Posts by Robert George

Quote: Originally Posted by MovieSwede 1. Because the HDTV screencap show more detail in certain scenes 2. Because the trailers that is included in the same disc show more detail then the BD. 3. And because the DNR does not preseve...

Quote: Originally Posted by emgesp 8 yr old cleaned up masters. What a freaking joke. What about new 4k/6k remasters? 4k/6K remasters of material that is often less than 2K at the source. Yeah, that would fix it. Quote: Peter...

The uncut version with proper English subtitles does exist in HD. I have seen a 720p rip of an HDTV source, but I don't know where this was originally shown. Finding it might be a trick. Good luck with that.

Quote: Originally Posted by sharkcohen 52" 1080p LCD calibrated by Jeff Meier, 6 foot viewing distance, FOTR looks fantastic. Translated; "Smack-smack-smack..." Mmmmm, tasty. Who knew those little black birdies tasted so good.

I recall this was released in in the UK a while back. It may now be out of print.

Quote: Originally Posted by Xylon BTW are you planning on purchasing the blu-ray? If you do are you willing to prove us wrong? Assuming that you know how to spot PQ issues (no offense intended). Yes, I'm going to get these discs when...

Quote: Originally Posted by Kram Sacul He's lecturing us all on credibilty while he's basing his opinion on re-encoded bootleg BD rips and crude fan edits. Classic. I am comparing similar sources, and I disclose up front what my...

RE: HDTV vs. Blu-ray (Disclaimer: my visual source is MKV rips of both versions...) I don't know how many different HDTV rips are out there or which one, or ones, are being referred to in this thread. What I have seen are 1080p rips...

Quote: Guess what? I have seen the Blu-rays (my review copy is right here), I have seen the HDTV cap (legitimately done for personal backup, perfectly legal in my country), and I call BS on your post. Thank god in my country reviewers...

Quote: Originally Posted by eric.exe Cool story bro. The Blu-ray clearly lacks details in some shots that the HDTV broadcast had. And "mkv rips" are often sharpened, which usually impresses novices. You would actually put more...