View Full Version : some format questions!!


Tread
02-09-08, 01:29 PM
a few questions here...

first, what dolby formats carry 7.1 channels of audio? I always see dts specifying how many channels, is it the same with dolby. Will it say, dolby truhd 7.1 if it is 7.1?


ssecond, I have a ps3, which I am aware doesn't decode dts-hd ma. So, if my disc I'm watching has dts-hd ma 7.1, does the ps3 still send the 7 channels to the receiver in pcm? Or what if I send it bitstream? What will the receiver do with it then?

thanks!

Phantom Stranger
02-09-08, 10:25 PM
Right now the PS3 will send the core audio track of the DTS-HD MA soundtrack via bitstream. Typically the core of DTS-HD MA is a 1.5 mbps DTS track with 5.1 channels.

Tread
02-10-08, 01:54 PM
so, right now, there is no way to get the 7 channels of audio out of a dts track on a ps3?

that sucks...

neil wilkes
02-11-08, 04:18 PM
so, right now, there is no way to get the 7 channels of audio out of a dts track on a ps3?

that sucks...

Talk to Sony!
Also, you really need to consider that a PS3 is not designed as an HD or a Music player. It is a games console first & foremost.
Sony may claim it is a BD player - they count PS3 sales as Blu Ray player sales - but that is pure sophistry.
If you go get an HD DVD or a Blu Ray player, as well as a reciever with the DTS-HD decoders - you will get the right audio out of it. It is, after all, the machine designed for the job.

DTS-HD MAS is awesome. The beauty of it is the way that all options are carried in just one single stream.
You can create the 7.1 Lossless version, include a 5.1 downmix, a 2.0 downmix, as well as the Core Audio (legacy streams) in up to 24/96 5.1 at 1.5MBPS.
With Dobly True HD, you need the HD stream as well as a Dobly Dirgital one.

Finally, why not go get a copy of the DTS-HD MAS encoder?
It's admittedly $1500 - but you get the full encoder as well as a streamplayer that will play the audio right off the computer into your soundcard.
You can also inxclude a quicktime video as well.
A copy of AnyDVD-HD will rip the BD or HD DVD discs, getting the audio onto your HDD. You can also archive everything to .dtshd MAS as well.

Luvverly.

Tread
02-11-08, 07:14 PM
well, from what I've found, it seems the ps3 is one of better blu-ray players out there, and is future proof, which apparently, no other BD players are.

And what, buy the encoder for $1500? Ummm, no thanks.

Phantom Stranger
02-11-08, 08:23 PM
well, from what I've found, it seems the ps3 is one of better blu-ray players out there, and is future proof, which apparently, no other BD players are.

And what, buy the encoder for $1500? Ummm, no thanks.

You do realize that virtually everyone believes Sony will update the PS3's firmware within the next six months to decode DTS-HD MA internally for full lossless resolution. The beauty of the PS3 is that because of its computing power that it can do virtually anything via software updates.

Tread
02-11-08, 08:31 PM
I've heard it's coming, just didn't know when. Can't wait for that day!

neil wilkes
02-13-08, 10:18 AM
well, from what I've found, it seems the ps3 is one of better blu-ray players out there, and is future proof, which apparently, no other BD players are.

It is still primarily a games console. The apparent fact it plays BD better than dedicated BD players does not say much for the format at all.

And what, buy the encoder for $1500? Ummm, no thanks.

Your Call.
But if you want to archive material in lossless form & have the ability to play it right off your HDD into a reciever, then this is the way to go.
It's not expensive for what you get.