Vizio's New True 5.1 Soundbar S4251W - Page 16 - AVS | Home Theater Discussions And Reviews
First ... 14  15  16 17  18  ... Last
Soundbars > Vizio's New True 5.1 Soundbar S4251W
Infinite Xero's Avatar Infinite Xero 01:57 AM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

If you select bitstream dts you will get the best audio but that requires switching the optical audio cable from sound bar to tv to sound bar to ps4.

 

When I set this option on my PS4, the soundbar still flashes Digital, indicating true 5.1 audio. So why would I need to remove the optical cable from my TV and put it into my PS4?



SlackerCSB's Avatar SlackerCSB 07:58 AM 01-28-2014
I have a Vizio 70" e701ia3 TV. If I run all my components into the TV (XBox, Comcast, Etc) and run the audio from the TV to the soundbar, will I get true 5.1 sound?
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 08:04 AM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by SlackerCSB View Post

I have a Vizio 70" e701ia3 TV. If I run all my components into the TV (XBox, Comcast, Etc) and run the audio from the TV to the soundbar, will I get true 5.1 sound?
No.
SlackerCSB's Avatar SlackerCSB 08:08 AM 01-28-2014
What if I run all the components into my Onkyo receiver and then run the audio out to the sound bar. Would that be 5.1?
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 08:12 AM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Infinite Xero View Post

When I set this option on my PS4, the soundbar still flashes Digital, indicating true 5.1 audio. So why would I need to remove the optical cable from my TV and put it into my PS4?
Just because it flashes "Digital" does not mean its 5.1. 99% of tvs will not output 5.1 from an external source via optical. The tv will downconvert it to 2.0. If you hook directly from the PS4 to the soundbar then you will get 5.1.
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 08:13 AM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by SlackerCSB View Post

What if I run all the components into my Onkyo receiver and then run the audio out to the sound bar. Would that be 5.1?
Yes
mercennarius's Avatar mercennarius 10:17 AM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

Just because it flashes "Digital" does not mean its 5.1. 99% of tvs will not output 5.1 from an external source via optical. The tv will downconvert it to 2.0. If you hook directly from the PS4 to the soundbar then you will get 5.1.

Many newer TVs output DTS and DD via optical from an external source. I know mine does and this soundbar switches between "dolby Digital" and "DTS" depending on what is playing on the TV.
naustin's Avatar naustin 12:01 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by skellogg02 View Post

Bump, anyone have similar issue?
I believe you are having the 2.0 versus 5.1 perception issue discussed above, hearing sounds out the rears when you turn dolby digital off. If you like hearing the rears all the time you can go back to running thru your TV. I don't think you have Sound bar problem, but as a test watch a Bluray action movie with the optical connection.
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:02 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by mercennarius View Post

Many newer TVs output DTS and DD via optical from an external source. I know mine does and this soundbar switches between "dolby Digital" and "DTS" depending on what is playing on the TV.
I didnt say 99% of tvs wouldnt output DTS and DD from an external source. I said they would not output 5.1 from an external source. The tv will downconvert the 5.1 signal to a 2.0 signal. And I just about guarantee your tv is doing that.
Just because it says "Dolby Digital" or "DTS" does not mean its 5.1. This is something that the makers of soundbars would never tell you. Soundbars are not meant to replace a multimedia AVR and true surround system. They are designed to be better than the tv speakers for OTA tv and the built in apps that many of todays Smart tvs have. As is usually the case you get what you pay for.
What kind of tv do you have?
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 12:06 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Infinite Xero View Post

When I set this option on my PS4, the soundbar still flashes Digital, indicating true 5.1 audio. So why would I need to remove the optical cable from my TV and put it into my PS4?



There's a dts light too but it only works if you run optical from sound bar to ps4
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 12:09 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

I didnt say 99% of tvs wouldnt output DTS and DD from an external source. I said they would not output 5.1 from an external source. The tv will downconvert the 5.1 signal to a 2.0 signal. And I just about guarantee your tv is doing that.
Just because it says "Dolby Digital" or "DTS" does not mean its 5.1. This is something that the makers of soundbars would never tell you.
What kind of tv do you have?

I run mine from soundbar to tv and I got 5.1 on cable box xbox and blu ray player the only thing I can't get is dts unless I run optical from soundbar to blu ray player... Even tho my vizio says it does dts.... Frustrating
naustin's Avatar naustin 12:11 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by mercennarius View Post

Many newer TVs output DTS and DD via optical from an external source. I know mine does and this soundbar switches between "dolby Digital" and "DTS" depending on what is playing on the TV.
As a point of information, Some Dolby digital is encoded as 2 channel only. Most network shows are 5.1 encoded but most PBS in Dolby digital 2.0. I know because my Onkyo AVR receiver shows the source signal.
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:13 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

I run mine from soundbar to tv and I got 5.1 on cable box xbox and blu ray player the only thing I can't get is dts unless I run optical from soundbar to blu ray player... Even tho my vizio says it does dts.... Frustrating
How do you know you are getting 5.1 from your bluray player?
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 12:19 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

How do you know you are getting 5.1 from your bluray player?


I have tested all kinds of methods and the sound is identical when using dd5.1 running optical from tv to sound bar or running optical to blu ray player unless I switch to dts then I notice better bass but when running from tv to sound bar It's very crisp and if it was making it run 2.0 wouldn't that be same as RCA?? I've also switched from RCA to optical during movies and there is a huge diff in quality of the sound and vizio rep said that when the light comes on you are getting 5.1 which I guess May not always be true but I know it is for me and they said I should be able to get dts but for some reason I can't.... Maybe I need a soundbar firmware update
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:20 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by naustin View Post

As a point of information, Some Dolby digital is encoded as 2 channel only. Most network shows are 5.1 encoded but most PBS in Dolby digital 2.0. I know because my Onkyo AVR receiver shows the source signal.
Exactly. DD and DTS can be 2.0, 2.1, 5.1, 7.1, 7.2 and anything else. Just because it says DD or DTS does not make it 5.1. And if you have a soundbar how would you know the difference? How would you know that the soundbar is not just simulating surround with something like Dolby ProLogicII? You wouldnt because the soundbar does not tell you exactly what kind of signal it is receiving. The makers do that on purpose because if it did tell you exactly what the signal was a lot of people would be very disappointed to find out that they are listening to everything in simulated surround instead of true 5.1.
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 12:27 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

Exactly. DD and DTS can be 2.0, 2.1, 5.1, 7.1, 7.2 and anything else. Just because it says DD or DTS does not make it 5.1. And if you have a soundbar how would you know the difference? How would you know that the soundbar is not just simulating surround with something like Dolby ProLogicII? You wouldnt because the soundbar does not tell you exactly what kind of signal it is receiving. The makers do that on purpose because if it did tell you exactly what the signal was a lot of people would be very disappointed to find out that they are listening to everything in simulated surround instead of true 5.1.


I can hear the difference
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:31 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

I have tested all kinds of methods and the sound is identical when using dd5.1 running optical from tv to sound bar or running optical to blu ray player unless I switch to dts then I notice better bass but when running from tv to sound bar It's very crisp and if it was making it run 2.0 wouldn't that be same as RCA?? I've also switched from RCA to optical during movies and there is a huge diff in quality of the sound and vizio rep said that when the light comes on you are getting 5.1 which I guess May not always be true but I know it is for me and they said I should be able to get dts but for some reason I can't.... Maybe I need a soundbar firmware update
The Vizio rep told you its 5.1 when the,light comes on because hes a Vizio rep.
And the sound is not "identical". No offense but you just cant tell the difference when switching. If you had a way to do it A/B you would notice the difference.
No its not the same as 2.0 through RCA. The soundbar is most likely using Dolby ProLogicII to fake 5.1 and that format is not supported by RCA.
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:33 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

I can hear the difference
Sure. Youre hearing the difference between Dolby ProLogicII and Stereo. Neither of which is 5.1.
naustin's Avatar naustin 12:34 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

Exactly. DD and DTS can be 2.0, 2.1, 5.1, 7.1, 7.2 and anything else. Just because it says DD or DTS does not make it 5.1. And if you have a soundbar how would you know the difference? How would you know that the soundbar is not just simulating surround with something like Dolby ProLogicII? You wouldnt because the soundbar does not tell you exactly what kind of signal it is receiving. The makers do that on purpose because if it did tell you exactly what the signal was a lot of people would be very disappointed to find out that they are listening to everything in simulated surround instead of true 5.1.

+1 on that! Most people want a simulated sound that throws sound out of 5 speakers all the time (getting their monies worth). I wish the sound bar had more digital inputs so I could ditch the AVR,
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 12:35 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

The Vizio rep told you its 5.1 when the,light comes on because hes a Vizio rep.
And the sound is not "identical". No offense but you just cant tell the difference when switching. If you had a way to do it A/B you would notice the difference.
No its not the same as 2.0 through RCA. The soundbar is most likely using Dolby ProLogicII to fake 5.1 and that format is not supported by RCA.


You could be right for most ppl but I keep one optical from tv to bar and keep one in blu ray player and the other end sitting next to the bar so when I switched it literally took 2 seconds an have notice noooo difference
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:40 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

You could be right for most ppl but I keep one optical from tv to bar and keep one in blu ray player and the other end sitting next to the bar so when I switched it literally took 2 seconds an have notice noooo difference
If you are running the optical directly from bluray to the bar then you will get 5.1. Now if you also do that for your cable box every time you want to watch cable you will be set.
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 12:46 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by naustin View Post

+1 on that! Most people want a simulated sound that throws sound out of 5 speakers all the time (getting their monies worth). I wish the sound bar had more digital inputs so I could ditch the AVR,
You get what you pay for. Really if you have an AVR I would never go with a soundbar. Youre paying too much for convenience and inferior sound. You could just buy some nice speakers for the same money and have 2.0, 3.0, 3.1 or even a decent true 5.1 setup for what some of these soundbars that come with ultra cheap speakers and sub. Then you throw in wireless and the sound suffers even more.
mercennarius's Avatar mercennarius 12:58 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post


I didnt say 99% of tvs wouldnt output DTS and DD from an external source. I said they would not output 5.1 from an external source. The tv will downconvert the 5.1 signal to a 2.0 signal. And I just about guarantee your tv is doing that.
Just because it says "Dolby Digital" or "DTS" does not mean its 5.1. This is something that the makers of soundbars would never tell you. Soundbars are not meant to replace a multimedia AVR and true surround system. They are designed to be better than the tv speakers for OTA tv and the built in apps that many of todays Smart tvs have. As is usually the case you get what you pay for.
What kind of tv do you have?

 

This soundbar does decode DTS and DD and outputs true surround. On the Vizio S4251W, every time it lights up Dolby Digital or DTS, my speakers are outputting true surround. My TV is an LG 55GA7900 and does pass through DTS and DD through the optical port.


Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 01:12 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by mercennarius View Post

This soundbar does decode DTS and DD and outputs true surround. On the Vizio S4251W, every time it lights up Dolby Digital or DTS, my speakers are outputting true surround. My TV is an LG 55GA7900 and does pass through DTS and DD through the optical port.
Never said it didnt decode DTS and DD.
As for the rest of your post...ok if you say so. I suggest you do some research on surround sound.
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 01:15 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by mercennarius View Post

This soundbar does decode DTS and DD and outputs true surround. On the Vizio S4251W, every time it lights up Dolby Digital or DTS, my speakers are outputting true surround. My TV is an LG 55GA7900 and does pass through DTS and DD through the optical port.
Post over in the owners thread for your tv and ask them if youre tv will output 5.1 from optical with an external source and see what they say.
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 01:24 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bond 007 View Post

If you are running the optical directly from bluray to the bar then you will get 5.1. Now if you also do that for your cable box every time you want to watch cable you will be set.

If I leave my blu ray player set to bitstream Dolby 5.1 there is no diff in the sound at all no matter where the optical cord is plugged into... The only way I get better sound is by changing the blu ray player settings to bitstream dts then running the cord to blu ray player
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 01:25 PM 01-28-2014

Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 01:30 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

If I leave my blu ray player set to bitstream Dolby 5.1 there is no diff in the sound at all no matter where the optical cord is plugged into... The only way I get better sound is by changing the blu ray player settings to bitstream dts then running the cord to blu ray player
Youve said that many times. I believe that is what you hear. Do you have a question?
If the Vizio has HDMI why dont you buy an HDMI cable?
JD4L's Avatar JD4L 01:31 PM 01-28-2014
Just trying to get my point across that I'm getting 5.1 and because this sound bar doesn't have hdmi
Bond 007's Avatar Bond 007 01:34 PM 01-28-2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD4L View Post

Just trying to get my point across that I'm getting 5.1 and because this sound bar doesn't have hdmi
And Im trying to get my point across that if you have the optical cable coming from the tv to the soundbar while watching a bluray you are NOT getting 5.1. I can care less if you think you can hear the difference or not. I will not type that again. Enjoy.
Tags: Vizio S4251w B4 5 1 Soundbar
First ... 14  15  16 17  18  ... Last

Up
Mobile  Desktop