AVS Forum

AVS Forum (http://www.avsforum.com/forum/)
-   Soundbars (http://www.avsforum.com/forum/195-soundbars/)
-   -   Latest Unofficial Update: Atlantic Technology H-PAS Powerbar 235 (http://www.avsforum.com/forum/195-soundbars/1375902-latest-unofficial-update-atlantic-technology-h-pas-powerbar-235-a.html)

Guy Owen 11-27-2011 12:18 PM

Don't hold your breath on the Atlantic Technology Powerbar 235 being available in 2011, as stated at nearly every website you find -- most of which rehash the CEDIA demonstration.

Earliest realistic date stated (by recent email) by Steve Feinstein, Director of Marketing & Product Development at Atlantic is "first quarter 2012" with no stated pricing, yet, other than "well below 4 figures". Looking forward to it, but what a bummer if you've been back-and-forth on getting the best soundbar!

Note that there is NO MENTION of this unit at their website as of 11/27/11. No Preview. No Pre-Order option. Nothing. Zero. Zilch. That seems really odd for an "upcoming" item that was supposedly getting released "in time for Christmas 2011" (based on claims by Reviewers who, apparently, saw the demo).

If you have no idea what this unit is, search for it on YouTube.

wilsodt 11-29-2011 10:15 AM

I got this reply when I inquired directly on their website:

We are still finalizing the details to make it as close to perfect as possible! We expect it around March...
Be sure to follow us on Facebook/Twitter and check on our website for updates...

wilsodt 02-08-2012 12:20 PM

I followed up with Atlantic today - got this update:

"Unfortunately it has taken longer than anticipated to get the unit finalized. In the original unit, it did not contain DTS, and that was added after feedback on the original prototype. It is now anticipated at early June. Feel free to check in as we get closer."

I am holding out for this one based on the video from CEDIA.

HLdan 05-13-2012 08:07 PM

I contacted Atlantic Technology on FB about the PB235's ETA. They stated that it's been pushed back until around August. I'm still going to wait. Never had a Soundbar before and from the early reviews I've read it may really be worth the wait. Sounds like a much more affordable solution over the Bose 1SR or the B&W Panorama.

wilsodt 09-04-2012 02:03 PM

I followed up with Atlantic. They are demoing pre-production units at Cedia this week and at long last expect to ship late this month. The retail will be $899. As you might expect it crept up some from the original announcement but seems in line with mid-upper end brands. This is the link:

http://www.atlantictechnology.com/default.asp?NodeId=170

Glenee 09-06-2012 08:21 AM

I don't see any HDMI inputs. In this case are we limited to Dolby Digital ? I have been waiting for this to hit the streets, but no HDMI for ARC will make me think before purchase.

rpconrad 09-26-2012 01:15 PM

This is supposedly shipping this week.

Has anyone heard this unit or seen any reviews?

Glenee 09-27-2012 07:00 PM

I just saw a report on AV Guide from Cedia. It's not good the unit will be priced at $899.00. It has No HDMI Support only RCA, Optical, and Coaxial inputs. You would of thought they would of looked at the Newer Soundbars and said, hey without HDMI and HD Codecs support We are dead in the water before we release it. It didn't take B&W long to notice the serious drop in Sales with their Panorama once the B&W Faithfull and reputation Sales wore off. They went back to the board and are set to release a New Panorama with HDMI and HD Codec support. This Bar would still have reasonable Sales at $499.00 to $599.00 but it won't go at $899.00 too many players with too much to offer at $900.00 that this can't compete with and It's SAD. What a great product design it just needed a little extra effort in the thought Department. I never thought they would of brought such a fine product to market with such limitations. If I wanted one for a bedroom or Office, I would wait till they go under $500.00 when they don't Sell.
Final is Great Product, Good Engineering, a Hell of a Idea. They just didn't add that extra $40.00 part ( I actually thought this was what the delay was about) to make it one of the products of the Year.
And there you have it Lady's and Gentlemen. What a Shame.

BobL 09-29-2012 06:58 AM

It would be a lot more than $40 part. The engineering and licensing for HDMI would probably add a million or more to R&D which would be very difficult for a small company like AT to swallow. HDMI has put many small companies out of developing consumer electronics.

Anyway, I wouldn't discount the bar for features. A couple extra cables aren't a big deal and the sound quality isn't any different with broadcast sources. With Blu-ray lossless codecs converted to the highest level DTS compared to lossless is something you are not likely to notice when comparing sound bars. I do agree the features would be nice but would it be worth it if the bar would then be $1999. Buying on features and specs doesn't always give one the best performance, although I agree it will hurt sales somewhat. But, a lot of AT is sold through specialty dealers, so probably not as much as the big companies. I wouldn't discount it until you hear it compared to other bars, that is what really matters.

Glenee 10-01-2012 08:45 AM

Bob,
I am in total agreement with most of what you say. I just think they had a real winner here, and they just short changed it a little. My thinking is a little different, I was thinking $40.00 X 25000 units is a $1,000,000.00 if the licensing is that, and I don't know anything about that. I don't know how many they expected to sell, if it was just a small amount to begin with, they would of been better Off licensing the technology and taking a royalty payment. In this day and time that is where the Technology level in Electronic Media is at Now. It is a shame that so many small companies have been priced out of competion, because some of our greatest feats in advancement come from these smaller companies. I wish them luck, but if they are going to be in this market they need to be in this Market's Lower Price Range.
Just my Humble Opinion,
Glen

almostinsane 10-01-2012 03:05 PM

There's no way that adding an HDMI port and an updated decoder chip adds a million bucks to the R&D costs. These have been around for years now and are no longer state of the art features.

BobL 10-01-2012 10:28 PM

I don't think you understand HDMI. The test equipment alone is $250,000+ to do proper HDMI testing. You can try to outsource it overseas but that is not as easy as it sounds and to get production runs on relatively small quantiites means you are paying a premium for engineering time. HDMI is one of the reasons small companies are having troubles producing preamps. Outlaw, Parasound and others have decided to go in other directions and HDMI is a big part of those decisions. Plus there is a new version of HDMI coming out. Small companies don't have the resources to keep up.

I think this soundbar is going to compete against the B&W, higher end Yamahas, Bose and others in the $1k or more range. They use quality drivers and components that are a considerable step up from the <$500 bars from Sony, Samsung, etc. I've heard a demo of it but haven't had a chance to test one yet.

Glenee 10-03-2012 07:17 AM

It's For Sale on Outlaw Audio's website for $799.00. Ships in 7-10 days. If anyone wants to try one. The price is a little more reasonable.

Zombeezy 10-03-2012 03:29 PM

Glad to see this post being added to again. Since my wife has continually complained about our TV's (currently a PRO-60X5FD) inability to decently allow one to watch moves without jiggling the volume controls up and down, have been hoping to use this soundbar to allow better control distinguishing of voices when action-generated sound effects are drowning them out. Am I missing a point here about lack of HDMI? My TV has a Digital audio output (optical) (TOSLINK), and the soundbar will have two optical inputs. Whether I play an avi file on a thumb drive through my BDP-83 (or a Blu-Ray for that matter), or am streaming a Netflix movie through the TV's app or my Logitech Revue, the sound outputs from these devices go through HDMI to the TV and the TV plays it out its speakers. With this soundbar, we'd disable the TV's internal speakers and have it use the optical link to the soundbar. Why would I need it to have HDMI and HD CODEC support?

I suspect this answer is linked to Glenee's "In this case are we limited to Dolby Digital ? I have been waiting for this to hit the streets, but no HDMI for ARC will make me think before purchase." but I will admit I am missing the point. Is this having to do with listening to music sources?

Oh, and thanks Glenee for mentioning Outlaw Audio's price. I emailed AT about any pre-order discounts since I had been following this since Sept. 2011, but nothing really came of it.

Cheers,

Z

Glenee 10-03-2012 07:11 PM

Hi Z, I am not saying I won't purchase one. I just wish it would of been able to Decode the newer HD Codecs. There is a difference in pure quality of surround sound. The ARC that you have on your Sharp Elite would of been a nice hook-up to the Sound bar. I own the Sharp Pro70X5 and I know what you talking about with the Speakers located in the TV. When they make "em that thin it's hard to fit any speaker capabilities in there. They shot for picture on the Elite's, and that's what they should of done. I was really hyped Up when this soundbar was first announced. I am a 2-Channel Guy and I thought the Idea of getting away from having to have a Sub for movies was right up my alley. I was just waiting to purchase this unit. Now Yamaha has hit the market with a ( wait to be seen) major improvement over the last edition of there sound projectors as they call them. They got it together with a smaller wireless sub, the improvement is supposedly significant. The YSP-3300 will be available for around the same price at Discounts. This is all guessing until we get them in our homes. But if you look at what it does for around the same 1K mark, if it does turn out to be that good. It's a No-Brainer over this. If it turns out to be POS I will probally end up with the AT 235 or the new B&W Panorama.
To all out there that want to give this thing a shot I'm waiting for your reviews. I think it will serve a very needed Quality Sound bar at the $500.00 mark NOT $900.00 and Outlaw has started closer to this mark right out of the box.
IMHO,
Glen

Zombeezy 10-05-2012 08:28 AM

Hi Glen! I appreciate your comments. I looked further into what ARC was and now think I understand what the dual-use HDMI-1 is for on the Elite, lol.

My TV is jammed at an angle into a corner with a vaulted ceiling and odd room angles where there are walls, so surround sound and deep bass are less important to me than clearing up the muddled standard sound and getting better voice clarity and some semi-wow stereo sound effects/music. With initial thoughts on the AT 235 as my go-to option that we've been waiting a year for, now you have me re-thinking this!

Although I question whether the quality of TV & Blu-Ray movie sound (compressed or not) in my mis-shaped room would be noticeable, it does seem that the more options I have, the better I can optimize for my room.

Another factor I need to consider is that, not having a wall mounted TV, where the soundbar will be placed. Its dimensions are 42.75"W x 5.5"H x 6.5"D. The height from the TV "cart" to the bottom of the Elite viewing area is about 4" (if I place the soundbar in front of the stand at the edge of the cart front edge). Or, sitting on top of the Elite stand and pushed back to the Elite, its about 3" to the bottom of the Elite viewing area. In other words, both placements would stick above the bottom of the screen, so I had been thinking of a right-corner wall arm mount for the H-Pas and swinging it into place above the TV.

Although I wasn't happy about the price-creep over the year, I could manage the AT Powerbar 235 at $899 (Outlaw OSB-1 at $799), but I think it will take too long for the YSP-3300 to drop enough from its $1600 MSRP to be a convincing sell to my wife, and even more so the new B&W Panorama 2 with HDMI at a yikes! $2200. So, it's probably either going with the Outlaw without HDMI, or having to look into other "lower" options I hadn't considered while holding out for H-PAS, like the Yamaha YSP-2200 (3.5"H) or Vizio VHT215 (4.5"H w/ stand; 3.3" H w/o stand).

I also recall that the since the H-PAS technology was a collaborative effort that included Phil Clements, that a soundbar was going to be released under the Solus/Clements branding also, but don't see anything there yet.

Gotta love it!

~Z

rpconrad 10-05-2012 09:24 AM

FYI

Have received distributor quotes for less than $700 all in (inclusive of tax and shipping) on the AT

J_bryan 10-05-2012 11:01 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenee View Post

I just saw a report on AV Guide from Cedia. It's not good the unit will be priced at $899.00. It has No HDMI Support only RCA, Optical, and Coaxial inputs. You would of thought they would of looked at the Newer Soundbars and said, hey without HDMI and HD Codecs support We are dead in the water before we release it. It didn't take B&W long to notice the serious drop in Sales with their Panorama once the B&W Faithfull and reputation Sales wore off. They went back to the board and are set to release a New Panorama with HDMI and HD Codec support. This Bar would still have reasonable Sales at $499.00 to $599.00 but it won't go at $899.00 too many players with too much to offer at $900.00 that this can't compete with and It's SAD. What a great product design it just needed a little extra effort in the thought Department. I never thought they would of brought such a fine product to market with such limitations. If I wanted one for a bedroom or Office, I would wait till they go under $500.00 when they don't Sell.
Final is Great Product, Good Engineering, a Hell of a Idea. They just didn't add that extra $40.00 part ( I actually thought this was what the delay was about) to make it one of the products of the Year.
And there you have it Lady's and Gentlemen. What a Shame.

+1

Was disappointed this unit does not have HDMI. In addition, the slightly bulky design of the sound bar (relative to the thickness of most flat panel TVs) caused me to keep looking.

Glenee 10-05-2012 12:01 PM

Well I'm out on the new B&W Panorama. No HD Codecs Support. If I pay that kind of price it better do everything.

Glenee 10-05-2012 12:02 PM

The $700.00 shipped is looking a little more like it. Now that makes this unit a little more interesting. Not there yet but getting there.
cool.gif

Zombeezy 10-26-2012 07:04 AM

I thought I'd start seeing some reviews trickling in by now! Maybe because other than the $799 Outlaw, I'm not seeing this discounted from $899 list stil ...

oh wait, Amazon dropped it $22 and Neobits has it for just under for $700 delivered. Has anyone bought anything from them? It actually has decent resellerratings (9 out of 10 in 6 months)

brianlin87 11-01-2012 09:42 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by rpconrad View Post

FYI
Have received distributor quotes for less than $700 all in (inclusive of tax and shipping) on the AT

Quote:
Originally Posted by Zombeezy View Post

I thought I'd start seeing some reviews trickling in by now! Maybe because other than the $799 Outlaw, I'm not seeing this discounted from $899 list stil ...
oh wait, Amazon dropped it $22 and Neobits has it for just under for $700 delivered. Has anyone bought anything from them? It actually has decent resellerratings (9 out of 10 in 6 months)

Just received my AT 235 Soundbar last night via FedEx from a referral from rpconrad. Personally, I'd rather buy from this referral than Neobits, but to each their own. Hooking it up this weekend. Excited. biggrin.gif

Sploinker 11-15-2012 09:29 AM

So how does it sound? Been looking at this for weeks.

cub4bearin 01-08-2013 08:58 PM

I got one for $699 and so far so good..

taichi4 01-10-2013 11:54 AM

How is the surround effect and dialogue clarity? What's your room layout like? (four closed walls?)

Can you PM me where you bought it for that price?

Enjoy it!

devildog77 01-16-2013 12:26 PM

Can't find it for less than $899 (unless you count the Outlaw OSB-1 for $799). Where did you find it for $699?


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 06:25 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.