Well, turned out to be an easy decision. I just need to record the late-night talk shows, that's it. Turns out 3 of them (Kimmel, Fallon, Colbert) are on at the same time. So I need at least 3 tuners. Tivo has 4, DVR+ has 2.
***EDIT: I flip-flopped and ordered the DVR+ because:
1) After reading dozens of reviews, it appears the DVR+ has a better tuner than Roamio OTA. Seems like DVR+ tuner is better for rural areas and Roamio is better for metro areas. Saw this in several reviews.
2) Several reviews go on and on about DVR+ great picture quality. Didn't see that for Roamio. I realize they both start with the same signal, but maybe the DVR+ video output path uses a better algorithm or scaler, etc.
Last edited by othermbx; 01-31-2017 at 03:36 PM.