Phono USB preamp advice - AVS Forum

AVS Forum > Audio > 2-Channel Audio > Phono USB preamp advice

2-Channel Audio

JD NC's Avatar JD NC
01:09 PM Liked: 40
post #1 of 4
04-10-2013 | Posts: 269
Joined: Jul 2012
I finally convinced my dad to pass on his LP collection to me, so I just went from a few dozen to a couple hundred records to spin, many of which I don't have on other formats. Right now I have an Art DJ Pre II preamp, which I like. Now that I have enough new content that recording to digital makes sense, I'm in the market for an upgrade with USB and could use some suggestions.

Here are my requirements:
-96khz/24 bit USB recording. My goal is to have a raw 96/24 recording of each album side archived so that I only have to record each album once. I can then muck around in Audacity until I get the levels and EQ reasonably close to my CD-based music files. Once I have the presets nailed down, I can just to a batch convert to 48/16 for my itunes library and I can keep the untouched HD versions around in case I want to go back and fix something.
-High quality analog processing. I'm not worried about the fidelity of the ADC or USB transfer, but getting the most accurate possible analog signal to the ADC is key. Everything I'm looking at includes RIAA EQ, but is some hardware significantly better than others? What other specs/features should I be looking for?
-$100 or less.

So far, the best option I've found is the Creative X-Fi HD USB. It's covers all the bases above, and has a lot of extra features that add value beyond the core features I'm looking for. It's also only $85, and have a very nice clean appearance.

Anything else I should be looking at? The Behringer UCA202 is the least expensive option at $30, but it tops out at 48khz (and I presume 16bit, but can't find any specs on bit depth). Wouldn't be a problem if I were recording cleaner analog audio, but I want the option to do a lot of post-processing with Audacity to clean up and balance out the sound, so I would feel much better with a 96/24 ADC.
JD NC's Avatar JD NC
04:21 PM Liked: 40
post #2 of 4
04-10-2013 | Posts: 269
Joined: Jul 2012
I should have also added mac compatibility is a must. I was all ready to get the Creative, and noticed it's windows only. And that seems to be the only sub-$100 unit I can find that does 96/24. Argh.

OK, if I'm stuck with 48/16, what's the best one under $100? The Behringer UCA202 ($30) and Art USB Phono Plus ($80) both look competent, but I'm not thrilled with the form factor of the Behringer and I think both are ugly. I'd much prefer a clean black box like the Creative.
kraut's Avatar kraut
11:38 PM Liked: 60
post #3 of 4
04-10-2013 | Posts: 379
Joined: Sep 2012
Quote:
The Behringer UCA202 ($30) and Art USB Phono Plus ($80) both look competent, but I'm not thrilled with the form factor of the Behringer and I think both are ugly. I'd much prefer a clean black box like the Creative.

Since you seem to prefer form over function - why do you even ask for help?
I have used behringer equipment for over ten years, maybe not the longest lasting but always good at what it does when it works (which in my experience is between four years and up).
I also use an art headphone amp, no problems. Good stuff at a good price.
JD NC's Avatar JD NC
05:46 PM Liked: 40
post #4 of 4
04-11-2013 | Posts: 269
Joined: Jul 2012
Quote:
Originally Posted by kraut View Post

Since you seem to prefer form over function - why do you even ask for help?

Heh, sorry if my question offended your sensibilities. Do you really believe that my preference for the X-Fi, which has better specs than the Art, is based on form over function? Or are you just being a concern troll?
Reply 2-Channel Audio

Subscribe to this Thread

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3