ID subs outperform store bought subs. Any of the ID subs you mentioned are great. I have a hsu 2.3 and do not regret getting the 2.4 for q control. Also, I added a hsu 3.3 on the cheap used. Worked out nicely. Personally I would recommend the epik or hsu. X2 even, for cleaner, tighter bass like you want.
butter and jelly please.
Home theater gladly not designed by ereed or bgtighe23. 65" JS9500, Marantz 7702MKII, Parasound Halo A31, ClassDaudio SDS470 4ch, RBH R56, 4xRBH R55, 2x RBH R5, Hsu VTF 2 MK 3 and VTF 3 for subwoofage, OnStage MS7701B mic stand with boom for improved Audussey XT32 calibrations. Listening space happily treated with 1" OC 703 rigid fiberglass. OPPO 203 or 205 soon.