Huh, first store I went to would do one or the other, but not both. I bought one @ 39.99 - 25 = 15 anyway, since that's still a decent deal. But I'm going to have to check the other store in town and see if they're willing to deal.
Went to the other store in town, and they took both discounts, no problem. Since I like a $5 price better than a $15 price, I will be taking one back to the first store.