52 AM
That's right. I knew there was something bad that no one had used yet.

no there is the image constraint token which would convert analog output to near-SD but that has not been used. HD-DVD has no region coding in the spec...a big reason disney didn't join in.

Highlight Germany uses ICT on their HD DVDs thus far. Fantastic Four, Resident Evil, Resident Evil: Apocalypse, Fantastic Four: Rise of The Silver Surfer will display at 480p max over component video cables.

tbase1
12-25-07, 11:05 AM
Is this movie in spanish only or did best buy sell me a spanish instead of a english version.

Sinastar
12-25-07, 11:17 AM
Is this movie in spanish only or did best buy sell me a spanish instead of a english version.

Spanish dialog only.

GamerGuyX
12-25-07, 11:20 AM
Is this movie in spanish only or did best buy sell me a spanish instead of a english version.

It's in Spanish. Thats the great thing about the high-def formats, the main audio is always the original language track. No god-awful dubbing.

tbase1
12-25-07, 11:23 AM
back to the moive then. I thought the picture in the first 2 min. looked pretty good. Thanks guys

akbled
12-25-07, 12:56 PM
Isn't this a combo disc? If so then the region coding would apply to the dvd side.

OggideM
12-25-07, 01:03 PM
Isn't this a combo disc? If so then the region coding would apply to the dvd side.

def. not a combo

Kentai
12-25-07, 05:24 PM
Come now, HD DVD and Blu-Ray still have dubs. They just aren't usually lossless. :)

Pan's Labyrinth just never got an English dub, which is a little surprising in the scheme of things. It was dubbed into French, Italian and Russian at the very least.