Thanks a bunch for the help. My dvd player was already on 4:3 letterbox so I switched it to 4:3 pan & scan and that seems to have fixed it, which is weird since Buffy is only available in 4:3 to begin with. We'll see if it needs to be switched back and forth with other dvd's but for now it's good. Thanks again.
10/17/13 at 11:45pm