Originally Posted by Dynero
James in all fairness the post i complained had absolutely nothing to do with Dynaudio in terms of context, comparison, etc. I simply didn't feel it was appropriate and i thought i should pipe in.
Even the Naim posts a few months back were too much and the conflict ended up with RaceTripper leaving, I'm not grandstanding or anything here but just wanted this thread to get back to it's roots.
As for a complete ban on posts and systems? Well I'll say it again at the risk of sounding like a tool, if your system has non dynaudio speakers, does not have relevance to Dynaudio in terms of system synergy or lack thereof and has in fact nothing to do with Dynaudio at all, then maybe you should consider posting it in another thread that doesn't say Dynaudio at the top
I'm with you. I agree that the majority of the posts in a Dynaudio forum should directly or indirectly be about Dynaudio. But as has been stated before, I think it's pretty educational to hear experiences from others, about other systems. Of course, in this context, that's only helpful if it's somehow related to Dynaudio-experiences. For example: I have been Dynaudio-free for a while, when I had Elac speakers. I found them dissapointing, despite a few strong points. I read here that others on a similar quest to improve their sound ended up with a different brand of speakers too. In that case, it could be educational to exchange stories and experiences. But these discussions were not about Dynaudio.
But still: this is a community with a common interest. It's nice to talk about different stuff. Different thoughts can be excanged, new ideas may arise, etc. Yes, this is a Dynaudio topic. But I think it's a bit nuts to start an "everything but Dynaudio" thread , just to keep the same people together with the ability to talk about non-Dynaudio stuff.
Besides: it's the internet. It's a (more or less) public place. People will talk about whatever they want, regardless of thread subject. Your cause is a noble one. But I doubt how many "followers" you'll get. What's happening now, is that people have resorted to throwing sarcasm at each other, because they don't agree. Not very mature. But that too, is the internet...