Hollie - two solid performances and was the best in the trio song
Phillip - great first song, horrendous duet, and GOD AWFUL 2nd song.
Skylar - unremarkable first song in which she lost her breath running around. Screamed all the big notes in the 2nd song. The worst of the girls in the trio. Not every song needs a country twang. Just sing.
Jessica - butchered Tina Turner. Terrible. Complete crap in the trio, but still better than Skylar. Beautiful vocal on the 2nd song.
Joshua - bored by his first song, loved his 2nd song, was embarrassed for him and Phillip in that duet.
Phillip should go home for that 2nd song, but he won't. My guess is Hollie or Joshua going home, but Skylar, Jessica, or Phillip should be the one to go based solely on tonight.