ATI Radeon 3870 - Horizontal scan lines during video playback

bnieman · 09-10-08, 10:53 PM

Video content, including all video played through Windows Media Player and YouTube via Internet Explorer or FireFox, yield horizontal scan lines during playback. The lines appear for a fraction of a second during fast panning, action, or abrupt scene changes. The problem is extremely noticeable when trying to watch a movie and is very distracting. When viewing a video in a window, the scan lines are contained in the video frame and do not affect the rest of the screen. I have tried many different screens including multiple monitors via DVI and a HDTV home theater projector via HDMI.

I cannot take a screen shot of the problem, the screen shot displays perfectly. Instead I took the above photo with my digital camera, notice the line in the top half of the picture. Can this be fixed or is it a problem with my video card?

I have gone through all the settings in Catalyst Control Center including pulldown detection and anti-aliasing with no success. The problem has been prevalent since the purchase of the card and has continued through multiple driver updates (currently I am running Catalyst version 8.8).

The problem seems to be worst in Flash videos, MKV, and Xvid files. I have tried (2) different codec packs with the same result with both.

Here is some relevant information:
OS: Windows Vista Ultimate x64
Video Card: MSI Radeon HD 3870 512MB PCI-e
Driver Version: Catalyst 8.8
Memory: 4GB
Processor: Intel Core 2 Quad Core q9300 @ 2.5ghz
Video Players Used: Windows Media Player 11, Media Player Classic, Flash Plugin for Internet Explorer 7, Firefox 2, and Firefox 3

sneakerx · 09-10-08, 11:07 PM

I've noticed that when Aero is turned on I no longer have screen tearing, which is what you are experiencing.

bnieman · 09-10-08, 11:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sneakerx

I've noticed that when Aero is turned on I no longer have screen tearing, which is what you are experiencing.

Sneakerx,
Your suggestion definitely helped but it still isn't flawless. I still get the "screen tearing" just not as often or as bad.

The reason I was not using Aero is when using Aero every so often my screen goes blank for a second and comes back and says "atikmdag stopped responding then recovered". It started happening every few days or so and then recently it started happening a few times a day so I just went to the Vista Basic theme.

Thanks for your suggestion, it definitely makes the video more watchable. Do you think the problem would be non-existent in Windows XP?

Cheers,
Bryan

terryj47 · 09-11-08, 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bnieman

Sneakerx,
Your suggestion definitely helped but it still isn't flawless. I still get the "screen tearing" just not as often or as bad.

The reason I was not using Aero is when using Aero every so often my screen goes blank for a second and comes back and says "atikmdag stopped responding then recovered". It started happening every few days or so and then recently it started happening a few times a day so I just went to the Vista Basic theme.

Thanks for your suggestion, it definitely makes the video more watchable. Do you think the problem would be non-existent in Windows XP?

Cheers,
Bryan

I get this sometimes while watching a video online while browsing. IE lauches media player. If I download it and watch it it's fine. My HDTV stuff-- live or recorded using Media CENTER is fine although I had to give up on the HD 3870 card due to video stutter. Read my thread by searching for "more media center stuttering". Good luck.

sneakerx · 09-11-08, 07:46 AM

Make sure your computer's refresh rate matches whatever your display is capable of(e.g. 60Hz, 59.94Hz, etc). You might want to try Media Player Classic Homecinema as well, and use EVR custom as the renderer. If that doesn't get rid of it then there's also an option in there to turn on vsync, though he calls it something else, to match the video playback to the displays refresh rate eliminating tearing completely. I've posted the following about ATIKMDAG before from the Hellgate: London forums, but haven't had the problem since using Catalyst 8.5 and 8.6, so I don't know if it really works:

-----

http://forums.anandtech.com/messagev...readid=2060689

Basic instructions:

1. From the search box in the start menu run "msconfig.exe"
2. Switch to the boot tab, and open advanced options.
3. At the top of the new box that opens, tick both the "Number of processors" and "Maximum memory" options and set them to the correct values for your system. NOTE THAT MULTIPLE CORES DO NOT MEAN MULTIPLE PROCESSORS!!
4. Also tick the option for "Detect HAL"
5. Click OK to close advanced options. Back on the boot tab tick "Make all boot settings permanent", click apply and confirm your choice. Finally click OK to close msconfig.exe.
6. Restart your system.

After these changes I immediately found my system both more responsive and more stable. I usually was seeing the ATIKMDAG error within minutes of loading the system, but now have not seen the error in 10+ hours puttering around windows. The crashes in HG:L have also not reappeared after 4+ hours in game (Usually I could only play for 30-45 minutes before crashing or freezing).

bnieman · 09-11-08, 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by terryj47

I get this sometimes while watching a video online while browsing. IE lauches media player. If I download it and watch it it's fine. My HDTV stuff-- live or recorded using Media CENTER is fine although I had to give up on the HD 3870 card due to video stutter. Read my thread by searching for "more media center stuttering". Good luck.

Terry,
I perused your 4 page thread on video stuttering, I am sorry you had to go through that! I hate problems like which is what my problem seems to be turning into

I am glad you were able to get your system running smoothly though.

I get the tearing on web videos and downloaded material, although turning Aero on seemed to alleviate most if not all tearing on web content. Now I am just dealing with tearing on downloaded content (although not as severe as the screen shot I posted as that was what the web video was doing).

I will post any updates here.

bryan

magnusr · 09-11-08, 11:11 AM

I have this if both monitors is enabled and playing video. If I make my 42" the main screen and disable the second screen in control center wizard, problem goes away. This is on 4850.

bnieman · 09-11-08, 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by magnusr

I have this if both monitors is enabled and playing video. If I make my 42" the main screen and disable the second screen in control center wizard, problem goes away. This is on 4850.

Magnusr,

Thank you for your input. I have tried to disable the second screen and it had no affect on the problem.

Bryan

bnieman · 09-11-08, 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sneakerx

Make sure your computer's refresh rate matches whatever your display is capable of(e.g. 60Hz, 59.94Hz, etc). You might want to try Media Player Classic Homecinema as well, and use EVR custom as the renderer. If that doesn't get rid of it then there's also an option in there to turn on vsync, though he calls it something else, to match the video playback to the displays refresh rate eliminating tearing completely. I've posted the following about ATIKMDAG before from the Hellgate: London forums, but haven't had the problem since using Catalyst 8.5 and 8.6, so I don't know if it really works:

-----

http://forums.anandtech.com/messagev...readid=2060689

Basic instructions:

1. From the search box in the start menu run "msconfig.exe"
2. Switch to the boot tab, and open advanced options.
3. At the top of the new box that opens, tick both the "Number of processors" and "Maximum memory" options and set them to the correct values for your system. NOTE THAT MULTIPLE CORES DO NOT MEAN MULTIPLE PROCESSORS!!
4. Also tick the option for "Detect HAL"
5. Click OK to close advanced options. Back on the boot tab tick "Make all boot settings permanent", click apply and confirm your choice. Finally click OK to close msconfig.exe.
6. Restart your system.

After these changes I immediately found my system both more responsive and more stable. I usually was seeing the ATIKMDAG error within minutes of loading the system, but now have not seen the error in 10+ hours puttering around windows. The crashes in HG:L have also not reappeared after 4+ hours in game (Usually I could only play for 30-45 minutes before crashing or freezing).

Sneakerx,
I have matched the computer's refresh rate with rates capable by the monitors.

I tried your suggestion of using Media Player Classic Home Cinema and the problem still persists. I tried using EVR as the renderer and enabling the screen tearing option. I tried both x86 (32bit) and x64 (64bit) version of the application and tearing was the same on both, but the video quality was DRASTICALLY worse on the x64 version. It made the video look highly compressed and blotchy.

If the atikmdag error comes upa again I will try your solution, but for now I am going to concentrate on the tearing.

Thanks for your ideas! Very good input. I will keep working on it and report back.

Bryan

bnieman · 09-15-08, 08:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sneakerx

Make sure your computer's refresh rate matches whatever your display is capable of(e.g. 60Hz, 59.94Hz, etc). You might want to try Media Player Classic Homecinema as well, and use EVR custom as the renderer. If that doesn't get rid of it then there's also an option in there to turn on vsync, though he calls it something else, to match the video playback to the displays refresh rate eliminating tearing completely. I've posted the following about ATIKMDAG before from the Hellgate: London forums, but haven't had the problem since using Catalyst 8.5 and 8.6, so I don't know if it really works:

-----

http://forums.anandtech.com/messagev...readid=2060689

Basic instructions:

1. From the search box in the start menu run "msconfig.exe"
2. Switch to the boot tab, and open advanced options.
3. At the top of the new box that opens, tick both the "Number of processors" and "Maximum memory" options and set them to the correct values for your system. NOTE THAT MULTIPLE CORES DO NOT MEAN MULTIPLE PROCESSORS!!
4. Also tick the option for "Detect HAL"
5. Click OK to close advanced options. Back on the boot tab tick "Make all boot settings permanent", click apply and confirm your choice. Finally click OK to close msconfig.exe.
6. Restart your system.

After these changes I immediately found my system both more responsive and more stable. I usually was seeing the ATIKMDAG error within minutes of loading the system, but now have not seen the error in 10+ hours puttering around windows. The crashes in HG:L have also not reappeared after 4+ hours in game (Usually I could only play for 30-45 minutes before crashing or freezing).

I tried following the above steps to resolve the ATIKMDAG error but it did not help. Today the error came up about 6 times in a row followed by a blue screen of death. I am thinking about reinstalling Vista and forgoing the Catalyst Control Center. Does anyone know if I can still set the output to my projector to 24hz without CCC? What other functionality do I lose?

I think enabling Aero fixed the screen tearing issue but intermittent times during playback of AVI and MKV files there is still a line of pixels that do not match up with the rest of the image. The location of this line varies... it is not very noticeable and if I wasn't the perfectionist I am I probably wouldn't notice it. I want to run some more tests with different source material, I will report back in case anyone is watching this thread.

infoman9 · 10-24-08, 04:20 PM

This has got to be a problem with ATI Catalyst. All worked great until I used it to change an option and all of a sudden one night I noticed my screen saver had the exact same symtom as the pic below.

Also games and vids won't display without it. I've tried every conceivable combination of resolutions and scan rates but nothing works to get rid of it.

Going to try completely removing Catalyst and will post back if I'm successful.

Otherwise MAinGear is sending me a new card to try out.

infoman9 · 10-24-08, 06:02 PM

Removed all drivers and ati catalyst software. no luck.

Still have what looks like pic at top of thread. Worse with higher gpu load.

I'm not a happy camper.

nintari · 10-24-08, 10:03 PM

in your 3D options go to all settings and set v-sync to always on, then try things out

infoman9 · 10-24-08, 11:45 PM

Ok, I have eliminated the tearing. What I did: (I hope I can get this straight)

Uninstalled all ATI.
Uninstalled video card entries from device mgr without restarting
manually updated ati card drivers from cd instead of running ati installer
installed ati ccc
rebooted

seems to have fixed my problems

Note: With wait for vertical refresh (vsync) on I was still having the problem before I performed above procedure. Now there is minimal tearing and only with gpu intensive stuff. With vsync checked there is no evidence of tearing whatsoever. Looks Great!

If anyone else can't get this to work I'll backtrack and try it again to make sure I got my steps right.

This is obviously a driver/ati control center problem. Oh, I'm using the beta download of catalyst 8.6, not the regular one.

infoman9 · 10-27-08, 04:03 PM

Wow, I hate to think I went through all that for nothing but that may be the case.

After updating to all latest versions and getting the problem back I realized that Wait for Vertical Refresh setting was somehow reverting to "off unless app specifies". Why would this change?

After setting it back to "on unless app specifies" my tearing prob goes away. If a game or app chooses to not wait for vertical refresh does the option revert to the default setting in CCC?

?????

toolio · 11-10-08, 12:31 PM

I have experienced the tearing problem on a number of different ATI cards, all on different computers, all connected with different TVs and using various versions of Catalyst.

In all cases, it exists only when the card is running a monitor and TV simultaneously. If I configure a profile for TV only, it seems to go away.

I am getting the same thing again with a 4670 i just installed a week or so ago.

09-10-08, 10:53 PM	#1 \| Link	<a href='http://rev.avsforum.com/phpAdsNew/adclick.php?n=a4ac4393' target='_blank'><img src='http://rev.avsforum.com/phpAdsNew/adview.php?what=zone:30&n=a4ac4393' border='0' alt=''></a>
bnieman Member Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 117	ATI Radeon 3870 - Horizontal scan lines during video playback Video content, including all video played through Windows Media Player and YouTube via Internet Explorer or FireFox, yield horizontal scan lines during playback. The lines appear for a fraction of a second during fast panning, action, or abrupt scene changes. The problem is extremely noticeable when trying to watch a movie and is very distracting. When viewing a video in a window, the scan lines are contained in the video frame and do not affect the rest of the screen. I have tried many different screens including multiple monitors via DVI and a HDTV home theater projector via HDMI. I cannot take a screen shot of the problem, the screen shot displays perfectly. Instead I took the above photo with my digital camera, notice the line in the top half of the picture. Can this be fixed or is it a problem with my video card? I have gone through all the settings in Catalyst Control Center including pulldown detection and anti-aliasing with no success. The problem has been prevalent since the purchase of the card and has continued through multiple driver updates (currently I am running Catalyst version 8.8). The problem seems to be worst in Flash videos, MKV, and Xvid files. I have tried (2) different codec packs with the same result with both. Here is some relevant information: OS: Windows Vista Ultimate x64 Video Card: MSI Radeon HD 3870 512MB PCI-e Driver Version: Catalyst 8.8 Memory: 4GB Processor: Intel Core 2 Quad Core q9300 @ 2.5ghz Video Players Used: Windows Media Player 11, Media Player Classic, Flash Plugin for Internet Explorer 7, Firefox 2, and Firefox 3

09-11-08, 07:46 AM	#5 \| Link	<a href='http://rev.avsforum.com/phpAdsNew/adclick.php?n=a591f81a' target='_blank'><img src='http://rev.avsforum.com/phpAdsNew/adview.php?what=zone:36&n=a591f81a' border='0' alt=''></a>
sneakerx Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 273	Make sure your computer's refresh rate matches whatever your display is capable of(e.g. 60Hz, 59.94Hz, etc). You might want to try Media Player Classic Homecinema as well, and use EVR custom as the renderer. If that doesn't get rid of it then there's also an option in there to turn on vsync, though he calls it something else, to match the video playback to the displays refresh rate eliminating tearing completely. I've posted the following about ATIKMDAG before from the Hellgate: London forums, but haven't had the problem since using Catalyst 8.5 and 8.6, so I don't know if it really works: ----- http://forums.anandtech.com/messagev...readid=2060689 Basic instructions: 1. From the search box in the start menu run "msconfig.exe" 2. Switch to the boot tab, and open advanced options. 3. At the top of the new box that opens, tick both the "Number of processors" and "Maximum memory" options and set them to the correct values for your system. NOTE THAT MULTIPLE CORES DO NOT MEAN MULTIPLE PROCESSORS!! 4. Also tick the option for "Detect HAL" 5. Click OK to close advanced options. Back on the boot tab tick "Make all boot settings permanent", click apply and confirm your choice. Finally click OK to close msconfig.exe. 6. Restart your system. After these changes I immediately found my system both more responsive and more stable. I usually was seeing the ATIKMDAG error within minutes of loading the system, but now have not seen the error in 10+ hours puttering around windows. The crashes in HG:L have also not reappeared after 4+ hours in game (Usually I could only play for 30-45 minutes before crashing or freezing). Last edited by sneakerx; 09-11-08 at 08:10 AM..

09-11-08, 11:11 AM	#7 \| Link
magnusr Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 371	I have this if both monitors is enabled and playing video. If I make my 42" the main screen and disable the second screen in control center wizard, problem goes away. This is on 4850. __________________ Pioneer SC-LX71 (Elite SC-05), Tannoy Eyris 3 + DCC + 1 + TS10, Samsung 52a866 52", Panasonic BD35, HTPC ATI 5870 Windows 7 x64 with blu-ray

10-24-08, 04:20 PM	#11 \| Link
infoman9 New Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 4	Same prob here with 4870x2, no joy. This has got to be a problem with ATI Catalyst. All worked great until I used it to change an option and all of a sudden one night I noticed my screen saver had the exact same symtom as the pic below. Also games and vids won't display without it. I've tried every conceivable combination of resolutions and scan rates but nothing works to get rid of it. Going to try completely removing Catalyst and will post back if I'm successful. Otherwise MAinGear is sending me a new card to try out.

10-24-08, 06:02 PM	#12 \| Link
infoman9 New Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 4	No Luck Removed all drivers and ati catalyst software. no luck. Still have what looks like pic at top of thread. Worse with higher gpu load. I'm not a happy camper.

09-10-08, 11:07 PM	#2 \| Link
sneakerx Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 273	I've noticed that when Aero is turned on I no longer have screen tearing, which is what you are experiencing.

10-24-08, 10:03 PM	#13 \| Link
nintari AVS Special Member Join Date: May 2002 Posts: 1,323	in your 3D options go to all settings and set v-sync to always on, then try things out

10-24-08, 11:45 PM	#14 \| Link
infoman9 New Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 4	got mine under control this way: Ok, I have eliminated the tearing. What I did: (I hope I can get this straight) Uninstalled all ATI. Uninstalled video card entries from device mgr without restarting manually updated ati card drivers from cd instead of running ati installer installed ati ccc rebooted seems to have fixed my problems Note: With wait for vertical refresh (vsync) on I was still having the problem before I performed above procedure. Now there is minimal tearing and only with gpu intensive stuff. With vsync checked there is no evidence of tearing whatsoever. Looks Great! If anyone else can't get this to work I'll backtrack and try it again to make sure I got my steps right. This is obviously a driver/ati control center problem. Oh, I'm using the beta download of catalyst 8.6, not the regular one.

10-27-08, 04:03 PM	#15 \| Link	<a href='http://rev.avsforum.com/phpAdsNew/adclick.php?n=a591f81a' target='_blank'><img src='http://rev.avsforum.com/phpAdsNew/adview.php?what=zone:36&n=a591f81a' border='0' alt=''></a>
infoman9 New Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 4	Wait for vertical refresh in CCC resetting to off Wow, I hate to think I went through all that for nothing but that may be the case. After updating to all latest versions and getting the problem back I realized that Wait for Vertical Refresh setting was somehow reverting to "off unless app specifies". Why would this change? After setting it back to "on unless app specifies" my tearing prob goes away. If a game or app chooses to not wait for vertical refresh does the option revert to the default setting in CCC? ?????

11-10-08, 12:31 PM	#16 \| Link
toolio Member Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 21	I have experienced the tearing problem on a number of different ATI cards, all on different computers, all connected with different TVs and using various versions of Catalyst. In all cases, it exists only when the card is running a monitor and TV simultaneously. If I configure a profile for TV only, it seems to go away. I am getting the same thing again with a 4670 i just installed a week or so ago.