Originally Posted by hodges69
"They ain't bright ...
Plasma whites aren't LCD - LED whites ... hockey can look dim ...sometimes grey - why is this ? why can't they get WHITE ? like the screen I'm typing on now is ..WHITE , bright & vibrant ...
They seem to do Sports real well .... movies is where they shine - just really beautiful PQ ....even on some lesser Plasma's ...
Am I correct in saying that the Videophile - the CNET guy ...aren't sports fans ...aren't ESPN fans...aren't big regular HDTV fans ....but more the kinda guy who watches 10+Blu Rays a week ?
So when we read these glowing reviews about Plasma's ...about their black levels etc...these are basically the views of film buffs correct?
So in theory is it really fair to just assume they're correct in naming "fill in the blank Panny Plasma " the best PQ every year? based on what ? Blu Ray?
Is it me doesn't THX mode make sports etc look terrible? dark ? dim? I'm not being negative , I just want to know, am I not appreciative of the colors?>
I do have 20/30 vision , so I have eyesight aided by glasses and I know we all see different.
I was in BB today mulling and mulling...staring at a VT50 and a GT50 and my eye always drifted to the LED on a white scene ....I believe it was the Panny LED....
Maybe I'm a moth "
Or mabe confused....you did start the above thread,did you not?
The reason a plasma is usually named the top display each year is a combination of factors that when put together out weigh the strengths of led lcds.
Plasma: Overall accuracy, deep and steady black levels, near perfect viewing angles, bright enough for most people and situations, best value for dollar.
Led lcd: brighter than anyone would ever need, can be made extremely thin, can have deep black levels in sets with local dimming but are often inconsistent especially on edgelit models, has very low power draw but you would have to run it for many years to break even against the lower prices of plasmas (at least 10 years average viewing)
You can see that most of the current crop of led lcd's strengths don't actually have much to do with overall picture quality at all but more to do with convenience. There are of course great lcds out there but they will run you 2-4 times the cost of a comparable plasma.
I for one don't see what people have to complain about, whether it be crt, plasma or lcd I have never owned a display that i would call dim even in a lit room and that includes a 2008 Panny plasma (they've likely improved since then
) Bright daytime tv viewing isn't something I care much about, as long as I can see what's on the screen it doesn't matter, if i want to be immersed in something however alot of ambient light is a tad counter productive.
Also the reason plasmas don't like to show blinding brightness is because they would "cook" in the process, manufacturers have worked to improve the achievable brightness with good results though.