AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Receivers, Amps, and Processors › Official Denon AVP-A1HD/AVP-A1HDCI and POA-A1HD/POA-A1HDCI owners thread.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Official Denon AVP-A1HD/AVP-A1HDCI and POA-A1HD/POA-A1HDCI owners thread. - Page 53

post #1561 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

Im using this one Thor Powersmart which is used for all my gear but I want to dedicate on to the pre/pro.

http://www.thortechnologies.com.au/d...p?V_DOC_ID=792

I took a quick look at your link and they make some interesting products. Are they Aussie only? I've never seen them here and didn't notice anything on the site about international dealers/distributors.
post #1562 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

I think you're onto something Franin. Mine sounded great right out of the box, which is why my next step would be to go back to the factory settings and start over.

So did mine and have to say it's geting better! It's pissing down with rain at the moment over here and thunderstorms.Solution: everything Off!
post #1563 of 25091
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

I don't even use audyssey at all and find the music as well as the HT excel.I guess you might need to sit down and have a good play with it and hopefully reach the sound your after.I guess it's not for everyone, we all have different tastes when it come to what were after in sound.

I totally agree, I also find music and HT to sound spectacular! While some may say there is no such thing as burn in time for pre/pro's, I highly disagree. Mine sounded great right out of the box, but now it sounds freakin' awesome! I think zeejayzee needs to give it a bit more time.

Just for my own curiosity I compared optical to HDMI, and in my setup both sounded excellent! But if I absolutely had to pick, I'd say the HDMI edged it out ever so slightly. Overall the sound from both was pretty much a tie. I was using my dedicated Sony CD players optical out and my Denon Blu-ray Transports HDMI out for comparisons.


Seth
post #1564 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by ohyeah32 View Post

Just for my own curiosity I compared optical to HDMI, and in my setup both sounded excellent! But if I absolutely had to pick, I'd say the HDMI edged it out ever so slightly. Overall the sound from from both was pretty much a tie. I was using my dedicated Sony CD players optical out and my Denon Blu-ray Transports HDMI out for comparisons.

Seth

That's what I'd expect, Seth. In fact, I'd expect any difference in your comparison to be a function of the players. Wouldn't you think that a digital signal coming in, regardless whether it's HDMI or optical, would get processed exactly the same in the AVP (assuming identical settings)? I haven't read the technical details on this, but it just seems to make sense.
post #1565 of 25091
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

That's what I'd expect, Seth. In fact, I'd expect any difference in your comparison to be a function of the players. Wouldn't you think that a digital signal coming in, regardless whether it's HDMI or optical, would get processed exactly the same in the AVP (assuming identical settings)? I haven't read the technical details on this, but it just seems to make sense.

Yes you are totally correct, it shouldn't matter if it's optical, coax, HDMI, or Denon Link. The D/A conversion in the AVP will be the same. So being that zeejayzee is getting such a dramatic difference using optical over HDMI says that something isn't right. A difference in sound character (ie. bright, warm, neutral) between pre/pro's yes, but no easily discernible difference should be heard using any digital inputs.

Like was mentioned maybe a system reset might be what's needed. I don't know, but he should be getting some killer sound.
post #1566 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by ohyeah32 View Post

I totally agree, I also find music and HT to sound spectacular! While some may say there is no such thing as burn in time for pre/pro's, I highly disagree. Mine sounded great right out of the box, but now it sounds freakin' awesome! I think zeejayzee needs to give it a bit more time.

Just for my own curiosity I compared optical to HDMI, and in my setup both sounded excellent! But if I absolutely had to pick, I'd say the HDMI edged it out ever so slightly. Overall the sound from both was pretty much a tie. I was using my dedicated Sony CD players optical out and my Denon Blu-ray Transports HDMI out for comparisons.


Seth

Looking forward in getting my blu ray Transport in a couple of weeks!
post #1567 of 25091
Franin

are you near quennsland? my son went to bond university last semester.
he had the best time.
it only cost me 22k and i did get a nice boomerang.
i would love to visit don't know if i can handle the 23 hour flight.
he is very happy that i got the avp because now he gets my lexicon
post #1568 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by bschaen View Post

Franin

are you near quennsland? my son went to bond university last semester.
he had the best time.
it only cost me 22k and i did get a nice boomerang.
i would love to visit don't know if i can handle the 23 hour flight.
he is very happy that i got the avp because now he gets my lexicon

No the other side in Western Australia. Queensland is where the most action is they have Warner Bros etc and it's were most tourist go.Where we are it's a very quite city compared to the rest.Yes I went to europe to see my sister and the long flight did not agree with me either.You happy with the AVP? I love it.
post #1569 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by ohyeah32 View Post

Yes you are totally correct, it shouldn't matter if it's optical, coax, HDMI, or Denon Link. The D/A conversion in the AVP will be the same. So being that zeejayzee is getting such a dramatic difference using optical over HDMI says that something isn't right. A difference in sound character (ie. bright, warm, neutral) between pre/pro's yes, but no easily discernible difference should be heard using any digital inputs.

Like was mentioned maybe a system reset might be what's needed. I don't know, but he should be getting some killer sound.

It's crazy, but the HDMI sound was dramatically worse than the coax or optical. My buddy was over, he's a pro-audio exec, ran a BIG recording technology company, and assured me that HDMI was not baked yet as an audio spec. I told him he was wrong, that digital was digital, but he convinced me to try the difference and waddaya know, he was right about the sound quality. Crazy, never read a thing about this, but I'm convinced.

Alebonau may be correct in that my amp ain't up to the task. I understand that lots of people like their Outlaws, but how can a first-gen $900 amp stand up to B&W Nautilus speakers driven by a $7k proc? Of course again this could be wishful thinking, and the issue could be the AVP. My concern is that I'm going to chase the issue with a new amp, new high-end cables, etc. and still not love where I'm at.

One question I asked earlier was in regards to the balanced vs. unbalanced outputs. Is there any chance that the balanced sound a lot better? I'm running unbalanced, so could that be an issue?

All-in-all I'm bummed. I really want the Denon AVP to live up to its billing. I need a super-configurable controller for all of my family's needs, and an 'esoteric' premium 2-channel system for music listening. If I can have it all in one box it is easily worth $7k. If not I'm back to square one, and not even sure if I can return the AVP.

Is anyone on this board using the AVP with a sub-standard amp? Is anyone else on this board not 100% happy with the sound of the AVP? Should I be calling Denon asking for their rep to come over & listen to my system?
post #1570 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by zeejayzee View Post


One question I asked earlier was in regards to the balanced vs. unbalanced outputs. Is there any chance that the balanced sound a lot better? I'm running unbalanced, so could that be an issue?

Definitley give that a go!
post #1571 of 25091
HDMI sounding worse than Toslink makes absolutely no sense. The resolution and bandwidth requirements of the HDMI 1.3 standard alone should make it a certainty. I had a $500 Yamaha 663 here for a bit, it was 1.3, and frankly it didn't hold a back seat by much to anything I've heard prior. I definitely attributed that to HDMI 1.3.

Franin, you've go to give the Audyssey a go. If you're not to enamored with the thought of room EQ I believe the AVP gives you a "front" option where the Audyssey will not EQ your mains but will do the subs and surrounds. Audyssey's main strength is what it does for the bass frequencies - well worth a try IMO.
post #1572 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by rnrgagne View Post

HDMI sounding worse than Toslink makes absolutely no sense. The resolution and bandwidth requirements of the HDMI 1.3 standard alone should make it a certainty. I had a $500 Yamaha 663 here for a bit, it was 1.3, and frankly it didn't hold a back seat by much to anything I've heard prior. I definitely attributed that to HDMI 1.3.

Franin, you've go to give the Audyssey a go. If you're not to enamored with the thought of room EQ I believe the AVP gives you a "front" option where the Audyssey will not EQ your mains but will do the subs and surrounds. Audyssey's main strength is what it does for the bass frequencies - well worth a try IMO.

So how then do I describe the results?

Maybe - and I stress maybe - my DVD player is doing the D/A conversion (from a CD) and then sending the converted audio down the wire on the HDMI cable. It's a low-end DVD player, so my guess is the D/A converters are pure crap. In this case the whole thing would make sense, since I'd be comparing the analog outs of the DVD player to the AVP, which should smoke it.

However, the same held true for the Apple TV. When I switched the HDMI to Optical, the sound opened up. I can't imagine the Apple TV is doing D/A conversion internally.

BTW: On the DVD player, I sent the Optical to the AVP's CD input. So I can just toggle back-and-forth frokm CD input to DVD input and the same player is sending the same audio, and I can immediately hear the difference in inputs. Optical just kills the HDMI. As my buddy said, "it's like a whole new speaker system."

I'm going to keep tweaking and will report. I have a lot of lossless audio ready to test, I have an EQ ready to play with, and hopefully I can get the thing sounding right.

Again I ask: is there ANYONE on this board that has not been 100% happy with their AVP for music?
post #1573 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by zeejayzee View Post

It's crazy, but the HDMI sound was dramatically worse than the coax or optical. My buddy was over, he's a pro-audio exec, ran a BIG recording technology company, and assured me that HDMI was not baked yet as an audio spec. I told him he was wrong, that digital was digital, but he convinced me to try the difference and waddaya know, he was right about the sound quality. Crazy, never read a thing about this, but I'm convinced.

I don't question that you're having a problem with 2CH in your setup, but it seems a little premature to blame the whole HDMI spec for something that no other AVP users seem to be experiencing. It's true that HDMI is not fully "baked" in the sense that it is an evolving spec, but it's perfectly capable of conveying digital audio data, as evidenced by the millions of systems where it's probably doing exactly that at this very moment. Seth made the comparison you refer to and saw no real difference, and no one else has reported the problem either. Objectively, I really think the focus should remain on your particular AVP and setup.

Some posters have tried to offer suggestions here but you haven't responded to them yet. Specifically:
  • What 2CH source are inputting via HDMI?
  • Have you tried turning off Audyssey?
  • Have you tried resetting to factory defaults and starting over?
post #1574 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by rnrgagne View Post

HDMI sounding worse than Toslink makes absolutely no sense. The resolution and bandwidth requirements of the HDMI 1.3 standard alone should make it a certainty. I had a $500 Yamaha 663 here for a bit, it was 1.3, and frankly it didn't hold a back seat by much to anything I've heard prior. I definitely attributed that to HDMI 1.3.

Franin, you've go to give the Audyssey a go. If you're not to enamored with the thought of room EQ I believe the AVP gives you a "front" option where the Audyssey will not EQ your mains but will do the subs and surrounds. Audyssey's main strength is what it does for the bass frequencies - well worth a try IMO.

Will do mate once room treatment is done.I've paid for it and now waiting for delivery and a time with the HAA caliobrator.Once thats all done I will do it to top it off.I was told by my HAA calibritor recently it does fnish it off quite nicely.BTW what time is it your end guys? it's 2:44pm over here!
post #1575 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by zeejayzee View Post

Maybe - and I stress maybe - my DVD player is doing the D/A conversion (from a CD) and then sending the converted audio down the wire on the HDMI cable. It's a low-end DVD player, so my guess is the D/A converters are pure crap. In this case the whole thing would make sense, since I'd be comparing the analog outs of the DVD player to the AVP, which should smoke it.

However, the same held true for the Apple TV. When I switched the HDMI to Optical, the sound opened up. I can't imagine the Apple TV is doing D/A conversion internally.

BTW: On the DVD player, I sent the Optical to the AVP's CD input. So I can just toggle back-and-forth frokm CD input to DVD input and the same player is sending the same audio, and I can immediately hear the difference in inputs. Optical just kills the HDMI. As my buddy said, "it's like a whole new speaker system."

Two thoughts.
  • Some components will not output proper signals simultaneously through multiple outputs. From your description, it sounds like you are having your CD/DVD player and your Apple TV do exactly that in your testing. Disconnect the HDMI when outputting optical and vice versa. (I once tried to A/B test the component and HDMI output of my HD-TiVo, only to discover that the component signal was funky & unreliable if the HDMI cable was attached even only on the TiVo end.)
  • It sounds like you're a little unsure about what your source equipment is outputting. This is critical. Check each source's settings (and manual) to ensure that the players themselves treat these outputs the same.
Quote:


Again I ask: is there ANYONE on this board that has not been 100% happy with their AVP for music?

Like many others here, I've been with this thread from the start and this has not come up as an issue.
post #1576 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

BTW what time is it your end guys? it's 2:44pm over here!

It's midnight here in the Pacific Northwest! I forget where the dateline is- is it Saturday afternoon for you?
post #1577 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

It's midnight here in the Pacific Northwest! I forget where the dateline is- is it Saturday afternoon for you?

yes Im at work at the moment!
post #1578 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

yes Im at work at the moment!

On Saturday??? That supposed to be HT tweak & play day. Work should never interfere.

I'm sitting here watching David Letterman. Do you guys get him?
post #1579 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

On Saturday??? That supposed to be HT tweak & play day. Work should never interfere.

I'm sitting here watching David Letterman. Do you guys get him?

yes we do very late at night also! Unfortunaltey my day off is the Sunday and a day during the week.
post #1580 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

yes we do very late at night also! Unfortunaltey my day off is the Sunday and a day during the week.

Hey, I saw earlier that you're waiting for the Blu-Ray transport. I assume you mean the Denon 2500. I'm just curious to know whether it's replacing another BD player, and why you decided on that one?
post #1581 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

Hey, I saw earlier that you're waiting for the Blu-Ray transport. I assume you mean the Denon 2500. I'm just curious to know whether it's replacing another BD player, and why you decided on that one?

It's going to be a region A.I mainly watch all HD movies and I will be replacing my SD player.I will then have 2 region B and 2 region A and 2 HD DVD players.
post #1582 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

I will then have 2 region B and 2 region A and 2 HD DVD players.

Yikes. You'll have them all hooked up simultaneously?
post #1583 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

Yikes. You'll have them all hooked up simultaneously?

Yes, thats what 6 hdmi inputs are for! Love to know if Denon would be able to produce a BR player one day which can carry the new audio formats through the Denon Link.
post #1584 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

Yes, thats what 6 hdmi inputs are for! Love to know if Denon would be able to produce a BR player one day which can carry the new audio formats through the Denon Link.

I'm new to Denon with the AVP, so not terribly familiar with Denon link. I thought it was just a proprietary digital audio-only connection. What would be the advantage of carrying the audio signal over Denon Link versus HDMI?

It's late here. Will check for your response tomorrow.
post #1585 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by TripleTapper View Post

Here is what I currently use.

http://www.ultimateavmag.com/powerconditioners/1005apc/

Here's a rather humorous review thats definately geared more towards all of us here on AVS of the same unit - http://www.enjoythemusic.com/magazin...achapter82.htm

I have horrible power and the piece of mind that this gives me is worth every cent.

TripleTapper - I was very impressed with the two reviews you posted and with this product! thank you. It seems they only offer a US model though and not something that will work for us in the UK... Anyone knows of anything of the same high quality result that will work in the UK? What I liked very much about the product TripleTapper wrote about is that the reviews clearly showed it worked, it wasn't over hyped, the fact the screen shows the current incoming and used power is very cool, and the battery option is a great way to shut-down the system or avoid temp power outages. I'm craving one now that will work for me in the UK ...
post #1586 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

I'm new to Denon with the AVP, so not terribly familiar with Denon link. I thought it was just a proprietary digital audio-only connection. What would be the advantage of carrying the audio signal over Denon Link versus HDMI?

It's late here. Will check for your response tomorrow.

hi prog. denon link, like i-link that pio and sony used to use, is a jitter free conection which is unlike hdmi or coax/optical. the other benefit being a proprietory link is some other little niceties in use which I'm sure franin can let you know about as he has a 3930. denon link is particularly good for multichannel hdaudio eg dvda/sacd as dont need to worry about the vagaries of analog multichannel as its all handled over digital and jitter free.

I'm hoping one day denon does bring out a blu-ray player with denon link and dvd/sacd/dvda capability as their previous universal players used to. I'll just have to wait patiently till that comes
post #1587 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by alebonau View Post

hi prog. denon link, like i-link that pio and sony used to use, is a jitter free conection which is unlike hdmi or coax/optical. the other benefit being a proprietory link is some other little niceties in use which I'm sure franin can let you know about as he has a 3930. denon link is particularly good for multichannel hdaudio eg dvda/sacd as dont need to worry about the vagaries of analog multichannel as its all handled over digital and jitter free.

I'm hoping one day denon does bring out a blu-ray player with denon link and dvd/sacd/dvda capability as their previous universal players used to. I'll just have to wait patiently till that comes

As Al explained thats the good thing about it is it's a Jitter free connection.It's just pure audio that can handle anything and it's clean.
post #1588 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by progprog View Post

I'm new to Denon with the AVP, so not terribly familiar with Denon link. I thought it was just a proprietary digital audio-only connection. What would be the advantage of carrying the audio signal over Denon Link versus HDMI?

It's late here. Will check for your response tomorrow.

Good night mate, you will be up soon!
post #1589 of 25091
What exactally is the use of the Denon Link between the AVP and the POA? I thought it would turn the POA on when I turned on the AVP, but no deal.
post #1590 of 25091
Quote:
Originally Posted by nethomas View Post

What exactally is the use of the Denon Link between the AVP and the POA? I thought it would turn the POA on when I turned on the AVP, but no deal.

have you set the POA link on? in the AVP GUI: go into manual setup/option 1 and you will see a menu for POA
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Receivers, Amps, and Processors
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Receivers, Amps, and Processors › Official Denon AVP-A1HD/AVP-A1HDCI and POA-A1HD/POA-A1HDCI owners thread.