Home Theater Direct (HTD) Owner's Thread - Page 16 - AVS Forum

AVS Forum > Audio > Speakers > Home Theater Direct (HTD) Owner's Thread

Speakers

bgtighe23
03:24 PM Liked: 5
post #451 of 471
11-22-2014 | Posts: 149
Joined: Sep 2014
I recently came across HTD in another thread. You really don't see many reviews on their products, but they look beautiful. I currently have the Andrew Jones Pioneer towers and curious how these would sound comparatively. I'm not concerned with bass output because of my 5.2 system but I'm looking to change things up.

Another product I was curious if anyone could compare these with is the new EMP Tek bookshelves. These 3 speakers (pioneers, EMP Teks, and HTDs) are all in the similar price range, though the bookshelves would require stands if used as mains.

I have my surrounds on actual bookshelves so no need for extra stands, 12x12 basic room, 2 windows, and a entry door way on opposite side of room the HT is located - about 10 ft. away from my center channel and tv is my listening position.
artyusmce's Avatar artyusmce
03:33 PM Liked: 13
post #452 of 471
11-22-2014 | Posts: 207
Joined: Apr 2006
love mine almost ten years on level 3 bookshelves
only issue sub died a year ago
rfb6435's Avatar rfb6435
04:22 PM Liked: 13
post #453 of 471
11-22-2014 | Posts: 59
Joined: Oct 2002
Quote:
Originally Posted by artyusmce View Post
love mine almost ten years on level 3 bookshelves
only issue sub died a year ago
Did the amp die? If so it is pretty easy to modify it to use the new style external amp. Just need to bypass the old amp. It should have speaker level inputs so you can connect the old speaker level input to external amp and internally to the driver and it will all be very clean.
artyusmce's Avatar artyusmce
04:30 PM Liked: 13
post #454 of 471
11-22-2014 | Posts: 207
Joined: Apr 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by rfb6435 View Post
Did the amp die? If so it is pretty easy to modify it to use the new style external amp. Just need to bypass the old amp. It should have speaker level inputs so you can connect the old speaker level input to external amp and internally to the driver and it will all be very clean.
That's the plan when my Inuke arrives will share duty with my DIY sub I'm building right now
MarsianMan's Avatar MarsianMan
11:14 AM Liked: 27
post #455 of 471
11-28-2014 | Posts: 321
Joined: Nov 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by bgtighe23 View Post
I recently came across HTD in another thread. You really don't see many reviews on their products, but they look beautiful. I currently have the Andrew Jones Pioneer towers and curious how these would sound comparatively. I'm not concerned with bass output because of my 5.2 system but I'm looking to change things up.

Another product I was curious if anyone could compare these with is the new EMP Tek bookshelves. These 3 speakers (pioneers, EMP Teks, and HTDs) are all in the similar price range, though the bookshelves would require stands if used as mains.

I have my surrounds on actual bookshelves so no need for extra stands, 12x12 basic room, 2 windows, and a entry door way on opposite side of room the HT is located - about 10 ft. away from my center channel and tv is my listening position.
Based on listening to the towers, EMP Tek and HTDs are--in my opinion--better than the Pioneers. Unless maybe you get Dennis Murphy's affordable accuracy versions. I haven't listened to them, but I own his Philharmonitor speakers and trust his ear. For the price the EMP Tek is great, but the treble I found slightly lacking in clarity. The HTD treble I found to be more forward but very smooth. I seem to have a thing for the riboon tweeters I have heard.
GusGus748s's Avatar GusGus748s
12:23 AM Liked: 608
post #456 of 471
11-29-2014 | Posts: 6,463
Joined: Mar 2009
Arx speakers use ribbon tweeters, and that's what I've got. Love them! Awesome for both movies and music. You can't go wrong with HTD as well.
Moxified's Avatar Moxified
07:57 AM Liked: 10
post #457 of 471
12-02-2014 | Posts: 40
Joined: Jul 2012
I just purchased 7 HTD HD-W65 speakers for my dedicated small theater. I wanted in-walls for space constraints as the room is only 15x9.

Of course you have to install them to hear what they sound like. I installed the front three and they sounded decent so I moved forward with the remaining 4. After watching a couple of movies I find that there is a very specific phase kind of sound that they produce primarily on dialogue. I'm guessing it is an issue with the crossover?

I honestly have a hard time putting my finger on exactly what I'm hearing. It isn't muffled. They are crisp and have decent low end. Actually it kind of sounds like it is metallic. Perhaps I'm not used to the aluminum tweeters. Almost like tapping on a piece of sheet metal or something mixed in with the dialogue. Again, hard to explain.

I have tried individual speakers, many different settings and they all seem to do it.

Of course I'm a little screwed as they are painted to match my walls and obviously they would leave behind holes.

I guess I'm looking for anybody else's experience or thoughts on the situation.
horseflesh's Avatar horseflesh
08:37 AM Liked: 40
post #458 of 471
12-02-2014 | Posts: 636
Joined: Nov 2000
Moxified, I had a damn strange problem with my HTDs... It sounded like a bad midrange driver, kind of sizzling during playback of certain sounds. High-pitched string instruments would always do it... bells, chimes, the high ranges of speech, that kind of thing.

I went through two driver replacements, which HTD assured me was damn strange. Drivers rarely fail. They were also emphatic that it would not be the crossover.

In the end, the culprit turned out to be my Pioneer AVR. When I switched to an Onkyo, all my problems went away, and stayed gone.

There is a lot about my case that didn't make sense. Neither my nor HTD really understood what was going on--best guess was the Pioneer had too much DC offset for the HTDs to handle. I even exchanged Pioneers, and the replacement had the same issue... But the Onkyo did not.

So, based on my experience, I suggest you find a way to drive your HTDs with a receiver of a different make, and see if the problem manifests any differently. Yeah, it is a long shot... the sound you describe isn't like the distortion I had. But it's something.

Good luck!
go pack
07:26 PM Liked: 0
post #459 of 471
12-26-2014 | Posts: 8
Joined: Dec 2014
Klipsch or HTD for a 5.0 system?
Newbie looking for advice. I'm finishing our basement into a combo home theater and family room, approx 14' x 26', but the couch and viewing area are on one side. In a 14' x 15' area of the space. Help me out people: Should i go with Klispch Reference II series in the 52 line - RF -52, RB 52, and RC 52, or Home Theater Direct level 3, 2 towers , 2 bookshelves and a center. These are both in my price range ($1250 vs $1350). Or would bookshelves for fronts be just as good as the towers?

The HTD might have a 6.5" speaker vs the Klipsch 5.5" - but the Klipsch sensitivity is much higher. - well into the 90's. That's the important thing right? These will mostly be used for TV/Movies/Football. I will be using a Denon 2307CI receiver and a Dayton Audio 10" sub. These are to replace my hodgepodge of Polk S6 fronts, Cerwin Vega center channel and JBL rears. Looking for crisper dialogue, will the Level 3 towers with a midrange help this more than using a center and 4 bookshelves if i go with HTD?

Any advice is appreciated. Thanks!
GusGus748s's Avatar GusGus748s
01:48 AM Liked: 608
post #460 of 471
Yesterday | Posts: 6,463
Joined: Mar 2009
Klipsch speakers have higher sensitivity, but their issue is their horn tweeter. To me they sound too bright, which hurt my ears. I would suggest the HTD Level 3 with the ribbon tweeters. I've got the Arx speakers, which use the ribbon tweeter, and they are warm and neutral. Sound much better. I would suggest buying bookshelves speakers, and with the money you save buy a better sub.
wardman1
06:55 AM Liked: 0
post #461 of 471
Yesterday | Posts: 32
Joined: Nov 2014
GoPack : Same boat for me - have heard HTD from members but then that Klipsch would be their preference. Can someone define "bright"? Space is the consideration for me and If I can get good TV sound with the RB42/52 and their rears, I might opt for it since I can actually hear them. I do not want to bring in HTD and ship back.

I also thought rear porting would be an issue, but in GoPack's other thread it appears it is not anymore, and Klipsch might be preferred over HTD.

I will have a sub - big room so thinking about adding a 12 or 15" to assist.
horseflesh's Avatar horseflesh
01:30 PM Liked: 40
post #462 of 471
Yesterday | Posts: 636
Joined: Nov 2000
I have an HTD system, and when I had a problem I got really good email and phone support from the office. If you really can't decide between the two, service might be the tie breaker. I doubt you'd get such good service from a huge brand like Klipsch.
bgtighe23
03:48 PM Liked: 5
post #463 of 471
Yesterday | Posts: 149
Joined: Sep 2014
Just ordered HTD level 3 bookshelves and center. Hoping to review soon. It's been a while.
rfb6435's Avatar rfb6435
12:58 AM Liked: 13
post #464 of 471
Today | Posts: 59
Joined: Oct 2002
Quote:
Originally Posted by GusGus748s View Post
Klipsch speakers have higher sensitivity, but their issue is their horn tweeter. To me they sound too bright, which hurt my ears. I would suggest the HTD Level 3 with the ribbon tweeters. I've got the Arx speakers, which use the ribbon tweeter, and they are warm and neutral. Sound much better. I would suggest buying bookshelves speakers, and with the money you save buy a better sub.
Sensitivity matters the most if you require very high sound pressure level (very loud) without using an amplifier that can supply a lot of power or if your speakers have low sensitivity and low power handling.

Sensitivity defines the speaker pressure level SPL that is output by the speaker at 1 watt.
90db sensativity means that they will provide 90db at 1 meter.

After that you lose 6db per extra meter away from the speaker.

So the overall SPL depends on:
  • Sensitivity
  • Speaker Power Handing Capabiilty
  • Amp Power Supplied Before Distortion
  • Distance from the speaker
  • Number Of Speakers (doubling the number of speakers adds 3db)

If you max out your amplifier or speakers then you hit the real SPL limit for the given speaker.

Try this calculator out: http://myhometheater.homestead.com/splcalculator.html

I just got a pair of HTD Middy speakers for my front heights and was surprised to see that they were 90db@1W.

They are more sensitive than the Level 2 bookshelf's which are 87db@1W that I use as surrounds. They max out at 80W but are 3db more sensitive so the specs say that they are actually louder than the Level 2 bookshelf speakers. The Middy speakers can provide 109db at 1M where the Level 2 Bookshelf is only 107db when both are completely maxed out. The middies have less bass response of course but that isn't a big issue for heights or surround channels. In reality a 2db difference would be barely perceivable (the equivalent of 1 foot closer or farther away from each speaker).

The important thing though is that the sensitivity is just for pure pressure level or noise level that is created per watt of power. That says nothing about how they actually sound.

In the end, the 6db of extra sensitivity from the Klipsch is equivalent to sitting 1 meter (3.28ft) farther away from them to achieve the same volume level relative to a 90db HTD speaker.

-Rich
go pack
08:09 AM Liked: 0
post #465 of 471
Today | Posts: 8
Joined: Dec 2014
Purchased the Klipsch's yesterday after listening to them and Definitive audio products at the local electronics store.(Flanner's) The Klipsch are definitively "brassyer" but I like the clarity of vocals and the dialogue. They sound amazing! I went with 52 center and towers, RS 41 surrounds. ~ $1230 with tax. My only question now - should I have gone with 62's? I'm going to go back to the store to give them a listen.

FYI I was willing to pay a little more for the service at a local store, but found the prices the same as the lowest internet prices (Acoustic Sound Design) The salesman Matt explained to me the Klipsch sets the prices and they should be the same everywhere. Also they are 20% off right now as they get ready to introduce a new line in February. The time he spent with me trying different speakers was priceless. Also I sent HTD my plans on Tuesday, and they are closed until Monday. I was able to hear the Klispch (and others) to make a decision, but not the HTD's and unable to speak with them or get some ideas.
GusGus748s's Avatar GusGus748s
08:30 AM Liked: 608
post #466 of 471
Today | Posts: 6,463
Joined: Mar 2009
Quote:
Originally Posted by go pack View Post
Purchased the Klipsch's yesterday after listening to them and Definitive audio products at the local electronics store.(Flanner's) The Klipsch are definitively "brassyer" but I like the clarity of vocals and the dialogue. They sound amazing! I went with 52 center and towers, RS 41 surrounds. ~ $1230 with tax. My only question now - should I have gone with 62's? I'm going to go back to the store to give them a listen.

FYI I was willing to pay a little more for the service at a local store, but found the prices the same as the lowest internet prices (Acoustic Sound Design) The salesman Matt explained to me the Klipsch sets the prices and they should be the same everywhere. Also they are 20% off right now as they get ready to introduce a new line in February. The time he spent with me trying different speakers was priceless. Also I sent HTD my plans on Tuesday, and they are closed until Monday. I was able to hear the Klispch (and others) to make a decision, but not the HTD's and unable to speak with them or get some ideas.
Go with what you like. That's the best thing you can do. Go to the store and listen to them. I've own Klipsch, and to me they were too bright. I've own Polk Audio as well Monitor and RTi / RTiA line and they were too bright as well. The LSi / LSiM line sound great but too expensive for me. I bought the Arx speakers without listening to them, and boy I was happy with the warm and neutral sound of the ribbon tweeters. Martin Logan ribbon tweeters sound similar to the Arx.

If you have a good subwoofer you do not need to get the bigger towers.
wardman1
09:05 AM Liked: 0
post #467 of 471
Today | Posts: 32
Joined: Nov 2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by bgtighe23 View Post
Just ordered HTD level 3 bookshelves and center. Hoping to review soon. It's been a while.
Looking forward to seeing the review! For me it is Level 3 bookshelves in front, level 2 center due to size, 12" sub, and Level 2 or in walls for rear (will the midi's work).

Thx!
bgtighe23
01:37 PM Liked: 5
post #468 of 471
Today | Posts: 149
Joined: Sep 2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by wardman1 View Post
Looking forward to seeing the review! For me it is Level 3 bookshelves in front, level 2 center due to size, 12" sub, and Level 2 or in walls for rear (will the midi's work).

Thx!
I'm looking forward to writing it!

I am a little confused about what you're saying. Are you saying what you already have? or asking for suggestions for rear surrounds?
rfb6435's Avatar rfb6435
01:44 PM Liked: 13
post #469 of 471
Today | Posts: 59
Joined: Oct 2002
Quote:
Originally Posted by wardman1 View Post
Looking forward to seeing the review! For me it is Level 3 bookshelves in front, level 2 center due to size, 12" sub, and Level 2 or in walls for rear (will the midi's work).

Thx!
I wouldn't mix the level 3 bookshelf and the level 2 center. The level 3's have a ribbon tweeter and won't match the level 2 silk dome tweeter...

If you are doing a level 2 center and don't have room for towers then I would suggest using all level 2 center speakers for the L/C/R instead.

Level 2 Centers and Level 3 Bookshelfs

The level 2 centers are $139 each or $278/pair where the level 3 bookshelfs are $319 a pair. IMO the level 2 center is very similar in performance to the level 3 bookshelf... The level 2 center has just slightly less range with 52Hz/20kHz vs. 47Hz/40kHz, the level 2 center is more sensitive and has the same power handling of 120W. The dual 5.25" drivers actually offer more cone area @ ~44in^2 (~22in^2*2) vs ~33in^2 for the single 6.5" driver and I usually set the crossover at 80Hz for everything except the towers so the lowest frequencies aren't an issue anyway.

I run the level 2 centers for L/R in my living room, with them oriented vertically and the tweeters on the inside (which means that one is upside down relative to the other but you can only see that on the rear with the binding posts being low on one and high on the other). The 5.25 drivers will the push the high frequencies from the tweeter slightly inward and work very well for left/right speakers. They offer grilles with no logo to accommodate this.

The Level 2 centers and Level 3 bookshelfs are also pretty similar in size where the level 2 centers are taller but overall smaller.

Level 2 Center vs. Level 3 Bookshelf


I have a pair of older style level 3 bookshelf's (6.5" drivers and 1" silk dome tweeter) in the workout area and I like the level 2 centers better.

If you really like the ribbon tweeter then go with the level 3's but then you really need all 3 fronts to be level 3's to sound right (timbre match) unless you aren't picky... I got locked into the dome tweeters due to my older Level 3 setup that predated the change to ribbon tweeters.

I haven't played with the ribbon tweeters but I think I have one or more of basically everything they have produced with the current level 2 style 1" silk dome tweeter.

Middy Speakers

Middy speakers sound quite good but I have only had them for a week. I wouldn't say that the Middy speakers are "as good" as the level 2 bookshelf speakers but they are very good for their compact size. The flat panel speakers are actually better than the level 2 bookshelf speakers IMO though as they are basically a Middy plus 2 extra 4 inch drivers (this is my living room center channel speaker which pairs with the level 2 centers for L/R).

Physically the Middys appear to be basically a mini level 2 center speaker that uses 2.5" drivers instead of 5.25" drivers. Unlike the level 2 center vs. level 3 main, the driver area of the Middy is much less at ~8in^2 (~4in^2*2) vs ~22in^2. This is the tradeoff for being small.

Middy vs. Level 2 bookshelf vs Flat panel.




Knowing how good the Middys sound I wouldn't hesitate to use them as surround speakers (especially rear surrounds which are the least critical surround speaker). I have them as heights which require even less low frequency handing than surrounds. I might very well get middy speakers mounted vertically for surrounds instead of the level 2 bookshelfs if I were to do it again but either way they both work great. The Level 2 bookshelfs do allow me to set the crossover at 80Hz where the Middys would be 100 or 120Hz.

-Rich
wardman1
08:29 PM Liked: 0
post #470 of 471
Today | Posts: 32
Joined: Nov 2014
Quote:
Originally Posted by bgtighe23 View Post
I'm looking forward to writing it!

I am a little confused about what you're saying. Are you saying what you already have? or asking for suggestions for rear surrounds?

My room is large, so leaning towards the Level 3 R/L, but no space for the L3 Center. The L2 Center will fit. And the in walls look good too and probably would save me some grief from my wife over the L2 Surrounds that will be on the rear wall as my only choice.


No purchase yet, I am watching for a sale.
careyc1
08:30 PM Liked: 0
post #471 of 471
Today | Posts: 6
Joined: Jul 2014
Has anyone purchased the Versay HTS1's yet? (http://www.htd.com/Products/Versa-Ca...rs/VERSA-HTS1#) I heard about them in another thread but it doesn't look like there's a whole lot of information or reviews on them yet. I'm not familiar with the brand but owners of the level 2 and level 3's seem to like them.
Tags: Denon Avr 789 630 Watt 7 1 Channel Home Theater Receiver

Reply Speakers

Subscribe to this Thread

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3