Obviously you have a more critical eye than I, and one I respect immensely, but at least you admit there is a baby in this particular bathtub.
Some are saying it's trash. I just hope enough people buy this BD to warrant double dipping us down the road.
This will sound stupid but men in my family die young and I'm just happy to have seen this version of Patton. May be the best I ever see it look.
Yes, no doubt it looks very good. I don't want my negative comments to come across as saying stay clear but only that I feel that a careful loving eye at the switch could have done better than we got.
I'm 53 so I hope I will see a better version that transferred the film, in tact, to a medium I can play in my home.