AVS › AVS Forum › Other Areas of Interest › Movies, Concerts, and Music Discussion › SD DVD NTSC vs PAL in UK
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

SD DVD NTSC vs PAL in UK

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
Say there were US TV shows recorded in standard definition NTSC.
Say they available on NTSC DVD and PAL DVD,
If you were in the UK and watching on a multiregion player to an LCD HDTV (or CRT), would the NTSC DVD usually give the best picture quality or might the PAL DVD be better in some ways?

What if you were watching them on an upconverting player to an LCD HDTV - would that make any difference (knowing that the version stored on PAL would be 576i and the NTSC 480i - even though originally they would have been recorded at 480i)?

I mean, 99% of UK TVs can probably playback NTSC, yet standard definition DVDs that were originally produced in the states are converted to PAL - is that catering to the 1% of UK TVs that might not be able to play it or will it genuinely give a better picture on UK TV's if converted to PAL? (ie. will it make scan lines less visible or be less flickery with the UK's 50hz electricity/lighting etc?)
post #2 of 7
For economies of scale most, if not all, LCD's are multi-region. The PAL DVD will provide the best video quality because it contains 576 scan lines vs 481 for NTSC. It is the same as comparing SD DVD to HD DVD.

Video quality is always about mathematics. The more scan lines the more detail the video will contain providing a superior picture.

For playback set the multi-region player to interlace, not progressive scan, to allow the LCD to up-convert the 576 to whatever its native resolution is, 720P, 768P, 1080i.
post #3 of 7
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ernie6 View Post

For economies of scale most, if not all, LCD's are multi-region. The PAL DVD will provide the best video quality because it contains 576 scan lines vs 481 for NTSC. It is the same as comparing SD DVD to HD DVD.

Yes, but I'm talking about US TV shows (before they started recording on HDTV cameras - that will have been recorded on NTSC video cameras at 480i and 60hz), that are available in the UK on PAL (576i discs) but can also be bought on NTSC DVDs.

I mean, converting to PAL would reduce the frame rate, but might give less compression per frame and might possibly give more of the original colours?? (eg. more lines/samples of the original stored? not too sure about that though).

I think it might make a difference too if you were watching on an LCD HDTV versus CRT (chances are LCD HDTV's would be more capable of displaying NTSC colour ranges maybe than CRT TVs which might convert to PAL 60 which wouldn't show the true NTSC colours?)
post #4 of 7
Some depends on whether the show was shot on film or video, 24fps vs 30fps. Hopefully the DVD was encoded/converted decently regardless of the original format and playing the DVD "natively" is your best bet. I wouldn't take a PAL DVD made from a US show shot as NTSC and play it converted back to NTSC - even though it may work just fine. Getting the R1 NTSC DVD for a US show and playing it as NTSC is probably the "safest" way. Just like I do for UK TV shows - I buy the PAL DVDs and play them as PAL. Also, PAL and NTSC have no color issues going back and forth between the two with digital video.

larry
post #5 of 7
Thread Starter 
Thanks for your help. So in general US TV shows shot on NTSC cameras at 480i should look the best on NTSC SD-DVDs rather than PAL ones.

It's a shame there isn't a site that lists all US TV shows and displays how they were recorded (eg. on 480i 60hz cameras which would look the best on NTSC SD-DVDs or on film cameras which might look better on PAL DVD (except for the speed-up vs judder issue) in PAL land - and imdb.com doesn't always show that info).

Still it should be less of an issue with TV shows on Blu-ray (recorded on film or HD video cameras). Though chances are they'll be more likely to always use 24p instead of 60i/p
post #6 of 7
I've never seen a PAL DVD of a US TV show so I can't really comment. The PAL DVD might look just fine.

larry
post #7 of 7
The sound is therefore different with the frame rate speed up. When comparing NTSC laserdisc to PAL laserdisc or NTSC laserdisc to PAL region 2 DVD.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Other Areas of Interest › Movies, Concerts, and Music Discussion › SD DVD NTSC vs PAL in UK