This is a site that has quite a few models compared. (Well I can't post URLs yet.) Go to smallnetbuilder dot com and navigate to the "LAN & Router" section, then the "Router Performance Charts" subsection.
Going off of the info there and other reviews a couple of my friends have purchased the D-Link DIR-655. They have only positive things to say about that model router. I plan to purchase the same model when I scratch together the money. The DIR-655 does have wireless, but in my price shopping it is almost the same price as comparable D-Link routers without wireless. Hope this helps in your search.