Unforgiven: 20th Anniversary Edition - AVS Forum | Home Theater Discussions And Reviews
1 2 
Blu-ray Software > Unforgiven: 20th Anniversary Edition
dvdmike007's Avatar dvdmike007 10:47 AM 11-14-2011
Looks like a repackage

Paramount and Warner really need to sort out this lossy nonsense



Quote:


Commentary by Eastwood biographer Richard Schickel
All on Accounta Pullin - a Trigger, featuring interviews with Morgan Freeman and others
Eastwood A Star
Eastwood & Co.: Making Unforgiven
Eastwood on Eastwood: A career retrospective from Time critic/biographer Richard Schickel
Maverick TV series episode 'Duel at Sundown' (1959), in which Eastwood plays a virtual younger incarnation of his Unforgiven role
Theatrical trailer



spectator's Avatar spectator 11:06 AM 11-14-2011
Every time one of these is announced, another little chip breaks off of my soul. Each repackaging of obsolete materials just means that much longer before a worthy release will arrive.
dvdmike007's Avatar dvdmike007 11:21 AM 11-14-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by spectator View Post

Every time one of these is announced, another little chip breaks off of my soul. Each repackaging of obsolete materials just means that much longer before a worthy release will arrive.

It's not like it's an important anniversary or anything
spectator's Avatar spectator 11:25 AM 11-14-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by dvdmike007 View Post

It's not like it's an important anniversary or anything

I don't think anyone outside of the studios actually cares about whatever anniversary they plaster all over the box- we just want a quality release and every time they repackage the old crap, we just have to suck up a couple more years before we can hope to see any improvement.
FendersRule's Avatar FendersRule 01:50 PM 11-14-2011
Same transfer, but now in a digibook?

I like digibook versions more, but why didn't they release it in a digibook in the first place?
Fanboyz's Avatar Fanboyz 01:54 PM 11-14-2011
Very disappointing...
AndyM's Avatar AndyM 02:33 PM 11-14-2011
come on warner, give this one a new transfer. you seem to like this film. it must have sold well to warrant another release on home video.

you got away with making the first release pretty sh*tty. old dated master, lossy audio etc.

give it a new scan and all us suckers will buy it again. you know we will.

but what incentive is there currently ? a repackage job isn't exactly hitting the bulls-eye for me.
msgohan's Avatar msgohan 02:47 PM 11-14-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by FendersRule View Post

I like digibook versions more, but why didn't they release it in a digibook in the first place?

Well...

Unforgiven Blu-ray: October 31, 2006
Warner's first Digibook: spring 2008
dvdmike007's Avatar dvdmike007 03:06 PM 11-14-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by FendersRule View Post

Same transfer, but now in a digibook?

I like digibook versions more, but why didn't they release it in a digibook in the first place?

There was an awards edition
oink's Avatar oink 10:24 PM 11-14-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by AndyM View Post

come on warner, give this one a new transfer. you seem to like this film. it must have sold well to warrant another release on home video.

you got away with making the first release pretty sh*tty. old dated master, lossy audio etc.

No new transfer, no lossless?

Warner....the studio you love to hate.
FendersRule's Avatar FendersRule 10:25 PM 11-14-2011
A digibook blu-ray with a lossy soundtrack. Would this be the first?

Enjoy your halfway-HD packaged media in a premium package, you poor sap consumer.
LexInVA's Avatar LexInVA 04:33 AM 11-15-2011
I think we need to pay Warner Home Video a visit and choke some bitches. It would seem that no matter how much progress they make going forward, they just keep rolling on back. This film deserves a fresh transfer and re-master for archival purposes and loss-less audio. Ya dig?
Fanboyz's Avatar Fanboyz 05:13 AM 11-15-2011
Word.
oink's Avatar oink 07:32 AM 11-15-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by LexInVA View Post

This film deserves a fresh transfer and re-master for archival purposes and loss-less audio.

Oh, you mean that film that received 9 Oscar nominations and 4 wins,
including BEST PICTURE and BEST DIRECTOR....you mean THAT little film?
Josh Z's Avatar Josh Z 10:13 AM 11-15-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by FendersRule View Post

A digibook blu-ray with a lossy soundtrack. Would this be the first?

They did the same with Goodfellas and Bonnie & Clyde.
FendersRule's Avatar FendersRule 10:15 PM 11-15-2011
That's sad.
giantchicken's Avatar giantchicken 10:58 PM 11-15-2011
Bought this on VHS, widescreen VHS, DVD, special edition DVD and finally Blu-Ray, and it was an upgrade every time. Since this is not an upgrade in quality compared to the last release, I guess I'll pass on this one.
Mr. Cinema's Avatar Mr. Cinema 03:34 PM 11-16-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by dvdmike007 View Post

It's not like it's an important anniversary or anything

Yes, this lazy repackaging is infuriating. Next year is the 20th anniversary, it was a Best Picture winner, it's on the AFI Top 100 list, and it's a very popular film among many people. And they still didn't bother to invest any money in an audio/video upgrade.

I guess George Feltenstein doesn't consider this a classic, but I sure as hell do.
lgans316's Avatar lgans316 04:55 PM 11-16-2011
Day 1 purchase for me. Love their low bit rate experimental encodes.
oink's Avatar oink 01:26 PM 11-19-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema View Post

Yes, this lazy repackaging is infuriating. Next year is the 20th anniversary, it was a Best Picture winner, it's on the AFI Top 100 list, and it's a very popular film among many people. And they still didn't bother to invest any money in an audio/video upgrade.

I guess George Feltenstein doesn't consider this a classic, but I sure as hell do.

Quote:
Originally Posted by lgans316 View Post

Day 1 purchase for me. Love their low bit rate experimental encodes.

WB....ya gotta luv 'em.
42041's Avatar 42041 01:35 PM 11-28-2011
Someone on blu-ray.com noticed that the back of the digibook says "newly restored" for its 20th anniversary...
http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Unforgiven-Blu-ray/33582/

Has WB said anything like that about their other repackages?
Strevlac's Avatar Strevlac 01:39 PM 11-28-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by 42041 View Post

Someone on blu-ray.com noticed that the back of the digibook says "newly restored" for its 20th anniversary...
http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Unforgiven-Blu-ray/33582/

Has WB said anything like that about their other repackages?

I dunno but with the audio specs still saying dolby digital I'd say the odds of a new transfer (or even reencoding) aren't looking very good.
oink's Avatar oink 02:04 PM 11-28-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by 42041 View Post

Someone on blu-ray.com noticed that the back of the digibook says "newly restored" for its 20th anniversary...
http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Unforgiven-Blu-ray/33582/

Hmmmm, that's interesting.
However...no lossless, no sale.
pcweber111's Avatar pcweber111 02:13 PM 11-28-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by oink View Post

Hmmmm, that's interesting.
However...no lossless, no sale.

If the transfer is done well and I notice the difference I'll rebuy it regardless of lossless audio or not. I can get around that. The image quality is what disappoints me more than anything. If they do just re-release the same disc as before but charge more for it because of packaging, well lol, I feel for the fool that falls for it. I'd rather them focus on giving us a new transfer than a fancy digibook packaging.
oink's Avatar oink 02:15 PM 11-28-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by pcweber111 View Post

I'd rather them focus on giving us a new transfer than a fancy digibook packaging.

Agreed.
paku's Avatar paku 03:57 PM 11-28-2011
I can't believe they would do a new transfer and not put lossless audio on there, so probably one of them is wrong. Most likely the part about the restoration.
oink's Avatar oink 04:13 PM 11-28-2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by paku View Post

I can't believe they would do a new transfer and not put lossless audio on there, so probably one of them is wrong. Most likely the part about the restoration.

You're right, it doesn't make sense.
DavidHir's Avatar DavidHir 06:51 AM 02-27-2012
I watched the original version last night and there is definitely noticeable DNR and edge enhancement. Source material seems good. Does anyone know for sure if this re-release is the same encode?
nick_danger's Avatar nick_danger 10:32 AM 02-27-2012
I have the HD DVD and the Blu-ray R2B upgrade, so this release would have to get everything right to earn a triple dip.
Fanboyz's Avatar Fanboyz 10:38 AM 02-27-2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by DavidHir View Post

I watched the original version last night and there is definitely noticeable DNR and edge enhancement. Source material seems good. Does anyone know for sure if this re-release is the same encode?

It's the same disc,
1 2 

Up