AVS Forum banner

Building a Dinner Theater w/ DIY Speakers, Subs, etc...

52K views 585 replies 76 participants last post by  dutchswan0311 
#1 ·
Build Thread Updated 05/09/13


This post is being updated to include a table of contents. Thank you for your patience while this update is being completed.


Wijk Winery is a family owned venture of which I am a part. We presently produce wine in Pleasant Hill, IA, which can be purchased at dozens of locations across Central Iowa; including grocery stores, art galleries, and even farmer's markets. We are moving our winery to a new location in Sully, Iowa after we finish remodeling an old church we acquired from the city. The building has been completely gutted; plaster, flooring, electrical, plumbing...everything. The only thing original to the building is its foundation and external frame. The old wood siding has been replaced with stone, we doubled the height of the tower; and we intent to erect two more towers in the back.


In this new winery location, we will have a space for weddings, receptions, events, as well as a licensed dinner theater. My original plan called for some pretty expensive in-wall speakers & subs, but after joining this forum I received 100% feedback that these would not be sufficient for our application. Further research and refinement of my plan has led me to building all of the speakers and subs for our dinner theater, as well as the sound for our live music stage adjacent to the dinner theater. I have included many pictures in this build threat to walk you through the evolution of the cinema sound in our Winery's Dinner Theater.


P.S. I am not sure if anyone is interested, but if you click here you can view the construction album for the overall winery on facebook. The album is open to the public (you don't have to "like" us to view it). If you are not so inclined, below is an image of the entrance to our dinner theater.


July 4, 2010: We tour a vacant former church for the first time. It is owned by the city and there is a proposal to demolish the 1929 building and sell the two lots on which it rests for residential housing. The structure is excellent, and is on a poured foundation. Our proposal is made for us to purchase the old church and turn it into our winery; thereby creating jobs, bringing business to the town (not to mention giving the citizens of Sully something to do). In December 2010, we purchase the property for $1.



F20 Subwoofer Build

General F20 Discussion (Placement, Crossover, Etc)
Subwoofer Highpass/Lowpass Discussion
F20 Wattage Recommendation
Subwoofer Placement Discussion
4pi LCR & 1pi Surround Build
4pi Highpass Discussion

1pi Discussion
Picking Out Amplifiers
Picking Out an AVR

Picking Out Projector

Baffle Wall Design
Picking Out an AT Screen

A/V over Cat6/HDBaseT

 
See less See more
1
#2 ·

F20 SUBWOOFER (x4 FOR LFE)


I will update our progress (with pictures) on the F20 subs below. We ended up purchasing the Dayton 390HF driver for this cabinet, which is what will be used in all four subs.


 




I had Lowes cut the wood to size on site. While most of it was cut precisely, a few panels were cut to 18 7/16 instead of 18 1/2. The width is the more important than the length, so I had to purchase more wood to get all of my panels at exactly 18 1/2. I needed to purchase an extra 4' x 8' sheet anyway for panel 6 of subs 2, 3, and 4; but my lesson is learned. If you want it done right, do it yourself (or purchase a flat pack when they become available).

 



For the first F20 sub, I found the access panel very easy to cut perfectly with a circular saw and then finish off the corners with a jig saw. The left over panel is perfect for using as the access panel itself. I decided to put the access panel on panel 1 (left side) this time because it was just easier to make the marks for it off the other marks.

 



The instructions called for the drilling of 18 holes, 1" from the ends of 9 panels. I imagine the rest would be drilled drawing lines between these holes. I like symmetry, so I just went ahead and drilled all of the holes where my screws will go. I tested this on a scrap piece of wood using the a 1/16" drill bit and it made for a good guide, but also a tight fit. Instead of drilling holes every 8", I divided the space between holes in halves until I had the first spacing that was under 8". This means some panels will have screws 7" apart, and others will have them as little as 4.5" apart. 6" was the average. In total, I drilled 61 holes, which means 122 screws will hold the overall enclosure together.

 



The 14" diameter hole was easy enough to measure and cut. I am now I am ready to drop the driver in and mark my screw holes for it.

 



 

Lowes did not carry some of the materials needed in the specified dimensions, so I attempted to substitute similar items in their place and then seek feedback here as to the appropriateness of their use. The following are the substituted items:


Instructions: 10-32 x 1-1/4" socket head cap screws

Substituted: 10-24 x 1-1/2" socket head cap screws


Instructions: 10-32 Hurricane Nuts

Substituted: 10-24 x 7/16 Pronged T-Nuts


I see now that the 10-24 nuts and screws are actually larger than the 10-32 (which of course makes sense, but when you are just skimming the instructions, the number 24 is smaller than 32 so you associate 10-24 as being smaller without thinking about it). This has caused the T-Nuts to protrude on the edge of the cut-out. I will search harder for the 10-32 nuts/bolts on the next three F20 builds. Since the driver came in yesterday (07/06/11), I am now able to finish the first F20 build.

 

 



 

I am very pleased how everything ended up screwing together. Everything seems very tight, and the dimensions are exactly what the instructions call for. There is one exception to this, but I am not certain how big of an issue it will be, but might need some advice on how to correct it (I don't want to just start prying on things...I would rather learn from other's mistakes if I can).


I made the mistake of tring to put a 1 5/8" drywall screw into the long end of Panel 3. This is where the baffle cut-out is the shallowest. The screw protruded into the cutout area, and it separated the middle two layers of ply by 1/8". I quickly put PL in the separation, backed the screw out, and then put a cap screw/washer in to hold it together tightly while the PL dries. An easy fix, but beware of this if you are building this cabinet.

 

 



 

Instead of cutting four pieces of ply at 1 1/2" wide, I thought it would be more effective and create fewer seams to just make it one piece. I then glued and screwed it on from the inside using 1 1/4" coarse drywall screws. I really like the results of this, as it is much more solid than it would have been as four pieces.

 



[Update on 03/16/12]


The second F20 is finished. I don't know if it was necessary, but I went ahead and added the bracing that was later added to the plans. I figured it couldn't hurt anything. I used 3/4" x 3.5" oak planks (seen below).

 



 

I repeated the above process for the other three F20s as well, except that I used 5x5 sheets of Baltic Birch for the other three.  I have to say, the Baltic Birch F20s each weight substantially more than the first one that was made from oak.


Here is a view of the installed F20s under the baffle wall.

 

 
#3 ·
4PI SPEAKERS (x3 FOR LCR DUTY)


There was a small learning curve as I began my speaker construction project. I feel I did very well making the first F20 (which was my first attempt at any speaker construction). The same did not go for the first of the Pi speakers. My first 4pi was constructed of arauco, and was immediately after I finished my first F20. Not yet realizing that I did not need to use screws, this first 4pi was screwed together, including the cross bracing. The result was less than pleasing to the eye. I am certain it would have functioned just fine; but being the perfectionist that I am, I discarded it and started over with a new "first" 4pi.


My new first 4pi was then constructed of 5' x 5' Baltic Birch. I used screws on this one as well, but it turned out very well and was pleased with the results. It was after I posted pictures of it on the audioroundtable.com forum that Parham informed me that screws were not needed for enclosures of this size and smaller. Not quite crazy enough to need that level of symmetry, I decided to use the "screwed" 4pi as the center channel (OCD much?).


From there, I finally went out and purchased clamps in order to glue the remaining 14 cabinets, and this is where the pictures below pick up.




The two 4pi cabinets below were constructed using just a circular saw, a drill, a jig saw, and a palm sander. At the recommendation of some more experienced cabinet makers, I moved from "PL Premium" (which I will still use on the remaining F20 enclosures) to using "TiteBond III" and "TiteBond Ultimate" on the Pi speakers. I find that you must work much more quickly when using TiteBond, but it also dries faster and is MUCH easier to clean up (PARTICULARLY off your on skin). The only down side to the TiteBond when compared to PL Premium is that it is not as good at filling voids if your wood does not meet up perfectly, but I suppose that is what wood filler is for.




Presenting my first 4pi held together entirely by glue. Not bad considering only hand tools were used with nothing to guide me but hopes and dreams. (Yup...at this point I still didn't know you could purchase saw guides for circular saws.) I will post a couple pictures of the screwed 4pi when I get a chance.




While the front of the third 4pi enclosure had been made for some time, I was able to cut the remaining panels and box for the port using our new table saw (see watershed below).







1PI SPEAKERS (x12 FOR SURROUND SOUND)


Though I am technically (as of 03/01/12) still sanding the third 4pi, I moved on to build four 1pi speakers using the same methods as I had employed on the 4pi enclosures. These four all turned out well, but I was sometimes making cut errors on my costly Baltic birch and had to sadly throw away some panels. One would think it would be easier to build a small speaker than a large speaker. But the narrow cuts and smaller panels are actually more difficult to achieve with precision using a circular saw (and not a very good one at that).


The two images below represented the first of the 1pi enclosures.




I used 60 grit sandpaper to take care of the low hanging fruit, and then moved to 150 grit to bring it to a nice finish.




The image below shows the stage of my project prior to purchasing a table saw; something I definitely recommend to anyone building a home theater.



A TABLE SAW IS FINALLY PURCHASED


"21" does not sound like a large number until you apply it to speaker building. Faced with task of building 14 more enclosures, and considering the amount of time it took me to build just 7 before. I talked the other winery partners into forking out the money for a table saw. We will use it later to build other things for the winery, such as decorative single wine boxes, among other things. In the mean time, it has made a huge difference in efficiency (not to mention precision and quality).




I go all "Henry Ford" on my project; a much more efficient process than building each speaker from cutting to painting before moving onto the next one.




I decided to build the enclosures without the fronts first, then go back and build all of the fronts, then go back and glue all of the fronts on, and then go back and do all of the sanding, followed by a massive painting party. Speaking of painting; I have been using Concrete Epoxy tinted black to paint all of my enclosures. It applies well in one coat, but I have been doing two coats for good measure. I wonder if it does anything to "seal" them up better as well. I suppose it could in theory.




Eight 1pi speakers are finished and only 4 remain. The final 4 are built and are in the final stages of sanding.

 
#6 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by rlj5242 /forum/post/20603132


I'm glad you at least dropped the idea of using Def Tech speakers like you proposed over at HTF. I still think you need horn subs.

The F-20's are front loaded horns



This area done right will be a spectacular place to enjoy music too btw. what a great idea
 
#7 ·
Elemental Designs in Newton, IA already has the F-20 programmed into their CNC since they are doing the F-20's for MKTheater. If you want more subs, it might be easier have them cut them since they are only 15 minutes away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NBPk402
#10 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by desertdome /forum/post/20603294


Elemental Designs in Newton, IA already has the F-20 programmed into their CNC since they are doing the F-20's for MKTheater. If you want more subs, it might be easier have them cut them since they are only 15 minutes away.

Awesome idea! (How did you even know that?) Newton is very close to the winery...but a little further from where I live in Clive.


On the first one, Lowes actually performed the 14 cuts @ $0.25 per cut lol. When I measured the panels at home, they actually did a pretty good job. A couple of panels are 1/32 - 1/16 long, but I think that should be within the tolerance range...don't you think? I will have to do the beveling myself, which I suppose the CNC would do as well. There is something to be said about precision.
 
#13 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by dutchswan0311 /forum/post/20604038


I meant how did you know that a place in Newton is making F20s for another theater?

Everyone knows what's going on in MKTheater's current project!
 
#14 ·
Small world, a good friend of mine is from Newton, IA. I did not know that ED was from IA.


I am currently building a set of three 4 Pi speakers (only have the drivers and x-overs to complete two, the third will go into long-term storage until I return from overseas). I considered JBL 3677s and Deluxe Econowaves for the L/C/R speakers. But in the end, the Pi design seemed to offer what I needed and with them available in a kit I could build my own enclosures.


For surround I am also leaning towards the JBL 8320s, for the price they seem hard to beat for surround duty. Picked up the idea of the 8320's from MKtheater's build thread ( http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1225270 ).


I bet no matter which way you go it will sound great since you seem willing to put the effort into optimizing the overall "system." Killer idea!
 
#16 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by NWCgrad /forum/post/20604092


Small world, a good friend of mine is from Newton, IA. I did not know that ED was from IA.

What are the odds that I would settle on the F20, and that our winery would be a mere 10-15 minutes away from ED where another set is being built. I guess it was meant to be :)


I am currently building a set of three 4 Pi speakers (only have the drivers and x-overs to complete two, the third will go into long-term storage until I return from overseas).

Are you finding these to be an easy build?


For surround I am also leaning towards the JBL 8320s, for the price they seem hard to beat for surround duty.

Yea, for $450/pair it seems like a bargain since I need at least 8 of them.

.
 
#17 ·
Can anyone provide guidance on sub placement in the floorplans above? I understand that using a meter would be ideal, but I cannot have these monsters just sitting anywhere. They need to be out of sight as much as possible. I have to keep telling myself, we are putting a theater in a winery; not a winery into a theater. :)
 
#18 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by NWCgrad /forum/post/20604092


For surround I am also leaning towards the JBL 8320s, for the price they seem hard to beat for surround duty. Picked up the idea of the 8320's from MKtheater's build thread ( http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1225270 ).

For the price they would be hard to beat...if they actually sounded good. After hearing them in a theater, I found it iffy to buy them when Eric was selling them at blow-out prices. Way too much energy in the 2-6k area and quite the rolloff above 10-12khz.
 
#19 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by dutchswan0311 /forum/post/20604101


After googling it, I realize that MKTheater is actually a person, not a theater. He must live in my area if a company in Newton is doing the CNC work?

He lives in New Hartford, NY and he is having them build the F-20 completely . Besides their own speakers and subs, Elemental Designs does custom work for people all over the world. I know of many that have had flatpacks made for DIY speakers. Here is a DIY speaker that they shipped to Australia.
 
#20 ·
Ooooooooooh BEVELING. After having only skimmed the instructions, I thought it was calling for the side panel to have grooves cut into for the various 18.5" panels to be put into. Now that I finally have the .skp file open, I see what everyone was talking about. You should see some of the coffered ceilings and bars I have built. This sub is going to be a piece of cake (famous last words...I know).

Update: After having looked more closely at MKTheater's build, it appears like the side panels have been cut into, probably with a lathe or grinder. Perhaps I should just shut up until I have read all of the instructions carefully.
 
#21 ·
The 4 Pi's are easy to build. I increased the complexity by adding oak internal framing to the MDF box for additional rigidity due to my frequent miltary moves.


Wayne Parham, the designer, provides free plans all you have to do is ask ( http://audioroundtable.com/forum/ind...ead&frm_id=33& ). The plans include schematics for the crossovers, but I chose to buy completed crossovers from him as they were only slightly higher cost than ordering the parts.


Wayne is a great guy and provides a lot of valuable design advice to the DIY community. For the price (basically the cost of the components), his speakers are hard to beat. I figure if by small chance I hate the speakers I can sell the JBL woofers and B&C compression drivers and recoup most of my invetment (except enclosure cost).
 
#22 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by desertdome /forum/post/20604228


He lives in New Hartford, NY and he is having them build the F-20 completely . Besides their own speakers and subs, Elemental Designs does custom work for people all over the world. I know of many that have had flatpacks made for DIY speakers. Here is a DIY speaker that they shipped to Australia.

That is amazingly ironic.
 
#23 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by dutchswan0311 /forum/post/0


Ooooooooooh BEVELING. After having only skimmed the instructions, I thought it was calling for the side panel to have grooves cut into for the various 18.5" panels to be put into. Now that I finally have the .skp file open, I see what everyone was talking about. You should see some of the coffered ceilings and bars I have built. This sub is going to be a piece of cake (famous last words...I know).


Update: After having looked more closely at MKTheater's build, it appears like the side panels have been cut into, probably with a lathe or grinder. Perhaps I should just shut up until I have read all of the instructions carefully.

Though MK chose to have it done that way, there is really no need to rabbet or groove the sides like that. The instructions do not call for it. If you do that - remember to account for the width of the interior panels that gets "lost" in the rabbets. I have built subs both ways. Rabbeting certainly makes things easier to build once the grooves are cut, and may make things slightly stronger, but cutting the rabbets perfectly for several cabinets really requires a template and some strong router kung-fu, or a CNC router. Since I don't have a CNC router, I had to lean on the template and router kung-fu, which worked out OK in the end, but it certainly was not easy or fast.


Honestly, the F-20 is not a hard horn sub to build. I tried to make this one as simple as I could. Read the directions - it should all be in there. There is more detail on the access panel in my design thread.


Accuracy is critical. Just keep the layout accurate, make your cuts accurately, and use enough (but not too much) PL and screws, things will turn out fine.


Good luck with your builds.
 
#24 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by lilmike /forum/post/20604784


Though MK chose to have it done that way, there is really no need to rabbet or groove the sides like that. The instructions do not call for it.

I have thoroughly read the instructions now and am happy to learn that the grooves are not needed. I lack the proper tools to allow for that kind of woodwork at this time.


Honestly, the F-20 is not a hard horn sub to build. I tried to make this one as simple as I could. Read the directions - it should all be in there. There is more detail on the access panel in my design thread.

As I was thinking about access panel design, I thought I would make that inner flange out of a single piece of wood, instead of 4 pieces of scrap. This would allow for a tighter fit, will be less likely to leak, and isn't really that difficult to cut out.


Accuracy is critical. Just keep the layout accurate, make your cuts accurately, and use enough (but not too much) PL and screws, things will turn out fine.

I am a perfectionist by nature. Given instructions, materials, and the needed tools I think I could build a nuclear reactor. I may not know or realize that is what I am building, but you get the point. The first one is always the hardest. Having finished the layout and carefully read the instructions, I am confident that building four F20s will not be difficult at all. You did a superb job on the instructions and diagrams.

I specifically purchased two 4" C Clamps because they were listed under the "minimum tools" section of the instructions. I am a little confused what these are for. It seems to me that the only size clamp that would do any good would be one that is 20+ inches. Thoughts?
 
#26 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by lilmike /forum/post/20606460


I used the 4" clamps to hold the boards together when drilling the second side, as well as to hold the panels in place during assembly with a squaring jig. I use the 3d Squares , but a shop-made clamping square would also work fine.

Understood...that makes sense. I saw pictures of others clamping the 18 1/2" sides down after putting the PL & screws on. My thoughts told me that just the act of screwing the panels on would make for a very tight fit. I was not certain how much tighter the clamps would make the fit on top of the screws.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top