I am looking to add a sound bar to the following setup:
Older Panasonic plasma TV - one optical digital out
TiVo Roamio Pro - one optical digital out, component out, and stereo rca out
PS3 - one optical digital out (and stereo rca out - need to be able to connect PS3 with analog, as well, for Rocksmith)
I use the TiVo for everything except for Blu Rays, which I use the PS3 for.
From what I understand, the optical out on most TVs only outputs stereo sound. If this is the case, then I could only get surround sound from the TiVo OR the PS3, by running the optical cable to the soundbar.
So far, I have narrowed my choices down to:
The Vizio S4251w-B4 is a 5.1 system, while the other two are 2.1 systems. Getting decent sound is my primary concern, and I don't absolutely have to have the surround sound. I am really more concerned about the lack of a center channel speaker than the surround speakers.
I wonder if it would be better to go with the Vizio S4251w-B4, manually switching the outputs, when necessary or "settle" for either the Vizio S4221W-C4 or the Sony HTCT260H. I know that the Sony HTCT260H has the HDMI, but my TV is older so it doesn't support ARC.
What do you think would be the best out of these three? Thanks a lot.
I saw some information posted in another thread about an optical audio switch that would let me run all of the necessary outputs into any of the sound bars that I had previously mentioned. Since the 5.1 system is only $50 more, I will probably end up going with the Vizio S4251w-B4.
I am pretty happy with the Sony soundbar. It is a huge improvement over using the TV speakers, and for having a smaller speaker in it, the sub puts out good bass. I don't think that the treble is as bad a a few people have let on, but I still think that the Vizio will sound better, having real tweeters in it. The volume range of the Sony is very adjustable, which was my biggest fear with the Vizio. If you end up with it, let me know what you think of it.
Lol, google search, and you are the thread starter for 2 things I'm interested in.
I'm currently grappling with the same choice. I have a Samsung soundbar+wireless sub right now attached over the top of our Sony W850A with Sewell brackets.
I'm going to move that soundbar to a SamsungTV in another room.
I've also narrowed my choice to the Sony or Vizio 2.1 you have listed.
Are you still happy with your 260H? Is there any way you could take a pic of your above TV setup?
I decided to hold out for this one:
I considered waiting too but I got impatient. There is also a 3851 on the way but no release date announced yet, could be May/June and then another few months for prices to become reasonable.
so i guess PCM is still true 5.1
I'd like to piggy back on this post because I'm having pretty much the same question has the tread starter.
I want a bar for my second living room where a computer is hooked up to a small 32 inch tv. Even if the picture is small I still like a good sound. The furniture in that room doesn't really allow for a receiver (damn cabinet have 6 inches tall compartment). soooo pretty much stuck with a soundbar option.
I just came back from futur shop and listened to the vizio s4221 and s4251
Strangelly enough the s4251 seemed to have more bass (as far as I know it's the same sub in both). Anyway, to my hear the 4251 sounded better with music.
I almost bought it even if I didn't sound perfect to me... I was figuring for the price that it would improve my tv sound... but at the cash I felt like I should really try to listen to the s5451 before buying. They didn't have any in store.
Here is my questions... I don't really need the back speakers so is the 4221 and 4251 should have sounded pretty much the same? Was I tricked by some settings at the store?
And most important question... did someone try the s5451 vs the s4251. There is a 200 dollars canadian difference so I'm wondering if the bigger one really sound better or if it's just numbers there...
Like I said... the s4251 seemed good enough for me but I could hear something was a little wrong... i'll take the plunge with the larger one if it does sound better with music... I have no doubt that either would do well for movies because I'm less picky about that.
P.S. please don't bash my english...it's my second langage... working on improving it everyday!
|Vizio S4251w B4 5 1 Soundbar , Vizio S4221w C4 , Sony Htct260h Sound Bar With Wireless Subwoofer|
|Gear in this thread|