Deciding between two 5.1 systems (polk or infinity) - AVS Forum

AVS Forum > Home Entertainment & Theater Builder > General Home Theater & Media/Game Rooms > Deciding between two 5.1 systems (polk or infinity)

General Home Theater & Media/Game Rooms

panesar187's Avatar panesar187
08:27 PM Liked: 10
post #1 of 12
06-27-2010 | Posts: 18
Joined: Jun 2010
Hello everyone I am relatively new to the whole separates-based home theatre thing. After a great deal of research and in-store listening (as well as paying attention to the wallet), I've narrowed it down to two setups:

Infinity Primus 5.1: p362 floorstanding, pc250 center, p152 bookshelf, along with a ps-210 sub (300W RMS, 500 peak)
Polk Audio TSi: TSi 300 floorstanding, cs20 center, TSi 100 bookshelf, and the famous PSW110 sub (seemingly skimpy at 100rms/200peak).
Either will be hooked up to the Onkyo TX-SR608 7.2 receiver.
Both sounded great upon listening to them, but the Polks just had a little more "punch", than the Infinitys. The thing is, the infinity set is for $900, and the TSis are for roughly $1300
Aesthetics are beside the point here since I have a dedicated theater room.

So, which system is better for the price?
yepimonfire's Avatar yepimonfire
09:10 PM Liked: 10
post #2 of 12
06-27-2010 | Posts: 22
Joined: Jun 2010
polks subs have a bad habit of "unloading" below the port tuning frequency, i own a PSW10 and it works fine MOST of the time, but when the serious theater bass comes in i hear lots of chuffing and wu-wumping sounds. all i can say is no matter what you decide on with speakers, i would say go with the infinity sub, actually, if your willing to have something shipped (for free mind you) i would go with a dayton sub from parts express, cheaper then one of those and much better, i cannot speak for infinity's subs though since i have never heard one.
Remax's Avatar Remax
10:52 PM Liked: 10
post #3 of 12
06-27-2010 | Posts: 582
Joined: Jan 2007
If the infinity sounds good then go for that since it's $400 cheaper. If you enjoyed both, then im sure you will be happy with whatever you purchase. I have infinity speakers and really enjoy them a lot. Im sure there is better stuff out there, but I dont think of that in the middle of a movie.
panesar187's Avatar panesar187
11:42 PM Liked: 10
post #4 of 12
06-27-2010 | Posts: 18
Joined: Jun 2010
Well I'll mostly be watching hd sports and gaming on a ps3, with the odd blu-ray movie here and there. Both systems sound great, but I'm more concerned about build quality and longevity than anything else. I just don't want to end up having to buy another set because I picked the wrong brand.
The Incident's Avatar The Incident
04:51 AM Liked: 10
post #5 of 12
06-28-2010 | Posts: 203
Joined: Jan 2010
Both are quality brands and should last you as long as you want to keep them. Trust your gut on which one you like better. Keep in mind that depending on your room acoustics, the speakers will never sound as good in your house as they did in the showroom.

If you have concerns about the subs, then do a little research and find one that makes you happy. It's not important for your sub to match the rest of your speakers.
yepimonfire's Avatar yepimonfire
10:57 AM Liked: 10
post #6 of 12
06-28-2010 | Posts: 22
Joined: Jun 2010
if i were you i would get the polk speakers and the infinity sub, as i have mentioned polk does not make very good subs. polks speakers have incredibly good imaging, the infinity's are ultra-bright and may become fatiguing after awhile.
cornhulio's Avatar cornhulio
01:57 PM Liked: 10
post #7 of 12
06-28-2010 | Posts: 874
Joined: Feb 2009
Go with the Infinitys. The polks are much brighter than the infinitys. I believe the previous post was thinking of Klipsch speakers which are often considered bright or harsh.
panesar187's Avatar panesar187
05:27 PM Liked: 10
post #8 of 12
06-28-2010 | Posts: 18
Joined: Jun 2010
Like I said, I've already done the listening and both sounded similar (infinitys were a little softer). Neither were bright and I was allowed to crank it to full volume. I've also listened to Klipsch, which sounded bright because I believe they use 'horn' rather than dome tweeters. Anyways, I believe I'll go with the infintys. If both brands have solid builds that last a while, then I see no reason to spend the extra money on the polks. Thanks for all the advice people.
RTROSE's Avatar RTROSE
05:15 PM Liked: 51
post #9 of 12
07-01-2010 | Posts: 6,180
Joined: Dec 2005
Hey are you totally sold on either the Polk's or Infinity's? If not consider the Klipsch Quintet III's. Neat smaller system ideal for gaming.

Doh! Just realized your looking at floor standers. Never mind!

Regards,

RTROSE
Jab31169's Avatar Jab31169
08:14 AM Liked: 10
post #10 of 12
07-02-2010 | Posts: 13
Joined: Jan 2010
I run the Infinity Primus p362's as my fronts, the pc350 as my center, and some infinity in walls for my rears. I've also got an Infinity BU-2 12 inch sub that I've had for 15 years now. On top of that I also have some Infinity SS bookshelf speakers that I've owned for 12 years that are in my garage. Needless to say I would go with Infinity.
panesar187's Avatar panesar187
11:19 PM Liked: 10
post #11 of 12
07-02-2010 | Posts: 18
Joined: Jun 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jab31169 View Post

I run the Infinity Primus p362's as my fronts, the pc350 as my center, and some infinity in walls for my rears.

Nice...and how does the setup handle music? I ask because the polks i listened to sounded surprisingly bright for music. I didn't get a chance to play my music on the infinitys.
mayhem13's Avatar mayhem13
07:32 PM Liked: 13
post #12 of 12
07-03-2010 | Posts: 3,959
Joined: Jan 2008
The PC350 center channel offered in the Infinity Line makes the Primus package the ONLY option as it's a FAR superior center channel to anything offered by POLk by design alone. For HT use, the center channel speaker is THE most important and the vertical MT section of the 350 gets it right without the off axis garble and comb filtering. As for your choice of subs, two will always be better than one creating a much smoother in room response. Adding a second PS210 is well worth the investment. If located close to the mains, cross a bit higher (say 100hz) and fill in the midbass gap you experienced when comparing to the Polks.
Reply General Home Theater & Media/Game Rooms

Subscribe to this Thread

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3