I wouldn't so much call it a debate as a discussion of personal experience. I'll try very high gain paint behind a electric drop screen to see if I can find the best 2D/3D experience with active shutters on a limited budget next.
That's what we do here on AVS I thought, try crazy ideas, and pass on the results, positive or negative so the next guy doesn't make the same mistake. I've followed your lead a bunch of times John.
Part of the enjoyment for me is getting the stuff to work best.