When the formats first came out, I saw (with my own eyes) that HD-DVDs tended to look either better or much better than BRs. Phantom of the Opera and King Kong were jaw dropping and every BR I saw (granted... on that troubled Samsung player) looked grainy and unnatural. What's more, the difference between the BR demo discs (which looked sensational) and the consumer software was unmissable.
I started reading the HD-DVD forum (where there is tremendous BR bashing) a few months ago, and it seemed quite clear to me that HD-DVD was the better format out of the gate.
Now, I still haven't purchased an HD player, and I get the sense that the gap may be narrowing. My number one priority is HD PQ, followed closely by SD-DVD upconversion (where it still appears clear that the Tosh XA2 dominates). The price difference is not important to me.
If I were reading this forum, rathern than that one, would I be convinced that BR is the way to go? Does everyone here feel like, in terms of HD PQ, BRs have caught up with or surpassed HD-DVDs? Does anyone here feel like a BR player can compete with the Tosh XA2 for SD upconversion?
Thanks for the opinions. Hopefully this honest inquiry into whether I'm being close minded about BR won't ignite any flames.
After 7 Years With a JVC RS1 - Starting to Get the Upgrade Itch