Just received mine today, I had sent it in the beginning of May.
Only "Seabiscuit" suffered the gouging at the UPC code spot on the case.
"Casablanca", "Tomb Raider", "We Were Soldiers", and "Blazing Saddles" are as pristine as from the store shelf.
And complete with the metal anti-shoplifting sticky in the "Seabiscuit case as well.
Perhaps this gouging is performed when a retailer returns the HD-DVD's?
"We did not have business relations with that company, Fuh Yuan."