AVS Addicted Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Colorado Springs, CO
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 266 Post(s)
Driver damage from clipping is often carelessly explained. Bob's explanation and Rodd Eliott's explanation at sound.westhost.com agree perfectly.
But he's not saying that amplifiers rated for more power than a speaker's continuous rating are inherently bad. What he's saying is that power, in general, kills drivers, usually due to thermal overload.
Tweeters, in particular can't handle a lot of power. See Rod Elliott's explanation of why tweeters blow. But let's say you are pushing 80 watts of non clipped power into a speaker rated at 50 watts continuous. Based on what I have read, this may be dangerous than clipping, for exactly the reason Bob explains.
There are two causes of speaker damage
* Thermal overload ( By all accounts, something that can happen with clipping)
* Mechanical overload ( I can exceed the woofer excursion limits on my small ACI Sapphires, and only a deaf person would not hear that)
You don't want to exceed either limit no matter how weak or powerful your receiver/amp is.
The bottom line is to not operate your speakers when you can hear any obvious distress. Besides, if you run your speakers at too high of a volume they will sound bad. Turn it up until the sound quality drops, then back down a bit. This should work whether your amp has too little power, or too much power.
"But this one goes up to 11"