While out and about today, I looked casually at some of the antenna's available in the area, and even though you recommended staying away from an Amped Antenna. I found a Winegard Flatwave Amped for super cheap at Costco and purchased it to try out.
Since plugging it in, I get every channel on that list, and then some.
The signals so far are all about 70%+. There were a few channels like HSN, QVC, and some other channels we aren't interested in watching that were OK signals and some duplicates that seemed to be from a different location further away, but I disabled them.
There are 14 channels total that we would watch consistently. But so far so good.