Which national HD channels distort 4:3 content and which ones don't? - AVS Forum

AVS Forum > HDTV > HDTV Programming > Which national HD channels distort 4:3 content and which ones don't?

HDTV Programming

mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
08:18 AM Liked: 16
post #1 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Just like the title says, I think it would be pretty useful for us to keep a tally of which HD channels keep 4:3 SD programming as is, and which ones zoom/crop/stretch it, and which ones falsely label SD programming as HD.

All of these different modes to manipulating and incorrectly labeling SD programming will do nothing but confused the new HD viewers.

Depending on your preference, I think having a viewer content email address to voice your concern/praise for what they are doing with 4:3 SD content would also help.

I'm at work today so I can't check all channels. However I will post which ones I know of. Please feel free to post what you have seen and I will update the first post when I get the chance.

HD programmers wish list courtesy of sleeks, http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=914106

Another list to view: http://digitalcaffeine.com/hd/

Stretch or Don't Stretch poll: http://www.dbstalk.com/showthread.php?t=102141 Please register and vote if you haven't already.


Leaves as is:
ABC Family
Big Ten Network HD
Bravo HD
CBS College Sports HD (initially distorted 4:3 SD)
CMT HD (Country Music TV)
CNBC HD +
CNN HD
HD Theater
Disney Channel HD
ESPN HD (initially distorted 4:3 SD)
ESPN2 HD
ESPNNews HD
ESPNU
FOX Business Channel HD
FOX News Channel
FOX Soccer Channel
FOX Sports Net
Fuel HD
FX HD
HBO HD
HDNet
HDNet Movies
Golf/Versus HD
Palladia (previously MHD)
MLB Network
MTV HD
NHL Network HD
NFL Network HD
National Geographic HD
Nick HD
Sci Fi HD
Showtime HD
Speed HD
Spike HD
Starz HD
Tennis Channel HD (initially distorted 4:3 SD)
Toon Disney
USA HD
VH1 HD
Weather Channel HD
WGN America HD


Correctly displays 4:3 SD programming, stretches commercials:
NBATV HD

Correctly displays 4:3 SD commercials, stretches programming:
TBS HD

Stretches/Zooms/Crops, grouped by corporate ownership:

A&E Television Networks:
A&E HD, Biography HD, History Channel HD, Crime and Investigation HD feedback@aetv.com

Rainbow Media Holdings:
AMC

Discovery Communications:
Animal Planet HD, Science HD, TLC HD, Discovery HD, Planet Green HD:Couldn't find an email address. You can use this. http://extweb.discovery.com/viewerrelations

Turner Broadcasting System:
[b]Cartoon Network HD, TNT HD: tnt@turner.com Use TNT in HD in the subject line

Scripps Networks:
Food Network HD, HGTV HD http://www.scripps.com/networks/networks-contact.html

Lifetime Networks:
Lifetime HD, Lifetime Movie Network HD

Cox Communications:
Travel Channel HD

IFC-HD

These channels falsely label everything as HD

Animal Planet HD
CMT HD
Discovery HD
Science HD
TBS HD
TNT HD

sleeks's Avatar sleeks
08:37 AM Liked: 11
post #2 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2004
I really fail to understand why the channels force the stretch down to us. Why not let us decide if we want to stretch or zoom.

Thank you ESPN, NFL, and Weather Channel.
acd483's Avatar acd483
08:39 AM Liked: 11
post #3 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 62
Joined: Aug 2005
I'm really disturbed by these channels dicking around with 4:3 content. Leave it to the consumer to zoom, stretch, etc. I know it's a marketing gimmick, but how patronizing!

What is worse is when the channel claims a show is HD, but it's really just stretched. That's false advertising.
afiggatt's Avatar afiggatt
08:43 AM Liked: 10
post #4 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 4,300
Joined: Jan 2004
You should change the title to "Which national HD channels distort 4:3 SD content and which don't". You want to keep this list separate from the broadcast networks that are at the mercy of what the local stations do which would only muddle the list. Second, specify 4:3 SD content because there is 4:3 HD content for old movies which amazingly enough TNT-HD does not stretch (but there are only two 4:3 HD movies I've seen on TNT-HD: Wizard of Oz, Gone with the Wind).

Add Lifetime Movie Network HD to the list of channels that stretch 4:3 SD. Not that I watch the channel, but I see the linear stretch as I surf up and down the HD channels on Fios.

PS. National Geographic HD does show some SD programs (older editions of their series shows) and does not stretch them. So put Nat Geo HD under the list of those who do not.
sleeks's Avatar sleeks
08:44 AM Liked: 11
post #5 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2004
I believe CNN is leaving it as it is. I only was able to watch for about 30 seconds this morning though.
mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
08:51 AM Liked: 16
post #6 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeks View Post

I really fail to understand why the channels force the stretch down to us. Why not let us decide if we want to stretch or zoom.

Thank you ESPN, NFL, and Weather Channel.

Quote:
Originally Posted by acd483 View Post

I'm really disturbed by these channels dicking around with 4:3 content. Leave it to the consumer to zoom, stretch, etc. I know it's a marketing gimmick, but how patronizing!

What is worse is when the channel claims a show is HD, but it's really just stretched. That's false advertising.

This is why I started this thread. So those that like what each channel is doing can say thank you and other that don't like their practice can voice their concerns. That's why we also needs email addresses.
mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
08:52 AM Liked: 16
post #7 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by afiggatt View Post

You should change the title to "Which national HD channels distort 4:3 SD content and which don't". You want to keep this list separate from the broadcast networks that are at the mercy of what the local stations do which would only muddle the list. Second, specify 4:3 SD content because there is 4:3 HD content for old movies which amazingly enough TNT-HD does not stretch (but there are only two 4:3 HD movies I've seen on TNT-HD: Wizard of Oz, Gone with the Wind).

Add Lifetime Movie Network HD to the list of channels that stretch 4:3 SD. Not that I watch the channel, but I see the linear stretch as I surf up and down the HD channels on Fios.

PS. National Geographic HD does show some SD programs (older editions of their series shows) and does not stretch them. So put Nat Geo HD under the list of those who do no.

Changed the wording to 4:3 SD programming. A mod has to change the title, but I think yours is a good idea.
Ken H's Avatar Ken H
08:56 AM Liked: 12
post #8 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 45,876
Joined: Nov 1999
Topic title edited.

You can probably add TBS HD to the list of stretched.
CPanther95's Avatar CPanther95
08:59 AM Liked: 73
post #9 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 23,797
Joined: Oct 2002
.... and CNN to the list of "leaves as is"
Marcus Carr's Avatar Marcus Carr
09:26 AM Liked: 31
post #10 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 8,088
Joined: Sep 2004
HGTV HD stretches infomercials and commercials, but all of their real programs are HD.

Golf/Vs does not stretch.
CPanther95's Avatar CPanther95
09:36 AM Liked: 73
post #11 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 23,797
Joined: Oct 2002
I'd like to also see an asterisk or some notation for any networks that label upconverted SD content as "HD" in their guide data. That really compounds the SD manipulation problem because scheduling recordings or viewings are affected.

I may pass on an SD program entirely, but there are times where even in SD I'll want to record, but if it's labeled incorrectly, I won't know to record the SD channel instead.
teevman's Avatar teevman
09:49 AM Liked: 12
post #12 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 275
Joined: Jul 2006
stretched content is hazardous to your health, mine anyways
sleeks's Avatar sleeks
11:09 AM Liked: 11
post #13 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2004
Working on an email campaign at dbstalk.

See link


http://www.dbstalk.com/showthread.php?t=101206
BradleyGreen's Avatar BradleyGreen
11:16 AM Liked: 10
post #14 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 245
Joined: Sep 2004
Big 10 Net appears to leave it as it is...
Amnesia's Avatar Amnesia
11:19 AM Liked: 12
post #15 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken H View Post

You can probably add TBS HD to the list of stretched.

"Probably"? I would hope that it wasn't added until stretching had been observed.

If people are just guessing, then what use is the list?
CPanther95's Avatar CPanther95
11:21 AM Liked: 73
post #16 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 23,797
Joined: Oct 2002
He's not guessing. TBS does the same goofy distorted circus mirror stretch that TNT uses.
Keenan's Avatar Keenan
11:23 AM Liked: 442
post #17 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 28,489
Joined: Aug 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amnesia View Post

"Probably"? I would hope that it wasn't added until stretching had been observed.

If people are just guessing, then what use is the list?

It wasn't a guess. TBS-HD is stretching. Looks rather bad in fact.
Keenan's Avatar Keenan
11:27 AM Liked: 442
post #18 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 28,489
Joined: Aug 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPanther95 View Post

He's not guessing. TBS does the same goofy distorted circus mirror stretch that TNT uses.

Yes, it's a hideous looking non-linear stretch of some sort.
Amnesia's Avatar Amnesia
11:39 AM Liked: 12
post #19 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2006
Then I don't understand why he used the word "probably".
hall's Avatar hall
11:43 AM Liked: 40
post #20 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 2,636
Joined: Mar 2004
Where is (Discovery) HD Theatre ? The Discovery channel listed above is the simulcast of the standard Discovery channel, I presume.

HD Theatre falls under "Leaves as is".
Marcus Carr's Avatar Marcus Carr
11:50 AM Liked: 31
post #21 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 8,088
Joined: Sep 2004
Quote:
Originally Posted by hall View Post

Where is (Discovery) HD Theatre ? The Discovery channel listed above is the simulcast of the standard Discovery channel, I presume.

HD Theatre falls under "Leaves as is".

HD Theater doesn't show any 4:3 SD programs.
mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
12:02 PM Liked: 16
post #22 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeks View Post

Working on an email campaign at dbstalk.

See link


http://www.dbstalk.com/showthread.php?t=101206

We can work together. I'll keep mine up over here.
richiephx's Avatar richiephx
12:51 PM Liked: 10
post #23 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 446
Joined: Sep 2006
Great idea...count me in
sleeks's Avatar sleeks
12:58 PM Liked: 11
post #24 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2004
Quote:
Originally Posted by mx6bfast View Post

We can work together. I'll keep mine up over here.


Perfect. The more the merrier. I'd love for these guys to get hammered with emails over the next few weeks. I realize they may not make a change overnight, but it can happen.
mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
12:59 PM Liked: 16
post #25 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeks View Post

Perfect. The more the merrier. I'd love for these guys to get hammered with emails over the next few weeks. I realize they may not make a change overnight, but it can happen.

ESPN did it, so you never know.

Maybe this can be stickied so it doesn't fall off the first page?
sleeks's Avatar sleeks
01:12 PM Liked: 11
post #26 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,198
Joined: Sep 2004
Quote:
Originally Posted by mx6bfast View Post

ESPN did it, so you never know.

Maybe this can be stickied so it doesn't fall off the first page?

Showtime also went to most movies being OAR thanks to this forum and emails/phone calls.

Personally, if a movie isn't in OAR, I don't watch. Thank goodness for HDNET Movies (and Netflix)
PRMan's Avatar PRMan
01:19 PM Liked: 10
post #27 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 1,853
Joined: Jul 2000
Can we differentiate between Discovery's zoomed channels and A&E's stretched channels?

While both are sub-optimal, I find that I can actually watch Discovery's channels. I don't like it, but I can watch it, because 300 lb people aren't running around.
mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
01:30 PM Liked: 16
post #28 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by PRMan View Post

Can we differentiate between Discovery's zoomed channels and A&E's stretched channels?

While both are sub-optimal, I find that I can actually watch Discovery's channels. I don't like it, but I can watch it, because 300 lb people aren't running around.

I had them broken out earlier but put them together because they might zoom and stretch. I just didn't want to run into a station that does both. I guess we would have to create a new section for that.
afiggatt's Avatar afiggatt
01:34 PM Liked: 10
post #29 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 4,300
Joined: Jan 2004
So it this a DirecTV thread for the HD channels currently carried on DirecTV? Where is National Geographic HD (no stretch), Lifetime Movie Network HD (stretches all SD). These two are going to be up on D* at some point. The fact that Lifetime Movie Net HD is stretched strongly indicates that Lifetime will be a stretched channel whenever the HD version goes live.

I don't recall seeing any stretching on HGTV, except for commercials, because I thought it was all HD channel. If they stretch only the commercials, does that count? If so, Showtime HD stretches the upconverted promos for their shows & movies. If the channel is going to be listed for only stretching the promos and/or commercials, then that should be noted in the list.
mx6bfast's Avatar mx6bfast
01:43 PM Liked: 16
post #30 of 310
09-26-2007 | Posts: 6,891
Joined: Mar 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by afiggatt View Post

So it this a DirecTV thread for the HD channels currently carried on DirecTV? Where is National Geographic HD (no stretch), Lifetime Movie Network HD (stretches all SD). These two are going to be up on D* at some point. The fact that Lifetime Movie Net HD is stretched strongly indicates that Lifetime will be a stretched channel whenever the HD version goes live.

I don't recall seeing any stretching on HGTV, except for commercials, because I thought it was all HD channel. If they stretch only the commercials, does that count? If so, Showtime HD stretches the upconverted promos for their shows & movies. If the channel is going to be listed for only stretching the promos and/or commercials, then that should be noted in the list.

No this is for all carriers. No one is safe.

Reply HDTV Programming

Subscribe to this Thread

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3