Having said that, I am afraid you have infected me with the bug. Now I feel I need to build the speakers, too, in order to maximize value. Crossovers and what not scare me, but that is still a bit off as I am not even sure what the different types (numbers) mean. I am thinking about the SEOS kits from Erich, and I see a lot of people using them in builds, but I can't really find anything that talks about WHY they chose the set they did (what the numbers mean in terms of performance/sound type/etc).
The HT will be used mostly for movies, and I am trying to decide between the Marantz AV7005 (http://www.accessories4less.com/make-a-store/item/MARAV7005/Marantz-AV7005-Networking-AV-Preamp/Processor/1.html#!specifications) or the Denon AVR-3313CI (http://www.amazon.com/Denon-AVR-3313CI-Networking-Receiver-Capacity/dp/B00829USKS) if it ends up making a difference on the advice you give for the speakers.
I would like to have at least five channels, but I could settle for LCR for now if I have to for quality. I think I have about $1,000 left to spend, perhaps a bit more (haven't factored in all the shipping and taxes yet, so attempting to conservatively estimate).
Could someone be so kind as to enlighten me on what the differences are, which sets might work well, or just anything to help me sift through all of this? If you would prefer to link me to things instead of explaining, I am ok with that, just need to figure out which direction I am headed so I can move closer to the buy/build!
generally, the larger more expensive speakers will perform better at the high volumes and tend to use a lower crossover point, which puts more of the sound in the driver that is better able to play it cleanly. beyond that if you have questions such as "how does the midrange clarity compare between the deltalite ii 2512 and the definimax 12 woofers" that is going to be tough to get.
I've been annoying erich from time to time to create some sort of comparison grid to help folks sort through your question and i'm not sure if it is something that will be part of the new site or not. it is a tough thing though to create because there are so many different ways to compare them.
here are some testamonials from java's bulid that used the deltalite ii 2512 woofer / seos12 / dna360 / bill waslo crossover / sealed.
"Great work Java. The 2512 is a good midrange or high midbass woofer. IMO it is best used when excursion is kept under control like how you are doing with the sealed box HPF'd around 80hz. It will definitely give you that punch feeling in the 80-200hz range and does well over the rest of its range too. For the money it is great.
I think the reason people were searching for an alternative was because the prices nearly doubled last year for this woofer and it was no longer such a great value. Now it is back to being a steal."
"Told ya!.......my test boxes are the same volume, just not as tall but deeper. The 2512 kicks like a mule. I'm actually quite surprised when i see so many posts looking for a different woofer to work with the SEOS 12 when the 2512 works so well for so little."
"NICE! You WILL be amazed at the sound when you get them going.....the only down side I've found - your ears get "spoiled" rather quickly.
I hope you have good subs to keep up with them!"
"Drum Roll, Please...
I have finally finished. All three are done and hooked up.
Massive improvement over my Paradigms. There is an effortless wall of sound now.
I tested out on some surround music and movies. Sound is fabulous. Given some of the concern about my design not being ported and comments that you need a sub with these mains, I wasn't expected too much bass. I was wrong. Huge bass."
java's build thread: http://www.avsforum.com/t/1417294/seos12-2512-build
final results are in post #2.
hey erich, you need testamonials on the new site. :-)
Honestly, mounting the surrounds has me a bit worried due to their apparent size.. perhaps starting with front stage and figuring out a way to do the surrounds in the mean time isn't such a bad idea. Thoughts?
What exactly is the problem... They don't fit in your space? You don't know how to wall mount them?
I have run a phantom center for a week and it was pretty damn good, voices were right smack in the middle like I had a center channel.
This wall mount is real popular. Its best if you mount it to a stud.
There is this surround design but not extremely sensitive
If you don't mind a wide speaker I built a one pi in a sealed enclosure for surround duty.
For a surround speaker they sound decent especially for the price. I think it cost me about $90 per speaker for the drivers and crossovers at partsexpress. The only change I made from the plans is the enclosure. I can notice a tonal difference between the LCR and surround but not a big enough difference to build a whole new set of surrounds. Overall I'm happy with the way they sound and the sensitivity is right on, I think its a 1db difference between the fronts and surrounds.
Another thing to mention is the difference between a waveguide and dome for a surround speaker. I don't know the technical terms but a dome is more dispersed shooting sound everywhere which some people might like in a surround. While a waveguide has a constant directivity...I think thats the right word.
|Marantz Av7005 Pre Processor , Fusion 8 Inch Super Slim Under Seat 300w Amplified Subwoofer , Behringer Nu3000 Inuke Ultra Lightweight High Density 3000 Watt Power Amplifier|