The kids want an additional fish tank for Xmas, to accommodate that i have to move some/all of my equipment into some closed shelves below their current location. Obviously i don't want to leave the cabinet door open all the time and need a solution such that our numerous factory remotes work. Here's what i've got
Brand spanking new Direct TV DVR
Blu-Ray player that came with TV in a bundle package
Apple TV (Doesn't HAVE to move)
Comcast Modem (Won't move signal is terrible as is)
So from some brief research it seems something like Next Generation Remote Control Extender might work, with me just getting extra batteries for the various remotes.
Is their a "best" solution, that isn't expensive? Are their some reasons i shouldn't get one? Any advice is appreciated!
A universal RF remote to replace all your factory remotes would be cheaper than 5 Next Gen batteries. Even a cheap universal with one Next Gen battery would be better than 5. I like the $13 RCA RCRP05B plus one Next Gen or the URC RFS200 and no Next Gens. Harmony Smart/Ultimate/Touch with hub would be other good, but more expensive options.
One simple repeater like a Power-Mid would also be a good cheap option. You could continue using all your original remotes in that case and not need any transmitter batteries like you do with Next Gen. The only drawback is it still requires aiming at the receiver, whereas Next Gen doesn't.
In any case, with 5 devices, a universal would make life much easier.
I guess i'm hesitant to get a universal remote. 90% of the time i just use the DirectTV remote to control whatever it is that we are watching/listening to. 90% of the time the rest of the remotes are in a drawer. For one thing my wife finds one remote per item less confusing. I use my iphone for the Denon/apple TV/Direct TV(some functions). What i dislike about the Iphone is the lag between pressing a control button and the denon responding. But when listening to music outside it's great (minus the lag).
It seems like the monoprice wired repeater would solve my issue, for the least $, and the least "change".....
Realize that you can get an RF DirecTV remote, assuming you don't have one already. Use a repeater for everything else. The RCA works exactly like your DirecTV remote only better. It's made by the same company and even uses the same codes. But it adds learning, macros and control of all your other devices. At $13 it's a no-brainer, IMO.
I believe during "remote setup" i had to choose between RF or IR for my new DirectTV remote. I guess tonight i can see what the setting is, maybe change it. Then i could lay a blanket over the DVR and see if it still works, correct?
Now if i have the RF remote, isn't it also sending out in IR? Reason i ask is because i have it set to control the Dennon volume. So it must be sending an IR signal to the receiver. Perhaps i will loose this functionality if i switch it to RF.