I really enjoy this thread. Thank you to those who have really put some strong effort in getting this to be a very reliable source on picture quality.
I do think though that with titles like "The Warriors", "Fifth Element", and the grainy "300" as Tier 1 titles, that the Prestige and Ice Age Meltdown as very underestimated as Tier 2 entries.
I thought that the picture quality, pop, and on Ice Age and Prestige definitely need to be in tier 1 at least compared to the three previously listed tier 1 titles.
I am using 1080P 56" Samsung, and am less than 10 feet away when viewing.