Once you have a short list - it is up to your ears, and your ears alone to make the final decision.
All the speakers on it are good, and would each make some people happy. You are at the personal preference stage of the decision.
My personal preference should be irrelevant, anybody else's personal preference should be irrelevant - yours is the only one that counts.
The best kind of advice is what elihawk gave, maybe add another to your list - but then the decision needs to be based on your ears, no one else's.
btw. You may not get as many answers here as you'd like. This is the third thread you've started, all on the same topic. People generally prefer to keep a single conversation, on a single topic, for a single person...in a single thread. Any particular reason you didn't just want to add your list to the existing "bookshelf help" thread?