Well Sam, your posts were wiped out, but I was working on a reply when the database went down. Here it is...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sam S 
So that means the colors on every DVD upscaled by the Oppo (assuming the were properly authored as Rec.601) are going to be wrong?
Absolutely not!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sam S 
...My old set has proper Rec.709 decoding on the 1080i component inputs, and Rec.609 on the 480p component inputs. You always know what you're getting, and where to send it for the desired results. The way I'm understanding it, going with any upscaling DVD player, my SD-DVDs are now all going to be "wrong" as detailed in the image chart above (lower left quadrant).

No. All TV's
must use the Rec.609 colorspace for SD resolutions (480i/480p), and switch to the Rec.709 colorspace for HD resolutions (720p and higher). The TV eventually converts that colorspace to RGB for the display panel.
The color-bar charts demonstrate that you have to MATCH the colorspace of the source
device, to the colorspace of the TV. So, if a player outputs 480p, it must send 601 (no conversion from DVD required) and the result can be seen in the top left bars. If the player outputs 720p, it must send 709 (conversion from DVD 601 required), and the result can be seen in the top right bars (color decoding still correct). If the player fails to convert to 709, the resulting mismatch can be seen in the bottom left bars.
If the TV incorrectly uses 601 for HD resolutions, the resulting mismatch can be seen in the bottom right bars.
OPPO players do the conversion correctly.
Gary