Tube Amp Watts vs Solid State Watts... Is this a red flag? - AVS Forum

AVS Forum > Audio > Receivers, Amps, and Processors > Tube Amp Watts vs Solid State Watts... Is this a red flag?

Receivers, Amps, and Processors

Newbie01's Avatar Newbie01
04:36 PM Liked: 30
post #1 of 11
02-24-2013 | Posts: 834
Joined: Jul 2001
So I was looking on a speaker website and I saw this in the specifications...

I "thought" an amp is an amp is an amp...I know the legendary debate of tube vs. solid state...I will stay out of that for sound..

But does this make sense? I know I have allot to learn but this is the first time I have come across this.



Recommended Amplification

40 – 100 tube watts
80 – 250 solid state watts
M Code's Avatar M Code
05:12 PM Liked: 131
post #2 of 11
02-24-2013 | Posts: 9,954
Joined: Mar 2003
Tube amplifiers were in that power range 40-100W..
Basic issue with tube amplifiers is their higher THD...
A quality solid state amplifer Class A-B has very low THD until it is pushed to its design limits..

Just my $0.02.. wink.gif
skriefal's Avatar skriefal
07:14 PM Liked: 38
post #3 of 11
02-24-2013 | Posts: 949
Joined: Jan 2000
Tube amps distort more "pleasantly" than solid state amps, so they can often be over-driven with less obvious negative results. If you want maximum accuracy and minimum distortion, then the 80-250 range is what you should aim for... even with a tube amp.
Class A's Avatar Class A
07:19 PM Liked: 51
post #4 of 11
02-24-2013 | Posts: 1,352
Joined: Jun 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by Newbie01 View Post

So I was looking on a speaker website and I saw this in the specifications...

I "thought" an amp is an amp is an amp...I know the legendary debate of tube vs. solid state...I will stay out of that for sound..

But does this make sense? I know I have allot to learn but this is the first time I have come across this.



Recommended Amplification

40 – 100 tube watts
80 – 250 solid state watts
Really the watts are not a true indication say 40watts =60db's 80 watts will give you 63db. not much of a difference.The clipping you get in tubes are even order harmonics which round off the sound. So even though it is clipping you get a more listenable sound which is perceived as louder. With solid state units the clipping will sound harsh. Of course it also depends on the type of speakers you hook the amps up to. I've heard Avantgard floor standers w/a 6wpc tube amp play very loud. Of course the efficiency rating on the speakers was a 106db. Does it mean that a 6wpc tube amp is as powerful as a 200wpc Bryston? No, But if you added a pair of 83db Platnium Audio speakers. Both amps would be perceived as just as powerful, There's more to it than just watts. There are some other people on this forum that have more expertise than me and can give a more in depth explanation.smile.gif
JHAz's Avatar JHAz
09:19 PM Liked: 164
post #5 of 11
02-24-2013 | Posts: 4,025
Joined: Mar 2009
while distortion may contribute to a sense of loudness, the more likely reason folks sometimes say tube watts are louder than ss watts it that tube amps also compressquite nicely, which will certainly make everything sound louder.

And of course if you have speakers (or a room big enough to let you sit so far away that) 40 watts is 60 dB you need a do-over. smile.gif but of course the basic maxim that doubling power yields a three dB increase holds true even with more typical speakers that are above 80 dB with one watt.
DonH50's Avatar DonH50
01:49 PM Liked: 291
post #6 of 11
02-25-2013 | Posts: 6,276
Joined: Feb 2010
I have seen this before and have three thoughts, mostly echong what has already been said:

1. Most SS amps clip quickly past their power limit while tube amps tend to compress much more gradually. If the speakers are sensitive to clipping (which tends to send more HF energy to the speaker) then it makes sense to provide more headroom in the SS design.

2. Tube amplifiers tend to have more single-ended distortion characteristics, emphasizing the second harmonic, then 3rd and higher. SS amps tend to emphasize odd harmonics and thus sound harsher when over driven. So, while a tube amp may in fact have much higher distortion, it might not sound as bad to us. Distortion is still adding signal that is not supposed to be there, of course.

3. High-power tube amps are harder to find and much more expensive than SS amps. That is not to say there are not high-priced SS amps, but for $1k you can get a lot of SS power compared to a tube amp at the same price point (be prepared for a litany of exceptions). Given the added headroom and distortion characteristics, it makes (marketing) sense to suggest higher-power SS amps.

All IMO - Don
Tim Sorrentino's Avatar Tim Sorrentino
11:10 AM Liked: 10
post #7 of 11
02-28-2013 | Posts: 14
Joined: Dec 2008
Also how an amp comes Out of clipping determines how "distorted" an amp may sound. From what I have heard some solid state amps "stick" and stay at clipping, before they come back to the "undistorted" state. Simply put many tube amplifiers clip much more gracefully and with a more benign distortion signature than many SS units. So therefore a lower wattage tube amp may sound as "loud" without distortion than a doubly powered SS unit.

All this aside, the "distortions" all amplifiers make is NOTHING compared to the distortion that most loudspeakers produce that our ear takes for granted. Any distortions produced by amplifiers is swamped by any SPEAKER "distortions" . Have you ever seen "distortion ratings" of speakers? Depending on the frequency it can be on the order of 20 percent to a low percent..

Whoa did he just say 20 percent? Indeed it is true!

Anyway I would really not pay much attention to any amp distortion ratings unless it is really, really high.

Tim
whoaru99's Avatar whoaru99
11:41 AM Liked: 67
post #8 of 11
02-28-2013 | Posts: 6,960
Joined: Dec 2004
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tim Sorrentino View Post

So therefore a lower wattage tube amp may sound as "loud" without distortion than a doubly powered SS unit.

Just to clarify, you mean may sound as loud without an unpleasant a type of distortion, rather than "without" distortion because the distortion is there, in spades, even if it's not like driving an ice pick into your ear.

I have a ~30W tube amp and I think it sounds pretty good, but by the same token I don't proclaim it as equivalent to 60W of ss power because the distortion at that output might be somewhat more tolerable.
EmotivaKeith's Avatar EmotivaKeith
02:30 PM Liked: 14
post #9 of 11
02-28-2013 | Posts: 20
Joined: Feb 2013
That's true, but the distortion characteristic of tube amps is usually more or less "monotonic".

That means that the distortion increases gradually as the level increases (while sold state amps play very cleanly, then distort once they reach a certain point).

Since our ears perceive small amounts of distortion as "loudness", this means that, as the tube amp gets louder (really),
we hear both the real increase in loudness AND the increase in distortion BOTH as increases in loudness.
So, we hear the increase in loudness when that tube amp goes from one watt to four watts (with increasing distortion) as being larger
than the increase between one watt and four watts with a solid state amp (with no increasing distortion).
The result is that the tube amp may seem both "more powerful" and "more dynamic"
(if you think about it, that gradually increasing distortion acts like a sort of virtual dynamic range expander).

Of course, the price factor comes into play; since you can often get a much more powerful solid state amp for the same price as a less powerful tube amp.

Quote:
Originally Posted by whoaru99 View Post

Just to clarify, you mean may sound as loud without an unpleasant a type of distortion, rather than "without" distortion because the distortion is there, in spades, even if it's not like driving an ice pick into your ear.

I have a ~30W tube amp and I think it sounds pretty good, but by the same token I don't proclaim it as equivalent to 60W of ss power because the distortion at that output might be somewhat more tolerable.

Tim Sorrentino's Avatar Tim Sorrentino
11:00 AM Liked: 10
post #10 of 11
04-04-2013 | Posts: 14
Joined: Dec 2008
Quote:
Originally Posted by whoaru99 View Post

Just to clarify, you mean may sound as loud without an unpleasant a type of distortion, rather than "without" distortion because the distortion is there, in spades, even if it's not like driving an ice pick into your ear.

I have a ~30W tube amp and I think it sounds pretty good, but by the same token I don't proclaim it as equivalent to 60W of ss power because the distortion at that output might be somewhat more tolerable.

All of the "good" tube amps that I have heard in no way sound remotely distorted. Even ones that are rated at "less than 1%" Here are the specs of a very famous tube amp that has been in production since about 1960 (well this is the modern reincarnation):

"Output power: 75Wpc (18.8dBW) into 4, 8, or 16 ohms (stereo), 150W into (21.8dBW) 2, 4, or 8 ohms (mono). Frequency response: 20Hz–20kHz, +0/–0.5dB; 10Hz–70kHz, +0/–3dB. Signal/noise ratio: 100dB, A-weighted (no reference level given). THD: 0.05% at any power level from 250mW to rated power output. "

Distortion "in spades" I think not. And remember that doubling your amplifier power is a mere 3db increase in sound volume, all things being equal. Also from what I heard if an amp designer wants a better distortion spec at the expense of the Sound of the amp all they need to do is crank up some more negative feedback ....
whoaru99's Avatar whoaru99
06:17 PM Liked: 67
post #11 of 11
04-04-2013 | Posts: 6,960
Joined: Dec 2004
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tim Sorrentino View Post

All of the "good" tube amps that I have heard in no way sound remotely distorted. Even ones that are rated at "less than 1%" Here are the specs of a very famous tube amp that has been in production since about 1960 (well this is the modern reincarnation):

"Output power: 75Wpc (18.8dBW) into 4, 8, or 16 ohms (stereo), 150W into (21.8dBW) 2, 4, or 8 ohms (mono). Frequency response: 20Hz–20kHz, +0/–0.5dB; 10Hz–70kHz, +0/–3dB. Signal/noise ratio: 100dB, A-weighted (no reference level given). THD: 0.05% at any power level from 250mW to rated power output. "

Distortion "in spades" I think not. And remember that doubling your amplifier power is a mere 3db increase in sound volume, all things being equal. Also from what I heard if an amp designer wants a better distortion spec at the expense of the Sound of the amp all they need to do is crank up some more negative feedback ....

Yeah, I've heard pretty much all the arguments and they all pretty much boil down to the only reason tube amp watts can be considered "more powerful" than SS watts is because you can drive them to higher levels of distortion before it becomes unpleasant. So, in fact, you are putting out more watts and it's no longer apples to apples..

Not dissing tube amps, as I said I have one and think it sounds just fine, just the "tube watts are more powerful" is bunk, apples to apples.
Reply Receivers, Amps, and Processors

Subscribe to this Thread

Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3