AVS Forum

AVS Forum (http://www.avsforum.com/forum/)
-   OLED Technology and Flat Panels General (http://www.avsforum.com/forum/40-oled-technology-flat-panels-general/)
-   -   LG 55EA9800 55" OLED Owner's thread (http://www.avsforum.com/forum/40-oled-technology-flat-panels-general/1493578-lg-55ea9800-55-oled-owner-s-thread.html)

Cleveland Plasma 10-05-2013 09:41 AM

Looks like the OLED's are actually out this year ! Here is LG's take, 55EA9800. These have hit the streets.



Click Here for more info.

Altahlus 10-06-2013 12:38 AM

Got to see one of these a couple of days ago, the picture quality was superb, viewing angels perfect, the blacks was reeally black, but I did find two dead pixels, so I gues Oled can also have them as plasma/lcd. But I can't wait to get a 75" Oled in my living room..

ALMA 10-08-2013 12:53 AM

First test results from Digitalversus.com
Quote:
With LG's 55EA980V, the black is perfectly black. So much so that it's impossible to make out the TV when watching with the lights off—even after your eyes have had a couple of minutes to adjust to the dark conditions.
Quote:
As you can see from the images above, this OLED screen has viewing angles on par with plasmas. From 45 degrees, we measured the variation in brightness at just 10%.
Quote:
And this OLED TV has still more impressive performances in store, as screen responsiveness is simply incredible! As soon as an image appears onscreen the previous frame has already gone. We've never seen such an amazing result from a TV! In comparison, the most responsive LCD TVs get ghosting times of 8 ms in our responsiveness tests, whereas the speediest plasmas get around 6 ms. The LG 55EA980V, however, pushes that down under 1 ms. That's so good that we can still hardly believe it!

http://www.digitalversus.com/tv-television/lg-55ea980v-p16197/lg-55ea980v-oled-tv-first-test-results-promise-impressive-performance-n31265.html

somelogin 10-08-2013 03:59 PM

Wish LG would give me a free one. Also, supposedly even the passive 3D impressed them. I know most people don't care about 3D, but it's a nice feature to use every once in a while.

Wizziwig 10-14-2013 11:36 AM

New review:

http://www.digitalversus.com/tv-television/lg-55ea980w-p16197/test.html#full-review

Mr.SoftDome 10-16-2013 09:55 PM

Got to see my first OLED yesterday. Went to buy headphones at our standalone Magnolia. Finally got to your LG. I really liked it a lot. They were only playing an LG marketing clip but it was great to finally see it. The greens looked too saturated to me but would love to see a Blu-Ray on it. But that aside very impressive. Not sure if a motion issue on a couple of clips.

I must say I think the curved screen is subtle and looks hot to me. The whole set looks beyond sexy and pics don't do it justice. I am beyond fine with curved screen. 70 inches and wall mountable with curve would work now that I've seen it.

Need to see a movie! How is motion? Sports? Something looked a bit off at times like in the waterfall clip. Remember the beer signs with the waterfalls in bars or pizza shacks? Kinna fun to watch but also a bit cartoonish. Maybe just me or settings. Other clips looked great.

Congrad's on your set.

Rick

Cleveland Plasma 10-31-2013 02:20 PM

It was very difficult not throwing out any feelers. She just got here !



First impression in the 5 minute's I have had it, light, very light weight. They need to take the LED part out of OLED as the picture is amazing, more of plasma VT or ZT Panasonic quality.

Cleveland Plasma 10-31-2013 05:25 PM

Wow, just amazing....... Black levels are super inky, Off angle superb. What technology we have !!





vinnie97 10-31-2013 05:50 PM

Inky, I take it you mean!

Wizziwig 11-01-2013 12:16 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cleveland Plasma View Post

Wow, just amazing....... Black levels are super inky, Off angle superb. What technology we have !!

Is it time to rename your business to "Cleveland OLED"? smile.gif Sound like the Plasma selection will be rather limited in 2014.

For the off-angle shots, you should have used the hockey game. The color shift is most apparent on white/gray images on the Samsung.

Will you be doing a full calibration and review on the LG?

8mile13 11-01-2013 07:36 AM

In a worst-case scenario it will be renamed ''Cleveland Edge-Lit'' tongue.gif

sytech 11-01-2013 08:30 AM

Very nice blacks, but in the last picture is all that blooming really going on or is caused by the camera?

Chronoptimist 11-01-2013 10:06 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by sytech View Post

Very nice blacks, but in the last picture is all that blooming really going on or is caused by the camera?
Looks like the camera; most likely a cellphone.

Cleveland Plasma 11-01-2013 11:29 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by sytech View Post

Very nice blacks, but in the last picture is all that blooming really going on or is caused by the camera?
Camera. Chad will be here tomorrow to work his magic along with Buzz on Sunday. Chad will have a long time with this set, he will be in until Monday. Also, if there is hockey on tonight I will get that off angled picture as well.

---Any special requests within reason ?

---Yes in the next 15 days we will be changing our name........ frown.gif Nothing else is Changing though smile.gif

buzzard767 11-01-2013 12:12 PM

If you find hockey, record it and let's look for evidence of visible ABL. Hopefully it's not as pronounced as PDP. We'll look at the AVSHD disc ABL pattern as well.

Gradius2 11-01-2013 06:39 PM

Get a REAL camera and take quasi-REAL photos with it. biggrin.gif

Timothy91 11-02-2013 07:09 PM

Wow. I actually have money in the bank for a house downpayment and I.......could.......buy.......this.......ARGH!!!!

vinnie97 11-02-2013 07:38 PM

The former is a way better investment.

Cleveland Plasma 11-03-2013 02:19 AM

We may have, well I guess we do have the new king, This LG OLED has black levels about 3 folds better than the Pioneer Kuro plasma. The Elite LED had better blacks than the Elite Plasma but there was plenty of blooming so some would say the Elite LED was not king. The OLED has little to no blooming.

---More testing to be done. I am sure there are some drawbacks as well..........more to come !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Timothy91 View Post

Wow. I actually have money in the bank for a house down payment and I.......could.......buy.......this.......ARGH!!!!
Back in the day the Pioneer Kuro plasma was king. The 60" unit was the biggest made and "about" $6500-$7000 on the street.. People paid this price all day long to get the best. This unit is 5" smaller and now "confirmed" to be better in black levels by about 3 folds, yes its true ! Chad and Buzz checked the set out last night. This LG streets for about $7,500. With this being said it is higher in price than the old king, however it is not that far off. There is one key as well here, this is the first year of OLED. The main difference between the Pioneer Kuro days and today, is back then the economy was good, now it is not so good frown.gif
.

vinnie97 11-03-2013 09:31 AM

^The LG does not sit in isolation, though. There is a Samsung that is just as good, if not better. wink.gif

buzzard767 11-03-2013 11:59 AM

Last night and this morning I spent a little time interrupting Chad and his work. I won't take anything from Chad's upcoming report but I will say that this display has attributes I've never before seen.

Here's Chad at work ---



Here's me at work --- rolleyes.gif


Chad B 11-04-2013 09:19 AM

I first heard of OLED display technology many years ago at a trade show. OLED sounded so exciting, but it was years before anything larger than a tiny monitor became available. Cleveland Plasma owner Chris Majoros arranged for me to get my first taste of OLED technology with the LG 55EA9800. The EA9800 has a beautiful, slightly curved screen design with a clear, crystal like base that imparts a free floating look. While the glossy screen does a good job of staying dark with a moderate amount of ambient light, reflections can be very distracting if care is not taken to minimize bright light sources in front of the screen.

Before calibration:

Sound quality from the EA9800's built in speakers was surprisingly good, with very clear dialogue and relatively adequate handling of movie sound effects.

Vivid mode looked over enhanced, as is often the case. Colors were too bold and strong, and whites looked bluish and over exposed. Brightly lit faces were slightly glazed over, with a caked on makeup look. Shadow detail was strong and neutral toned. The combination of high light output and very deep blacks gave a very impressive sense of contrast.


Standard mode was an improvement over Vivid in every respect except colors, which were even bolder and over the top. There was more sense of depth, and the picture had a smooth, almost glossy photo quality.


Eco mode looked somewhat similar to Standard, but was less intense. Skin tones and colors were still too hot, but the added richness was a welcome improvement.


THX Cinema mode made a fundamental change to the picture. Whites took on a slightly off white tone, and the image appeared a bit washed out. Shadow detail was perhaps a bit too strong, but colors looked fairly natural. With the reduced light output, the image became more natural though a bit bland and shallow. Still an excellent picture overall, most viewers will probably not take to THX mode's relative lack of excitement.


Game mode turned out to be a pleasant surprise, with a good balance between the excitement of Standard and the naturalness of THX. Colors were still too vivid; but motion, shadow detail, and clarity were all very good. Game mode seemed to strike the best balance between accuracy and vibrancy.


The ISF Expert modes had similar color presentations to THX, though the image seemed a bit more defined and less washed out.


Over all, the EA9800's out of the box tuning was well above average, with oodles of contrast, pop, smoothness, and clarity.

Calibration:

Calibration was performed with a Jeti 1211 spectroradiometer, along with Klein K-10a (thanks Buzz!) and X-Rite i1D3 colorimeters, both profiled off the reference Jeti spectro.

Sources close to the engineering team, who spoke under conditions of anonymity since they admittedly have an overactive imagination, report overhearing the following conversation during the design of the EA9800:
“10 point adjustments are great. They worked good on our LED LCDs.”

“Well, we gotta come out ahead! Let's give 'em 20!”

“Some people didn't like our old partial CMS adjustments, though. They worked OK, but they didn't have enough control to really get it dialed in.”

“I know you think we don't have all the kinks ironed out yet, but put the full CMS adjustment in there too. It's OK, at least we'll have the most adjustments. I pity the fool who tries to use 'em, though! And make sure to give 'em that new space age remote... You know, that wand like thing I seen you waving around. It won't help none when they go to make the adjustments, but it's the coolest thing I ever did see!”

The EA9800 presented some tough calibration challenges. The first issue became apparent soon into my first pass of the 20 point adjustment: if the same shaped object is displayed on the AE9800 for more than a brief period, the TV loses light output, giving way to fatigue. It doesn't matter if the intensity or color is changed; the shape seems to be the trigger. Unchecked, that leads to wildly inaccurate calibration. Stopping the calibration after each control or two and popping up other portions of the menu or other test patterns seemed to be the only solution; and even then, multiple passes were required for any precision. If the problematic 20 point adjustment is ignored and only the simple 2 point adjustment is calibrated, gamma and grayscale tracking have visible errors because of the quirky tracking of the 2 point adjustment.

In addition to panel fatigue, the 20 points progressively mistrack at the high end if the contrast control is not kept very high.

I found that the best way to calibrate the 20 point control was not to try to do it in real time, but rather pass by pass, making adjustments after each pass as needed.

Finally, I discovered that all of the CMS adjustments, but especially the red saturation and luminance, have severe side effects. Making significant adjustments to these controls resulted in patchy looking skin tones, and taken to the extreme they turn Hollywood's most beautiful people into horrifying zombie-like creatures.

The great news is despite these issues, the AE9800 had the most impressive contrast performance I've ever seen, and it did so without resorting to such things as dimming zones or floating blacks. Full black fields were under the .0001 fL threshold of the mighty Klein K-10a.


After calibration, the ANSI checkerboard contrast ratio measured around 70,000:1, with a very small amount of light leakage leading to blacks that measured between .0006 and .0007 fL. Whites measured about 47.1 fL in this test.

There was no real change between different size measurement windows, and there was no color shift when ABL finally kicked in with full fields. There should be no mystery surrounding what size or style of windows to use when calibrating the EA9800, as it appears that just about any window will give similar results. The maximum light output with a 100% full white field was about 24 fL, indicating minimal ABL intrusion. Another test of ABL is the dynamic brightness pattern on the AVS 709 test disc, which showed some brightness limiting but less than what would be seen on a plasma.

White field uniformity was excellent, with no visible changes across the screen. Black uniformity was not an issue since black was totally dark. Off axis, whites take on a more off white, yellowish tone, but otherwise the picture appears to have no change. Images are perfectly watchable at extreme off axis angles, though with the curved screen and white balance shift giving a distinctive character.


Below are measurements of the differences between the color space selections of the EA9800's advanced picture menu.

Standard and BT709:


EBU:


SMPTE:


Wide:


Sony and some others in the industry recommend using spectrometers set to the Judd Vos modified 2 degree CMF for OLED displays. I tried that for the day mode calibration and all the before calibration measurements. For the night mode, I switched back to the standard 1931 CIE 2 degree setting. I found the standard 1931 CIE setting gave the most neutral looking white balance, with the Judd mod setting appearing a bit cool and giving a slightly reddish cast to skin tones.

ISF Night mode after calibration:


ISF Day mode after calibration:


After calibration:

Each time I viewed the EA9800, I was struck by how photo realistic the image was. I believe the exceptionally smooth yet detailed presentation along with the exceptional blacks are what contributed to this impression.

Watching Battleship on DirecTV revealed exceptional pop, natural skin tones, and great detail in dark areas of the picture. The combination of smoothness, clarity, depth, and contrast was beyond anything I had experienced before. Skin tones were natural, and colors of all shades had an addictive vibrancy.

On one HBO promo that featured vibrating and shaking white letters on a black background, I noticed color fringing around the edges of the letters while they shook. Thankfully, that was the only time I noticed the effect. Some upconverted standard def programming on a certain channel seemed to require a reduction in the contrast control of the ISF Day mode to avoid glazing over brightly lit faces. Otherwise, standard definition programming looked better than I expected.

If you like very bright images, the EA9800 can deliver, with no apparent sacrifice in accuracy or stability. Hockey looked great, with good purity and brightness of the ice and fine motion. No dirty screen effect or ABL action was visible in that or any other programming.

Compared to the best plasmas, namely the Pioneer Elite Kuro and the Panasonic VT/ZT60, the EA9800 is significantly superior in most areas, especially smoothness and clarity. Contrast is superior also, with the EA9800 maintaining that contrast even in dark movie scenes. It's greater light output capability means that, provided reflections are minimized, the EA9800 will look punchier and more exciting in rooms with moderately bright ambient light. Color accuracy is very good, though this is one area where the EA9800's measured performance could not quite match that of the reference plasmas. Thankfully, any measured color accuracy deficiencies were so minor that they were not visible with normal programming, which always had beautiful color in ISF Night mode. In comparison with arguably the best LED LCD, the Sharp Elite, the EA9800 displays visibly better color, no blooming around white objects, and better purity in moving white objects such as hockey rinks. In short, the EA9800 is the best of the best, handily surpassing previous reference displays.

buzzard767 11-04-2013 09:46 AM

I would add that reference viewing, sans reflections, in a darkened room, was mind boggling. OLED is the best so far and the future is now. cool.gif

buzzard767 11-04-2013 09:47 AM

Nice new avatar, Chad. biggrin.gif

8mile13 11-04-2013 10:31 AM

What about the curve? Seems to me that the curve makes this TV, at this size, only suitable for one person, two people max.

Chad B 11-04-2013 12:38 PM

I didnt find it obtrusive at all even at extreme angles.

turbe 11-04-2013 09:44 PM



The mystical barefoot calibrator strikes again eek.gif

htwaits 11-04-2013 09:53 PM

The earth is flat and I refuse to buy a TV that isn't also flat. Flat, I want flat. eek.gif

Cleveland Plasma 11-05-2013 06:20 AM

There are times when you do not even realize it is curved....... I would like a flat one as well though.

tgm1024 11-05-2013 10:49 AM

Quote:

 

I hope you're right about the curve not being intrusive.  Because this photo above makes me cringe.



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 01:49 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.