Welcome to the forum. I live very, very close to you. See my earlier posts which describe my setup. I will tell you that, even though Riverview is only 40 miles away, an attic mounted antenna is not reliable all of the time. I have no experience with either of the antennas you are referring to.
Currently I'm using a combination of DirecTV and the attic antenna. I've given up on Holiday, as it's just too far away. I may throw in the towel and pay the $$$ for Comcast's HD lineup. They are, however, lacking NBC, but actually Ft. Myers, off the back of my attic antenna, comes in pretty good.