Well, we tried the Carrington Farms brand coconut oil from Costco this weekend. It is definitely different from the Lou Ana.
The first thing I noticed was the smell. Lou Ana is almost odorless, while the Carrington Farms oil has a very sweet and distinct smell of coconut. Now, I love coconut, but not with my popcorn. The small was somewhat reminiscent of the old-fashioned popcorn balls, and I think it would be excellent for that. But, for movie-style popcorn, it just didn't work for us. The smell was too sweet and fragrant, and overpowered the taste of the popcorn.
I'll be switching back to Lou Ana, after the Carrington Farms container is done.